Chapter 10: Presentational Speaking: Cultural Comparison
Exam Section II, Task 4
Comparing Cultures
- Fast-paced exercise- only takes 6 minutes
- It will allow you to use language to convey a cultural and authentic message based on products, practices, and perspectives, using what you have learned about the French-speaking world.
- To get a 5 in this category, you need to be culturally savvy and able to compare without judging.
Product, Practice, Perspective
- The Three Ps will help you organize your response and make a valid and interesting comparison
- An example- Tou are asked about the use of coffee in the US and France:
- The Product is coffee
- The Practice- in the US it is consumed in the mornings (in your home, in the car…), there are different flavors- add details
- compare the different cultures- accentuate the french way of living
- The Perspective- what do these practices tell us about cultures?- you could add negative and positive points
}}The comparisons are derived from the 6 themes of the curriculum:}}
- }}Families in Different Societies}}
- }}The Influence of Language and Culture on Identity}}
- }}Influences of Beauty and Art}}
- }}How Science and Technology Affect Our Lives}}
- }}Factors That Impact the Quality of Life}}
- }}Environmental, Political, and Societal Challenges}}
Strategies and Tips
Get beyond the Superficial
- Explain what the practice tells you about the people
- Do not assume that your listeners know a lot about the topic
- Be explicit- use examples, think about the research that you have done already
Jot Down Your Ideas
- You have 4 minutes to create a ^^draft^^
- DO NOT make a list for each culture- It is not a comparison unless you specifically say how they differ and how they are similar
- Fill out the chart given to you on page 326
Step A: The Introduction
- 15 seconds max (out of 2 mins)
- Specify the two communities you are going to compare
- Use these sentences:
}}L’idée du/de la/de l’___ est vue similairement en/au ___ et en/au.}}
}}Le thème du/de la/de l’ est vu différemment en/au _ et en/au.}}
}}Je vais vous parler du/de la/de l’ en/au + name of country et dans ma communauté des États-Unis.}}
Step B: The Comparison
1 min 30 seconds
The comparison has to be well balanced
You should be talking and advancing your argument- elaborate and be explicit
Explain what the cultural perspective demonstrates
Use the words of tranisition (same or different comparison)
\n
Step C: The Conclusion
- 15 seconds
- Add anything you forgot to say and then wrap up.
- Examples of a concluding sentence:
- Et donc, je voulais dire que la grande différence entre ___ et ___ c’est ___.
- Et donc, on remarque qu’en fait en/au ___ et en/au __, c’est pareil au niveau de ____.
Scoring Guidelines: [https://apcentral.collegeboard.org/pdf/ap19-sg-french-language.pdf]()