Reconstruction

Reconstruction Overview

  • Post-Civil War challenges: 3.5 million freed slaves without money, property, or direction.

  • Questions of real freedom: land ownership, legal equality, versus the desire of Southern whites for a return to antebellum life, regional autonomy, and white supremacy.

  • Role of the Federal government: military presence to protect freed blacks, establishment of the Freedmen’s Bureau, but its effectiveness is questioned.

Alternate Plans for Reconstruction

Lincoln’s 10% Plan

  • Implemented a lenient policy for Southern reconstruction.

  • Offered general amnesty to white Southerners (some exceptions exist).

  • Required an oath of loyalty from 10% of voters in a state for readmission.

  • Mandated acceptance of abolition of slavery.

  • Proposed extending suffrage to educated black men who owned property or served in the Union Army.

  • By 1864, three Southern states (Louisiana, Arkansas, and Tennessee) had loyal governments.

Radical Republicans

  • Aimed for total abolition and protection of black civil rights.

  • Advocated for confiscating property from white Southerners; land distributions to blacks.

  • Conservatives called for abolition alone without further measures.

  • Radicals pushed for the Wade-Davis Bill, countering Lincoln’s leniency.

Wade-Davis Bill

  • Required majority of white males to pledge allegiance to the Union.

  • Each state would appoint a provisional governor.

  • States needed to hold constitutional conventions, with delegates elected by those not involved in the rebellion.

  • New state constitutions had to abolish slavery, disenfranchise Confederate leaders, and repudiate war debts.

  • Lincoln used a pocket veto to block this bill.

Johnson and Reconstruction

  • Andrew Johnson’s presidency marks a turn in Reconstruction policy.

  • He was pro-Union but had Southern sympathies.

  • Proposed a plan for "Restoration" combining elements of Lincoln’s and the Wade-Davis Plan.

  • Appointment of provisional governors in states; conventions to revoke secession ordinances, abolish slavery, and ratify the 13th Amendment.

  • Offered amnesty for most Southerners who would swear allegiance, excluding high-ranking officials.

  • Growing frustration in the North as the South resisted abolition and black suffrage.

Radical Reconstruction Measures

Congressional Actions

  • In December 1865, Congress refused to seat representatives from restored Southern governments.

  • Southern state legislatures enacted Black Codes (1865-1886) restricting black freedoms.

  • These Codes allowed arresting unemployed blacks, imposing fines for vagrancy, and limited employment options.

  • Congressional response included the expansion of the Freedmen’s Bureau and the Civil Rights Act of 1866.

    • This Act declared blacks as citizens and empowered federal intervention in civil rights matters.

  • Johnson vetoed both measures, but Congress overrode his vetoes.

Reconstruction Bills of 1867

  • Radicals dominated Congress and passed three Reconstruction Bills in early 1867.

  • Tennessee admitted after ratifying the 14th Amendment; other Confederate states’ Lincoln-Johnson governments were rejected.

  • Established five military districts overseen by military commanders.

  • Required newly registered voters to elect conventions guaranteeing black suffrage and ratification of the 14th Amendment.

  • Required congressional approval of new state constitutions.

Congressional Control and Tensions

Tenure of Office Act

  • Restricted the President from removing officials without Senate consent (notably, Secretary of War Edwin Stanton).

  • Command of the Army Act mandated presidential orders go through the commanding general of the army.

  • Ex parte Milligan ruled military tribunals unconstitutional when civil courts were available.

Impeachment of Johnson

  • Johnson removed Stanton and appointed General Lorenzo Thomas, leading to impeachment but narrowly avoiding removal from office.

Life in the South Post-Civil War

  • Scalawags and Carpetbaggers: terms used to describe Southern whites who supported Reconstruction and Northern transplants, respectively.

  • Freed black men became prominent in Republican politics.

  • Improvements in education: by 1876, over half of white children and 40% of black children attended public schools.

  • Segregated schools aimed to maintain racial norms; sharecropping was the dominant labor system as most blacks and many whites didn’t own land.

  • Crop lien system disadvantages for many farmers: lack of credit availability and predatory lending led to land loss during poor crop years.

Election of 1868 and Grantism

  • Ulysses S. Grant was elected, benefitting from black voter support.

  • Despite inexperience, Grant’s administration was noted for corruption and reliance on the spoils system.

  • Secured election even after primary challenges from Horace Greeley and “liberal republicans.”

Panic of 1873

  • Led to economic downturn and domestic challenges; the government passed the Specie Resumption Act in 1875 to stabilize currency.

Challenges to Reconstruction Efforts

  • Midterms of 1874 saw Democrats regain control of the House; intimidation tactics (KKK) influenced black voter turnout.

  • Some landowners refused services to Republicans; the Panic of 1873 frustrated Reconstruction efforts.

  • Enforcement Acts (1870-1871) aimed to protect voters but were weakly enforced.

  • In 1876, a contested election between Rutherford B. Hayes and Samuel Tilden led to a special congressional commission declaring Hayes the winner.

Compromise of 1877

  • Resulted in Hayes's presidency through concessions: appointment of Southern cabinet members, local control of federal patronage, internal improvements, and removal of federal troops from the South.

  • Marked the end of Reconstruction and the beginning of the Jim Crow era.

Legacy and Industrialization

  • The post-Reconstruction South dealt with economic disparities between races and class struggles.

  • Redeemers emerged, advocating for industrial growth at the expense of public schooling.

  • Industrial progress lagged behind the North; the South remained at 40% of Northern income levels.

Atlanta Compromise

  • Proposed by Booker T. Washington who founded the Tuskegee Institute; emphasized economic advancement for blacks, postponing demands for social equality.

Jim Crow Laws

  • Established a system of segregation and disenfranchisement, exemplified by Plessy v. Ferguson (1896) and other legal challenges.

  • Restrictions included poll taxes, literacy tests, and unjust practices leading to a 62% decline in black voter participation.

  • Enforced racial separation in all aspects of public life.

  • Widespread violence against blacks persisted, including lynching, with activists like Ida B. Wells bringing awareness to these issues.

robot