ch1t

Economic Theories/Models Outline

• Economic Theories

  • Definition: An economic theory is a model used to explain observed economic facts.

  • Model Composition: Two components of a theory are:

    • Assumptions: Statements like "If something is true..."

    • Predictions: Statements like "then something else will happen."

    • Example: Law of Demand - If price is cut, demand will increase.

Simplifying Assumptions

• Economic models rely on simplifying assumptions due to the complexity of the real world.

• The vastness of details (e.g., even extensive media cannot capture full reality) makes simplifications necessary.

• Example: Snapshots like a California winery's production provide limited insight into price impacts on wine consumption.

Reality vs. Modeling

• Orson Welles's quote, "We sell no wine before its time," highlights the economic principle of aging affecting price.

• Economic models must focus on observable, verifiable, and replicable data.

• The essential aspects analyzed depend on the analysis's purpose, indicating the need for simplifying assumptions:

  • No uncertainty regarding factors like price and rainfall.

  • Homogeneous consumer tastes.

  • Assumption of one product despite multiple producers.

• The justification for simplified, often unrealistic assumptions is to focus on relevant issues while omitting insignificant details.

• Economists prefer simple models for ease of understanding, communication, and data testing.

Criticisms of Economic Models

• Two common criticisms include:

  1. Oversimplification leading to misleading results.

  2. Unrealistic assumptions that may not reflect true conditions.

• Remark 1: Starting with a simple model is beneficial for testing predictions before adding complexity.

Milton Friedman and Simplification

• Milton Friedman's perspective on hypotheses:

  • Importance lies in their descriptively false assumptions to enable broader analysis using simplified models.

  • Example: Representing a wine producer's output incorporates capital input and labor without real consumers' variances.

• Simplification is essential as it allows for manageable analysis rather than overwhelming complexity.

• Cost-effectiveness in information gathering is achieved through simpler models requiring less data.

Ceteris Paribus (Other Things Equal)

• The concept of Ceteris Paribus indicates holding other factors constant when analyzing the effects of a policy change.

• In policy decisions (e.g., tax cuts), isolating the effects on employment while excluding other variables is critical.

• Example: Increasing working hours leads to more output only if efficiency remains constant.

Real-World Implications of Ceteris Paribus

• Not always realistic; notable historical example:

  • During the 1940 Battle of Britain, Britain faced labor shortages and increased working hours, initially boosting output.

  • However, prolonged hours led to worker fatigue, decreased efficiency, and increased errors, demonstrating the limitations of the Ceteris Paribus assumption.

  • Eventually, the government capped working hours to maintain productivity without sacrificing worker safety.

• Conclusion: In real predictive scenarios, while we assume other things constant, human behavior and attention span complicate outcomes.