A Bronsted-Lowry acid is a proton donor.
A Bronsted-Lowry base is a proton acceptor.
Let's review what a proton is:
A neutral hydrogen atom (most common isotope) contains:
One proton in the nucleus
One electron outside the nucleus
Removing the electron leaves only the proton (the nucleus of a hydrogen atom), which is equivalent to H+.
When dealing with Bronsted-Lowry definitions, think about one proton (H+) difference between the acid and base.
HCl donates a proton to water.
A lone pair of electrons on the oxygen in water picks up the proton. The electron from hydrogen is left behind and goes to the chlorine.
Products:
Hydronium ion (H3O+): The oxygen is now bonded to three hydrogens, giving it a +1 formal charge. The two electrons from the oxygen form the new bond with the proton.
Chloride anion (Cl−): Chlorine gains an additional lone pair, giving it a negative charge.
Therefore:
HCl is a Bronsted-Lowry acid because it donates a proton.
Water is a Bronsted-Lowry base because it accepts a proton.
Let's think about the possibility of the reverse reaction in the previous example.
The chloride anion (Cl−) would have to function as a base and pick up a proton from the hydronium ion (H3O+).
Cl− is the conjugate base to HCl.
H3O+ functions as an acid. This would be the conjugate acid to water.
A conjugate acid-base pair consists of two substances that differ by one proton (H+H+).
Acid | Conjugate Base |
---|---|
HCl | Cl− |
H2O | H3O+ |
A Lewis acid is an electron pair acceptor.
A good way to remember this is with the mnemonic device Acid and electron pair Acceptor
A Lewis base is an electron pair donor.
A good way to remember this is with the mnemonic device Lewis Base, if you flip the B you get a D for electron pair Donor
Boron in BF3 does not have an octet (only six electrons around it).
Boron is sp^2 hybridized, meaning it has an empty p orbital that can accept a pair of electrons. Therefore, BF3 functions as a Lewis acid.
Water (H2O) has a lone pair of electrons on the oxygen that it can donate. Therefore, water functions as a Lewis base.
The lone pair of electrons on oxygen is donated into the empty p orbital of boron, forming a bond between the oxygen and the boron.
This gives the oxygen a +1 formal charge and the boron a -1 formal charge.
There is no H+ transfer in this reaction, so the Bronsted-Lowry definition does not apply.
The Lewis definition is broader than the Bronsted-Lowry definition and can be applied to reactions where there is no H+ transfer.
Water can be a Lewis base: Water can donate a pair of electrons.
HCl can be a source of a Lewis acid: The proton (H+) accepts a pair of electrons.