Logical Fallacies Group C
Informal Logic Fallacies C – focus on specific general or part-whole relationships (the sum is great than its parts)
Group C – Accident/Exception
This occurs when accidental factors are overlooked while arguing that a general rule should be applied – when should a general rule NOT be applied
E.g. Lying is wrong. When Liz lied to her mother about how her hair looked, she acted immorally despite wanting to protect her mother from the ugly facts
Group C – Hasty Generalization
This occurs when an argument overlooks certain features when connecting to the general/whole argument
E.g. Matt was allowed to hand in his assignment late because he had surgery the day before. So everyone else should be able to hand in their assignment late
Sufficient evidence/reason must be provided in order to make an argument cogent
An argument cannot generalize based on limited data/exception to a general rule
Group C - Composition
This occurs when the whole may not be greater than the sum of its parts, but it can certainly be different
E.g. The brain may have features of consciousness, but individual neurons do not
Each part of the body has a function, but this does not mean that the body has a function as a whole
Parts of the argument may not match parts of the whole
Group C - Decomposition
This occurs when a feature of the whole argument is erroneously applied to parts of the argument
E.g. Suppose that, in total, more gasoline is consumed by cars than by trucks. We could not use this to conclude that a particular car uses more gasoline than a particular truck.
This attributes a feature of the whole to the parts
Logical Fallacies Group C
Informal Logic Fallacies C – focus on specific general or part-whole relationships (the sum is great than its parts)
Group C – Accident/Exception
This occurs when accidental factors are overlooked while arguing that a general rule should be applied – when should a general rule NOT be applied
E.g. Lying is wrong. When Liz lied to her mother about how her hair looked, she acted immorally despite wanting to protect her mother from the ugly facts
Group C – Hasty Generalization
This occurs when an argument overlooks certain features when connecting to the general/whole argument
E.g. Matt was allowed to hand in his assignment late because he had surgery the day before. So everyone else should be able to hand in their assignment late
Sufficient evidence/reason must be provided in order to make an argument cogent
An argument cannot generalize based on limited data/exception to a general rule
Group C - Composition
This occurs when the whole may not be greater than the sum of its parts, but it can certainly be different
E.g. The brain may have features of consciousness, but individual neurons do not
Each part of the body has a function, but this does not mean that the body has a function as a whole
Parts of the argument may not match parts of the whole
Group C - Decomposition
This occurs when a feature of the whole argument is erroneously applied to parts of the argument
E.g. Suppose that, in total, more gasoline is consumed by cars than by trucks. We could not use this to conclude that a particular car uses more gasoline than a particular truck.
This attributes a feature of the whole to the parts
