In-depth Notes on International Politics: Geographies of War and Peace
Nuremberg-type Criminal Tribunals
- Transitional Justice Mechanisms: Aimed at addressing injustices to promote reconciliation and healing in post-conflict societies.
- Peace as Individual Accountability: Focusing on holding individuals responsible for their actions during conflicts.
- Peace as Victims' Rights: Emphasizes the right of victims to truth, justice, reparations, and guarantees of non-recurrence.
- Concepts:
- Retributive Justice: Focused primarily on punishing perpetrators of crimes.
- Restorative Justice: Concentrates on healing for victims and society, advocating for dialogue and understanding.
- Established through various means such as international treaties, UN Security Council resolutions, or multilateral agreements.
- Can be domestically driven, allowing for adaptations based on local contexts.
Peacemaking
- Definition: Involves diplomatic actions to mediate ongoing conflicts and facilitate negotiations to achieve peace.
- Can involve various actors such as envoys, governments, states, and organizations including the UN.
- Includes unofficial entities or individuals acting independently to resolve conflicts.
Peacekeeping
- Purpose: To stop or limit violence and maintain peace in regions affected by conflict.
- Key Activities: Involves deploying international personnel to:
- Monitor ceasefires.
- Protect civilians.
- Support the implementation of peace agreements.
- Functions as a neutral third party to help maintain peace on the ground.
Peacebuilding
- Definition: Refers to long-term efforts aimed at addressing the underlying causes of conflicts and promoting sustainable peace and reconciliation.
- Activities Included:
- Transitional justice mechanisms.
- Disarmament, Demobilization, Reintegration (DDR) programs.
- Post-war reconciliation initiatives.
Comparison of Terms
Peacemaking:
Focus: Ending active conflicts.
Main Activities: Negotiation and mediation.
Examples:
- Oslo Accords (1993)
- Dayton Accords (1995)
- Kenya post-election mediation (2008)
Peacekeeping:
Focus: Maintaining peace on the ground.
Main Activities: Deploying neutral forces, monitoring ceasefires.
Examples:
- UNFICYP (Cyprus)
- MONUSCO (DRC)
- UNMISS (South Sudan)
Peacebuilding:
Focus: Sustaining long-term peace after conflict.
Main Activities: Rebuilding institutions and addressing root causes.
Examples:
- Gacaca Courts (Rwanda)
- DDR programs (Liberia)
- FARC reintegration (Colombia)
Conflict Stages and Intervention
- Stages:
- Escalation
- Rapprochement
- De-escalation
- Post-conflict
- Intervention Levels:
- Prevention
- Containment
- Negotiation
- Maintenance
Assumptions of Post-Conflict Peacebuilding
- Conceptual Framework:
- Peace is a linear process.
- Peacebuilding inherently benefits all civilians.
- Western liberal peace models are universally applicable and effective.
- Institutional reform leads to sustainable peace.
- Top-down approaches dominate as they are perceived as having better solutions.