Systems Thinking MIDTERM
1.
Understand what a system is
A collection of interacting parts/components/actors, in which the interactions result in system-level properties and behaviors not attributable to the sum of individual parts
● Understand the core concepts of systems thinking, including:
Open and closed systems
Open systems interact with the environment, can change the environment and be changed by it.
Closed Systems do not interact nor have any reaction to the environment.
Most systems are open, closed are rare
Three types: fully open, partially open, and closed system
Hard and soft systems
All hard systems are embedded into soft systems
Hard systems are predictable and constructed by components
Soft systems are unpredictable and constructed by social behaviours
Worldviews
Perceptions influenced by social factors
Complexity
When talking about complexity, think of it in terms of technical and perceived complexity
Technical complexity is an intrinsic property of a system
What makes systems complex are: number of parts and connections, dynamic relationships between parts, non-linear interactions, and varying responses
Perceived complexity is how stakeholders view the system
Systems can be complex or complicated
Complex: woven together, Cannot be deconstructed, unpredictable, thus is a soft system. Can only be understood as a whole
Complicated: folded together, able to deconstruct and put together. Mostly hard systems.
Emergence
Emergence refers to the properties of the system that are caused by the interaction and relationships between elements rather than by the elements themselves.
Emergence is the complexity arising from simplicity and it can be observed everywhere in the world around us.ex. Flock of birds navigating through the sky
Levels of emergence. Weak or Strong
Weak: behavior of the system can be explained and/or predicted
Strong: Behavior of the system is more difficult to explain.
Self-organizing systems and organizational models
Self-organization in decentralized systems as a process where some form of overall order arises from local interaction between parts of an initially disordered system. Consequently, complex and unpredictable behaviors emerge
The more self-organized, the more resilient it is
Hierarchies are more resilient. Has multiple points of failure
Networks have no concentrations of points of failure.
Holacracy: form of organization that distributes authority and decision making through a network of self-organized teams that are bound together with a share purpose and common set of goals and rules
Different kinds of systems problems
System problems can be classified as tame, messy, and wicked
Tame: Can be solved.
Messy: most common problem type. Poorly defined and do not have a single correct solution. Requires negotiations and compromises
Wicked: always involves a loser and a winner.
2.
The function and purpose of a system
The purpose of the system is what is does
The function is how it delivers this purpose
Ex. car. Purpose is to transport. Function is how they do it.
A system does something (function) for a particular purpose
Systems inputs and outputs
Inputs: are processed through the system and leave the system in a changed state
Resources: are consumed by the function of the system
Controls (also a form of input) set the expectations, standards or requirements a system should fulfill
Outputs are produced by the system in line with its function and, where known, its purpose. May be useful when they are consistent with the purpose of the system. Other outputs may be unintended due to the emergent behavior of the system
System performance
Performance has two dimensions: efficiency and Effectiveness.
Effectiveness is defined as the extent in which a goal is achieved
Efficiency is how well a goal is achieved using minimal resources
Efficacy is concerned with the potential performance of a system, mostly within a lab setting
Stocks, flows and forces
Stocks and flows are concepts commonly used in systems thinking.
Stock is defined as a quantity existing at a given point in time
Flow is the rate at which one receives their stock
Stocks and flows are mostly used fo the tangible
For the intangible is often referred to as forces
System structure and boundary
System boundary is an artificial concept to aid the analyst or the manager in conceptualizing and understanding the system
Entropy and homeostasis
The term entropy is used as a metaphor for ageing, skill fade, obsolescence, or similar.
A key purpose for management is to prevent entrophy
Homeostasis is used to describe a system that maintains its steady state
According to
this illustration the system has a purpose and a function. It has inputs and
outputs. It has controls that govern the system and it uses resources to carry
out its function and transform the inputs to outputs. While carrying out its
function, things (materials, information, people, energy, etc.) flow through
the system. These flows come from stocks which either exist within the system or come from outside the system. We can conceptualize and measure the
performance of the system as effectiveness and efficiency of the system.
3.
Characteristics of living systems
The control and communication within viable systems
The importance of systems architecture
How variation and worldviews may interact with and shape the
behaviour of systems
How constraints govern the performance of a system
James Grier Miller
American psychologist, psychiatrist, academic, and forerunner of systems thinking.
Established and led the mental health research institute at UM
Creator of the Living systems theory
Cells represent fundamental building blocks of life, which organize themselves into organs, which in turn organize themselves into organisms. Organisms organize themselves into groups and in turn groups organize themselves into organizations. Communities include both individual organisms and groups, with different functions within the community. Societies are associations of communities and supranational systems are organizations of societies.
Core to the theory is that all nature is a continuum; the endless complexity of life can be organised into patterns that repeat themselves at each level of system
All levels are considered open self-organizing systems that may be conceptualized using four dimensions
Miller’s theory suggests that all eight levels of systems sustain themselves through 20 subsystems that recur at each level
Miller focused on concrete systems developed his theory distinguishing between concrete, abstract, and conceptual
Concrete: a system that existed in reality and are made of tangible - hard system
Conceptual are non-physical, intangible - soft system
Abstract composed of both tangible and intangible parts, but does not exist in reality, only as an idea
Beer’s system
4.
Key characteristics of hard systems are their predictable behaviours, caused by high integrity parts that are connected through well-understood interactions
Hard systems:
Predictable
High-integrity parts
High-integrity connections
Feedback that can be used to compensate for deviation
Rate of deterioration/entropy that is predictable
Hard system thinking is a way of thinking about systems whereby the analyst is assuming that systems behave as a hard system/ are predictable
Flowcharts
A diagram that uses standard symbols to illustrate various activities of a process in sequential order
Typically used to describe process flows in different processes
Main purpose is to model flows of activity within a process
Data-flow diagrams
A form of flowchart that provide the means of representing flow of data through a system
Use only 4 symbols to enable modelling of data flows through they system: entity - process, function or subsystem that transforms inputs to outputs. Flow - connects entities to one another. Store - illustrate storage of what is flowing between entities. External entity - stands outside the boundaries of the system but interacts with the system
Soft System: consisting of autonomous parts that are characterised by high variability and unpredictable behaviours and connected through loosely defined dynamic web of relationships
5.
Key characteristic of soft systems
Unpredictable behavior, caused by autonomy of each part together with loosely defined dynamic relationships between these parts
Parts connected through defined dynamic web of relationships, power, structure, shared interests, and values
Feedback used to compensate for deviation
Soft Systems Methodology (SSM)
1960s by Peter Checkland
SSM was developed specifically for dealing with situations where we are not sure what to do, why the problem exists, how urgent the situation is, who is involved, who the stakeholders are and what their views about the problem are.
7 steps
First two steps focus on exploring and finding about out about the problem in the real world
Steps 3 and 4, are about applying systems thinking by developin the root definitions for the relevant systems and building conceptual models of the system
Final 3 steps are about exploring the models in the context of the real-world situation
Causal loop diagram illustrates the causal relationships between the entities within a system
Types of feedback loops: positive, reinforcing, negative, and balancing
Understand feedback loops and the 7 steps
6.
Open strategy
Advocates for building on the experience, capabilities, wisdom and hunches of managers at different levels in the organization.
Steps in constructing a causal map
1.
Understand what a system is
A collection of interacting parts/components/actors, in which the interactions result in system-level properties and behaviors not attributable to the sum of individual parts
● Understand the core concepts of systems thinking, including:
Open and closed systems
Open systems interact with the environment, can change the environment and be changed by it.
Closed Systems do not interact nor have any reaction to the environment.
Most systems are open, closed are rare
Three types: fully open, partially open, and closed system
Hard and soft systems
All hard systems are embedded into soft systems
Hard systems are predictable and constructed by components
Soft systems are unpredictable and constructed by social behaviours
Worldviews
Perceptions influenced by social factors
Complexity
When talking about complexity, think of it in terms of technical and perceived complexity
Technical complexity is an intrinsic property of a system
What makes systems complex are: number of parts and connections, dynamic relationships between parts, non-linear interactions, and varying responses
Perceived complexity is how stakeholders view the system
Systems can be complex or complicated
Complex: woven together, Cannot be deconstructed, unpredictable, thus is a soft system. Can only be understood as a whole
Complicated: folded together, able to deconstruct and put together. Mostly hard systems.
Emergence
Emergence refers to the properties of the system that are caused by the interaction and relationships between elements rather than by the elements themselves.
Emergence is the complexity arising from simplicity and it can be observed everywhere in the world around us.ex. Flock of birds navigating through the sky
Levels of emergence. Weak or Strong
Weak: behavior of the system can be explained and/or predicted
Strong: Behavior of the system is more difficult to explain.
Self-organizing systems and organizational models
Self-organization in decentralized systems as a process where some form of overall order arises from local interaction between parts of an initially disordered system. Consequently, complex and unpredictable behaviors emerge
The more self-organized, the more resilient it is
Hierarchies are more resilient. Has multiple points of failure
Networks have no concentrations of points of failure.
Holacracy: form of organization that distributes authority and decision making through a network of self-organized teams that are bound together with a share purpose and common set of goals and rules
Different kinds of systems problems
System problems can be classified as tame, messy, and wicked
Tame: Can be solved.
Messy: most common problem type. Poorly defined and do not have a single correct solution. Requires negotiations and compromises
Wicked: always involves a loser and a winner.
2.
The function and purpose of a system
The purpose of the system is what is does
The function is how it delivers this purpose
Ex. car. Purpose is to transport. Function is how they do it.
A system does something (function) for a particular purpose
Systems inputs and outputs
Inputs: are processed through the system and leave the system in a changed state
Resources: are consumed by the function of the system
Controls (also a form of input) set the expectations, standards or requirements a system should fulfill
Outputs are produced by the system in line with its function and, where known, its purpose. May be useful when they are consistent with the purpose of the system. Other outputs may be unintended due to the emergent behavior of the system
System performance
Performance has two dimensions: efficiency and Effectiveness.
Effectiveness is defined as the extent in which a goal is achieved
Efficiency is how well a goal is achieved using minimal resources
Efficacy is concerned with the potential performance of a system, mostly within a lab setting
Stocks, flows and forces
Stocks and flows are concepts commonly used in systems thinking.
Stock is defined as a quantity existing at a given point in time
Flow is the rate at which one receives their stock
Stocks and flows are mostly used fo the tangible
For the intangible is often referred to as forces
System structure and boundary
System boundary is an artificial concept to aid the analyst or the manager in conceptualizing and understanding the system
Entropy and homeostasis
The term entropy is used as a metaphor for ageing, skill fade, obsolescence, or similar.
A key purpose for management is to prevent entrophy
Homeostasis is used to describe a system that maintains its steady state
According to
this illustration the system has a purpose and a function. It has inputs and
outputs. It has controls that govern the system and it uses resources to carry
out its function and transform the inputs to outputs. While carrying out its
function, things (materials, information, people, energy, etc.) flow through
the system. These flows come from stocks which either exist within the system or come from outside the system. We can conceptualize and measure the
performance of the system as effectiveness and efficiency of the system.
3.
Characteristics of living systems
The control and communication within viable systems
The importance of systems architecture
How variation and worldviews may interact with and shape the
behaviour of systems
How constraints govern the performance of a system
James Grier Miller
American psychologist, psychiatrist, academic, and forerunner of systems thinking.
Established and led the mental health research institute at UM
Creator of the Living systems theory
Cells represent fundamental building blocks of life, which organize themselves into organs, which in turn organize themselves into organisms. Organisms organize themselves into groups and in turn groups organize themselves into organizations. Communities include both individual organisms and groups, with different functions within the community. Societies are associations of communities and supranational systems are organizations of societies.
Core to the theory is that all nature is a continuum; the endless complexity of life can be organised into patterns that repeat themselves at each level of system
All levels are considered open self-organizing systems that may be conceptualized using four dimensions
Miller’s theory suggests that all eight levels of systems sustain themselves through 20 subsystems that recur at each level
Miller focused on concrete systems developed his theory distinguishing between concrete, abstract, and conceptual
Concrete: a system that existed in reality and are made of tangible - hard system
Conceptual are non-physical, intangible - soft system
Abstract composed of both tangible and intangible parts, but does not exist in reality, only as an idea
Beer’s system
4.
Key characteristics of hard systems are their predictable behaviours, caused by high integrity parts that are connected through well-understood interactions
Hard systems:
Predictable
High-integrity parts
High-integrity connections
Feedback that can be used to compensate for deviation
Rate of deterioration/entropy that is predictable
Hard system thinking is a way of thinking about systems whereby the analyst is assuming that systems behave as a hard system/ are predictable
Flowcharts
A diagram that uses standard symbols to illustrate various activities of a process in sequential order
Typically used to describe process flows in different processes
Main purpose is to model flows of activity within a process
Data-flow diagrams
A form of flowchart that provide the means of representing flow of data through a system
Use only 4 symbols to enable modelling of data flows through they system: entity - process, function or subsystem that transforms inputs to outputs. Flow - connects entities to one another. Store - illustrate storage of what is flowing between entities. External entity - stands outside the boundaries of the system but interacts with the system
Soft System: consisting of autonomous parts that are characterised by high variability and unpredictable behaviours and connected through loosely defined dynamic web of relationships
5.
Key characteristic of soft systems
Unpredictable behavior, caused by autonomy of each part together with loosely defined dynamic relationships between these parts
Parts connected through defined dynamic web of relationships, power, structure, shared interests, and values
Feedback used to compensate for deviation
Soft Systems Methodology (SSM)
1960s by Peter Checkland
SSM was developed specifically for dealing with situations where we are not sure what to do, why the problem exists, how urgent the situation is, who is involved, who the stakeholders are and what their views about the problem are.
7 steps
First two steps focus on exploring and finding about out about the problem in the real world
Steps 3 and 4, are about applying systems thinking by developin the root definitions for the relevant systems and building conceptual models of the system
Final 3 steps are about exploring the models in the context of the real-world situation
Causal loop diagram illustrates the causal relationships between the entities within a system
Types of feedback loops: positive, reinforcing, negative, and balancing
Understand feedback loops and the 7 steps
6.
Open strategy
Advocates for building on the experience, capabilities, wisdom and hunches of managers at different levels in the organization.
Steps in constructing a causal map