7.1 Interviewing Children

Introduction to Interviewing Children
  • Child's Perspective: Crucial to understand; children often perceive adults as enormous (trousers/skirts, not faces).

  • Reliability: Key concern is the reliability of young children's answers.

  • Language: Essential to use appropriate language for effective communication.

The Interview Situation: Physical Environment and Poise
  • Putting Yourself at the Child's Level:

    • Physically & Seating: Crucial to be at child's physical level (e.g., sit in child's chair for comfort).

    • Attire: Avoid restrictive clothing (e.g., tight skirts) for ease of movement.

  • Arranging the Physical Conditions:

    • Privacy & Comfort: Ensure quiet, private, comfortable setting with no interruptions.

    • Decorations: Minimize distractions; avoid busy décor, bright colors are fine.

    • Furniture: Child-suitable (strong, low); table should be appropriate height for materials, sturdy, safe, non-toxic.

    • Equipment: Store out of sight when not in use.

Engaging the Child: Activities During Interviews
  • Activities: Often used as adjuncts (e.g., research testing, clinical interviews, projective tests with pictures/dolls).

  • Purpose: Activities anchor questioning, integral to interview, not just distractions.

  • Examples: Videos, cartoons, plasticine, crayons, drawing paper.

  • Rapport: Maintain rapport; don't abruptly remove activities when questioning starts.

Communicating with Children: Language and Speech Style
  • Speech Style: Adults adapt speech for children (Brown, 1973), from baby talk to simplified vocabulary/syntax.

  • Grammar: By 5 years, basic grammar is typically acquired.

  • Appropriate Language:

    • Clear, plain, avoiding long/complex sentences.

    • Ask one simple question at a time; avoid rhetorical questions.

    • Check word meanings.

    • Adapt to individual language skills; use introductory stages to gauge level.

Children's Memory and Understanding
  • Concerns: Reliability vs. adults, suggestibility by leading questions/power dynamics.

  • Cognitive Development: Less cognitive development can lead to errors, but not always.

  • Age Influence: Age is not the greatest factor in changing testimony due to leading questions (Dent, 1992).

  • Long-Term Memory: Young children remember past experiences well, especially with prior knowledge (Gordon, Baker-Ward, & Ornstein, 2001).

  • Accuracy: Children over 3 provide accurate accounts if interviewed nonsuggestively (Gordon, Baker-Ward, & Ornstein, 2001).

  • Resistance: Younger children's naivete can help them resist influence more than adults (who are more socially aware).

  • Reliability: Young children's memory can be highly reliable, even against leading questions.

Children's Imagination
  • Benefit: Imagination is valuable, especially for story-based responses to activities.

  • Misinterpretation: Don't mistake imagination for memory error or failure.

  • Interviewer Skill: Differentiate experience from fantasy; gently guide back to interview theme without criticizing creativity.

Rewards in Interviewing Children
  • Contentious: Giving rewards is debated.

  • Contingency: Avoid making cooperation dependent on a reward – it can backfire.

  • Purpose: If a reward is given, it should be given as an acknowledgment of their effort, not as a bribe for participation.