Skills tests linked to class participation (performed during lab time)
Group project: 20% of the final grade; largest component of the lab
Group project goal: conduct a plant science experiment in a group setting
The instructor emphasizes early planning and group selection; groups are student-chosen and not assigned
The Group Project
You must do a plant science experiment within a group
Group size guidelines:
Recommended: 2–3 people
Maximum: 4 people
Occasionally a student may work alone if others drop
Groups are formed by the students themselves
The project is designed to be challenging and requires care for living plants (they die if neglected)
You will decide what plant-based experiment to run, taking into account seasonal timing and plant needs
Seasonal considerations: fall, changing seasons, temperature changes affect plant growth and survival
Plant selections discussed include warm-season vs cool-season grasses:
Bermuda grass = warm-season
Ryegrass = cool-season
Timing and environment matter: choose plants appropriate to the season and climate window
The project demands planning ahead to avoid last-minute, one-night efforts (e.g., growing plants in a dorm room overnight is not realistic)
The group must plan for potential disasters (e.g., weather, pests) and discuss contingencies
Project can involve a variety of activities: plant growth, germination tests, soil sampling, fertilizer recommendations, plant identification, etc.
Weather dependence: labs may shift order based on weather; flexibility is expected
Planning and Time Management
Procrastination is discouraged due to plant growth requirements
Students should anticipate the time it takes for plants to grow or produce results
The instructor highlights the need to plan what to study and test early in the semester
The concept of “disasters” in experiments (e.g., pests) is acknowledged; plan for contingencies
Plant Growth and Environmental Considerations
Plants depend on humans for survival in many cases, and humans depend on plants for food and resources
As seasons change, some plants will die while others will begin to grow; timing is critical for the experiment
Plant environment compatibility is essential: use species suited to the given season and facilities
The instructor notes personal experience with gardening and uses it to illustrate planning and care requirements
Group Formation Rules
Groups are student-chosen rather than assigned by the instructor
Size guidelines reiterated:
2–3 preferred; up to 4 may be acceptable
Sometimes a student ends up alone if others drop
You should decide who works in your group and who does the tasks
The instructor will not assign groups
What is a Scientific Experiment? The Scientific Method
Purpose: solve a problem using scientific inquiry
Steps of scientific inquiry/experimental process:
Identify the problem or question
Do background research
Form a hypothesis (educated guess)
Test the hypothesis by conducting an experiment or study
Analyze the data
Draw a conclusion
Report results
Big-picture goal: address problems relevant to agriculture, e.g., how to feed a growing population with limited resources
The process is iterative and aims to derive plausible descriptions consistent with data from experiments
Controlled experiments are emphasized as the most reliable way to obtain information for decision making
Formulating a Hypothesis
Definition: an educated guess about how the dependent variable will respond to changes in the independent variable
Key points:
The hypothesis should be testable
Avoid questions you already know the answer to
Do not use first-person pronouns like "I" in the hypothesis
Example: The rate of reaction R↑ when T↑. (Rate increases with temperature)
If the hypothesis is not proven by the experiment, explain why in the conclusion
Do not change the hypothesis after starting the experiment; if new insights arise, you may start a different experiment but keep the original hypothesis fixed for the current study
The instructor notes that occasionally surprising or novel discoveries can occur, but emphasize documenting the rationale and results
Experimental Design: Variables, Controls, and Groups
Independent variable (IV): the variable intentionally changed to test its effect (e.g., amount of fertilizer, type of fertilizer, or presence of diesel exhaust fluid)
Dependent variable (DV): the measured outcome that responds to the IV (e.g., plant height, biomass, germination rate)
Constants: factors kept the same across all treatments to avoid confounding effects (e.g., same soil type, same light exposure, same watering schedule, etc.)
Control group: standard or baseline treatment used for comparison (e.g., plants with no fertilizer or no DEF)
Experimental group: the group(s) where the IV is applied/altered
Replication: multiple experimental units within each treatment to improve reliability
Randomization: place treatment units randomly to avoid positional effects and biases
Blocking: group units into blocks to control for known sources of variation (e.g., shade or soil differences)
Example discussion: a ryegrass growth experiment with shade and soil type as blocks
A note on common misuse: failing to rotate plants or failing to keep constants truly constant can undermine validity
Reliability and Validity
Reliability: if the procedure is followed, the same results should be obtained when repeated by someone else
Internal validity: the degree to which the experiment actually tests the intended variable and yields trustworthy results
External validity: the extent to which laboratory results translate to real-world settings
The instructor uses examples (e.g., plants near a window grew taller due to more sunlight) to illustrate threats to internal validity and the need for proper controls
In some introductory labs, external validity may be of secondary concern, but internal validity and replicability are critical
Designing the Experiment and Procedure
Start with a clear purpose statement describing what you want to find out; be specific
Preliminary research and literature review are encouraged before finalizing the design
Example purpose: "What are the effects of diesel exhaust fluid on the growth and height of ryegrass?" (DEF described as water and urea; urea is a fertilizer)
Independent variable identification: specify what will be changed (e.g., presence/absence of DEF, or DEF concentration)
Dependent variable identification: specify what will be measured (e.g., plant height in cm, biomass)
Measurement plan: the change in the variable must be measurable and quantifiable
Procedure: present step-by-step methods (bullet points preferred) so that another researcher can replicate the experiment
The number of trials: typically 3–4 (n = 3 to 4)
Data type: aim for quantitative data (numerical measurements) rather than vague qualitative judgments
Example: a fertilizer treatment with a specific rate (e.g., 50extlb/acre) to connect with practical farming decisions
Hypothesis testing in practice: may yield demonstrated results or not; include discussion of results and limitations in the conclusion
Discussion of potential discipline-specific measurement strategies: e.g., height, leaf number, biomass, germination rate, etc.
Avoid vague language such as "+> more green"; strive for objective, measurable outcomes
The instructor emphasizes the importance of economic relevance when possible (e.g., yield or cost implications)
Data, Analysis, and Conclusion
Data can be qualitative or quantitative, but quantitative data is preferred for clarity and replicability
In this course, statistics are noted but not required to perform extensive statistical analysis
When presenting results, include a conclusion that restates the problem, the hypothesis, and the data analysis
Explain the reasoning behind whether the hypothesis was supported or refuted
Acknowledge any mistakes or limitations encountered in the lab and discuss potential sources of error
If issues like pests (e.g., fall armyworms) affect results, report them and consider how to proceed (e.g., restarting or adjusting the design)
The conclusion should reflect whether the experiment was reliable and valid, and propose possible improvements for future runs
Practical Examples Discussed in Class
Hay analysis (Skills Test): order hay from highest to lowest quality
Criteria: Total Digestible Nutrients (TDN) and protein content
Example ranges encountered: TDN≈60%; Protein≈18%; historically, protein around 14%–18% depending on management and season
Highest-nutrient/higher-protein hay is valuable for animal nutrition; differences can be due to maturity, fertilizer, and harvest practices
The concept of nitrogen and protein in hay:
Nitrogen content influences protein level in hay
A protein is described in class as a "carbohydrate with nitrogen" (not chemically exact, but this is how it was presented)
Other activities mentioned for the lab: soil samples, fertilizer recommendations, germination tests, plant identification, and seasonal plant trials
Weather dependence and real-world constraints impact lab planning and outcomes
Additional Concepts and Anecdotes
The instructor emphasizes the broader goal of agricultural science: producing more with less to feed a growing population
The role of weather, soil type, shade, and moisture as factors that complicate ecological experiments
The difference between controlled experiments (artificially controlled environments) and ecological/field studies (more complex variables)
The importance of documenting errors and acknowledging unforeseen events (e.g., pests) in the final report
The importance of clarity and reproducibility in the written procedure; the grader will assess whether another person can repeat the experiment and obtain similar results
Some light humor and storytelling to illustrate concepts (e.g., group dynamics, common misinterpretations) used to reinforce key points, not to replace formal content
Key Formulas and Notable Values
Hypothesized relationship: Rate of reaction↑⟺T↑
Example fertilizer rate: 50lb/acre
Group size constraints (guidance):
Recommended: 2≤n≤3
Maximum: n≤4
Trials:n=3 to 4
Hay quality indicators:
TDN≈60%
Protein≈18% (range often 14%–18% depending on factors)
Variable definitions (summary):
Independent Variable: the variable intentionally changed by the investigator
Dependent Variable: the measured outcome
Constants: factors kept the same across all treatments
Control Group: baseline for comparison
Experimental Group: receives the treatment/IV
Quick Reminders for Exam Preparation
Always define independent, dependent, constants, control, and experimental groups clearly in your design
Plan for replication and randomization to strengthen reliability
Strive for quantitative data when possible; connect results to practical, real-world implications (economics, yield, etc.)
Be prepared to discuss internal and external validity and how you would address threats to validity in your own experiment
Prepare to articulate a testable hypothesis in third person and explain the rationale in your conclusion
Be ready to describe potential sources of error and how you would mitigate them in future iterations