Chapter 12 (FOUNDATIONS OF INTL. RELATIONS)
Chapter 12 (FOUNDATIONS OF INTL. RELATIONS)
Introduction to Religion and Culture in International Relations
The significance of religion and culture in shaping International Relations is often underestimated.
Initially ignored by scholars due to secularisation theory, suggesting religion would decline in importance.
Historical perspectives: Western Europe experienced a decline in religion after 1648.
Globalisation was believed to merge cultural differences, refocusing IR scholarship elsewhere.
Events such as the Iranian Revolution, the fall of the Soviet Union, and 9/11 shifted this perspective, highlighting religion's impact.
This chapter separates and then intertwines religion and culture to explore their joint influence on identities.
Key Terms
Secularisation Theory
Theory positing that science and reason diminish religion's relevance.
Assumed influences of religion would decrease in state affairs globally, particularly post-Cold War.
Diplomacy often avoided religious discussions, focusing instead on political, economic, and social issues.
Elements of Religion
Framework of Religious Belief
Divided into fundamental and contextual forms.
Importance of divine beings/forces in political order.
Religious Practices:
Rituals serve as tangible expressions of intangible beliefs, affecting public life.
Dynamics of Power:
Religion serves as an agent of power, influencing political orders across contexts.
The Role of Religion in Politics
Fundamental religious traditions view politics of governing society according to divine commands (e.g., Iran's Supreme Leader).
Contextual approaches adapt to societal diversity, influencing politics while not seeking total control (e.g., Aga Khan Development Network).
Religion and politics interact, impacting behavior in the public domain.
Understanding Elements of Culture
Culture defined simply as humanly constructed social elements shaping coexistence over generations.
Three Elements of Culture
Common/shared life:
Cooperation often goes unnoticed amongst conflict narratives.
Symbols of identity:
Constructs of identity through cultural artefacts (flags, clothing, architecture).
Debates about 'a good life':
Culture reflects societal views on well-being and happiness, affecting policy and identity.
Interrelations of Religion and Culture
Geertz: Religion as a cultural system providing meaning through symbols and practices.
Interlinked approaches allow examination of overlapping elements of culture and religion in IR.
Huntington’s notion: post-Cold War politics defined by 'clashes of civilisations' increasingly oriented on cultural and religious lines.
Interaction includes examining conflicts and cooperative potentials.
Case Studies and Applications
Religious movements can serve both oppressive and liberating purposes (e.g., Bethel Church's intervention in the Tamrazyan case).
Cultural practices, like South Korean intelligence techniques, emphasize the role of cultural frames in strategic contexts.
Conclusion
Religion and culture are integral to understanding contemporary global issues.
Acknowledging religio-cultural identities enhances insights into cooperation and conflict in global politics.
A 'both/and' approach facilitates a nuanced understanding of their dual contributions to societal dynamics.