Feminism, The Body, And The Machine by Wendell Berry
Feminism, The Body, And The Machine
Introduction
- The author's refusal to buy a computer led to numerous critical responses, primarily focusing on his perceived insensitivity to technological advancements.
- Only a small fraction of the received letters were supportive (3 out of 20).
- The author expresses surprise at the intensity of the attacks and acknowledges the existence of a significant number of people who share his views.
Critique of Negative Letters
- Most negative letters lacked intelligence and were primarily emotional.
- One intelligent response questioned if there was any work better than Dante's, which was written on a Royal standard typewriter.
- Other responses accused the author of self-righteousness and prioritizing moral purity over ecological concerns.
Feminist Criticism
- Feminist letters accused the author of exploiting his wife, based on the fact that she types his manuscripts and provides feedback.
- The author argues that his essay does not provide any basis for this accusation, as it doesn't detail his wife's motives, workload, or compensation.
- The accusation relies on a flimsy syllogism: his wife helps him, some wives have been exploited, therefore his wife is exploited.
- This is considered an unjust conviction based on a general indictment rather than specific, provable accusations.
Marriage and Household
- The author laments that modern marriage is often seen as a negotiation of rights and interests or a short-term "relationship" between careerists.
- He contrasts this with marriages where couples see themselves as belonging to each other and sharing resources and responsibilities.
- The modern household is often a place of consumption rather than production, relying on external energy and technology suppliers.
- The author values a productive household economy where both partners contribute skills and industry, leading to economic independence and common satisfaction.
The Value of Home Employment
- The author believes that it is equally important for men and women to prioritize making their marriage and household.
- He emphasizes the importance of children having daily associations with both parents and seeing them at work.
- The work done at home should have economic value and contribute to the family's well-being.
- He questions the assumption that working away from home is inherently more desirable or liberating.
Questioning