D

Land Law: Limitation in Specific Performance Actions

Limitation in Land Sale Agreements

Key Principles

  • Limitation Period: An action to recover land, including specific performance of a sale agreement, has a limitation period of 12 years.

  • Accrual of Cause of Action: Time begins to run from the date of infringement or threat of infringement of the plaintiff's right under the agreement.

  • Breach of Contract: A cause of action on a contract accrues on the date of the breach.

  • Definition of Cause of Action: A cause of action includes every fact that the plaintiff must prove to obtain judgment.

  • Application of Limitation Law: The law of limitation is that in force on the date the action is instituted, not when the cause of action arises.

Key Cases

  • Nasri v Mesah:

    • Specific performance sought for a land sale agreement from 1947; action commenced in 1967.

    • The action is essentially to recover land, thus subject to a 12-year limitation.

    • Time runs from the infringement or threat of infringement of the appellant's right under the agreement.

  • Ponnusamy & Anor v Nathu Ram:

    • Action to recover land has a 12-year limitation period.

  • Ng Moh v Tan Bok Kim & Anor:

    • Time begins to run when there is an infringement of the appellant's right under the sale agreement.

  • Bolo v Koklan & Ors:

    • There can be no right to sue until there is an accrual of the right asserted and its infringement or threat of infringement.

Important Considerations

  • Moratorium Effect: The moratorium period is excluded when computing the limitation period.

  • Threat of Infringement: Limitation begins upon a clear and unequivocal threat to the plaintiff's right to the land transfer.

  • Refusal to Transfer: The absence of a clear refusal to transfer the land may affect when the limitation period starts.

  • Legal Precedent: Precedents indicate that actions effectively seeking land through court judgments are considered actions to recover land.