Chapter 3 FBS
Family Dynamics in Criminal Behavior
Father and Son Duo: Bernard Peters and his son, Scott, have shared a cell at Elmira Correctional Facility for nearly 15 years.
Case Study: Numerous familial connections are highlighted in relation to criminal behavior within families, connecting biological and social factors.
The Bogle Clan: Showcases a family history rife with criminal convictions and run-ins with the law.
Example: Dale Vincent (Rooster) Bogle, with a criminal record in Texas and multiple arrests in Oregon.
Heredity and Criminal Behavior
Concept of Heredity: It involves the transmission of traits from parents to offspring through genes.
Impact on Personality and Behavior: Genetic traits can influence behavioral and personality characteristics, which encompass impulsivity, aggression, and criminal tendencies.
Personality Traits and Temperament
Personality Definition: Regularities in behavior that form a coherent sense of self; behaviors are organized into traits.
Temperament: Refers to stable emotional and behavioral reactions present from a young age; it can predispose individuals to certain behaviors, including criminality.
Neurodevelopmental Disorders
Lists a variety of mental disorders including:
Schizophrenia
Bipolar disorders
Anxiety disorders
Personality disorders
This section depicts the breadth of psychological factors influencing behavior.
Antisocial Personality Disorder (APD)
Diagnostic Criteria: Involves a pervasive pattern of disregard for others, with symptoms including:
Repeated criminal acts.
Deceitfulness and manipulation.
Impulsivity and aggression.
Requirements: Must be at least 18 years old and show evidence of conduct disorder from a young age.
Genetic Studies on Crime
Twin Studies: Investigate the influence of genetics versus environment on criminal behaviors.
Identical twins vs. fraternal twins explore shared environments and genetics.
Concordance Rates: Demonstrates that identical twins show a higher concordance rate for criminal behaviors compared to fraternal twins.
Brain Function and Criminal Behavior
Brain Lobes: The frontal lobes are critical for high cognitive functions which, when impaired, can lead to problematic behaviors.
Executive Functioning: Organization, focus, effort, emotions, memory, and action regulation are key to leading a law-abiding life.
Environmental Influence on Behavior
Adoption Studies: Data indicates a link between biological parents' criminal history and adopted children's behavior, even in healthy environments.
Results suggest genetic predispositions continue to influence behavior regardless of the environment.
Example: Jeffrey Landrigan reflects on the link between his criminal behavior and his family history.
Behavioral Genetics in Legal System
Italian Court Case: A convicted murderer's sentence was reduced due to identified genes linked to violent behavior, showcasing the intersection of genetics and law.
Raises questions about the scientific validity of using genetic predisposition as mitigating factors in court.
Case Studies Highlighting Genetic Influence
Dutch Study: Investigated a family with a history of violence possibly linked to a genetic defect on the X chromosome.
Links aggression to a defect on the MAO-A gene, suggesting a hereditary component in aggressive behaviors.
Conclusion: Interplay of Genes and Environment
The evidence points to a complex interplay between genetic predispositions and environmental factors in explaining criminal behaviors across generations, indicating that both aspects must be considered in understanding criminality.