Exercise: Gentle ROM (extension and flexion), quadriceps/VMO setting, supported (bilateral) calf raises, hip abduction and extension, hamstring pulleys/rubbers, gait re-education drills, light exercise bike.
Exercise: ROM drills, quadriceps/VMO setting, mini-squats and lunges, leg press (double, then single-leg), step-ups, bridges (double, then single-leg), hip abduction and extension with rubber tubing, single-leg calf raises, gait re-education drills, balance and proprioceptive drills (single-leg).
Phase 3 (2-3 weeks):
Goal: Full ROM, full strength, full squat, dynamic proprioceptive training, return to running and restricted sport-specific drills.
Physiotherapy: Manual therapy, exercise/activity modification and supervision.
Exercise: As above - increase difficulty, repetitions and weight where appropriate, jump and land drills, agility drills, functional/sport-related activity, progress to FWB and normal gait pattern, swimming (light kick), exercise bike, walking, running.
Phase 4 (3-5 weeks):
Goal: Full strength, ROM, and endurance of affected limb, return to sport-specific drills and restricted training and match play.
Physiotherapy: As above.
Exercise: High-level sport-specific strengthening as required, swimming, road bike, sport-specific exercises (progressively sequenced). Return to sport-specific drills, restricted training and match play.
Evidence
Exercise program vs. arthroscopic partial meniscectomy and exercise:
N = 351 (meniscal injury with OA).
6-month follow-up: No significant difference between groups; 30% of exercise group had surgery.
12-month follow-up: No significant difference between groups (Katz et al., 2013).
12-week exercise program vs. arthroscopic partial meniscectomy:
N = 140 (meniscal injury, no OA).
3-month follow-up: Exercise group was stronger.
2-year follow-up: No significant difference between groups (Kise et al., 2016).
Arthroscopic partial meniscectomy vs. placebo surgery:
N = 146 (meniscal injury with no OA).
2-year follow-up: Real surgery was no better than placebo surgery (Sihvonen et al., 2017).
Anterior Cruciate Ligament Injury (ACL)
Problem
MOI: Slight knee flexion with quads activation, valgus collapse, and internal rotation of femur relative to fixed tibia – “cutting maneuver”.
Less common MOI: Hyperextension – femur moves posteriorly.
Commonly injured knee ligament.
52 per 100,000 in Australia (Janssen et al., 2012).
Severe pain at time of injury (inability to continue play).
± current pain (depending on stage).
1° complaint giving way/instability.
Swelling++/Heamarthrosis.
Loss of ROM.
Weakness/inability to maximal contract.
Diagnosis
Special tests:
Lachman’s test.
Anterior Drawer Test.
Pivot shift test.
MRI, X-ray (sulcus sign).
Outcome measures:
Strength ratio (between legs/between quads/hamstrings).
RTS.
ACL QoL Questionnaire.
LLTQ, SF-36.
Treatment (not a one size fits all)
Phase 1 (Acute phase) goals:
Control pain and swelling, Restore pain free ROM, Improve flexibility, Normalize gait mechanics (WBAT w crutches), Establish good quadriceps activation.
Phase 2 (Sub-acute/strengthening phase) goals:
Avoid patella femoral pain, Maintain ROM and flexibility, Restore muscle strength, Improve neuromuscular control.
Phase 3 (Limited return to activity phase) goals:
Avoid patella femoral pain, Maintain ROM and flexibility, Progress with single leg strengthening to maximize strength, Progress dynamic proprioception exercises to maximize neuromuscular control, Initiate plyometrics* and light jogging*.
Phase 4 (Return to activity/sport phase) goals:
Maintain adequate ROM, flexibility and strength, Continue progressive/dynamic strengthening, proprioceptive, plyometric and agility training, Achieve adequate strength to return to sport (pending physician’s clearance).
Evidence
Conservative vs. Surgery 6 – 16 months follow-up
n = 12 conservative vs. n = 21 operative.
Operative group scored better for ligamentous stability.
Conservative group had > muscle strength (knee ext & flx, ankle plantarflexors).
Conservative vs. Surgery 11 year follow-up
n = 109 (60 surgery, 49 conservative) Isolated ACL rupture – same rehab program.
11 years after ACL rupture, surgery group had better stability but more Knee OA (>Grade II), no difference in physical activity level (both groups decreased physical activity level) (Karanikas et al., 2005). (Kessler et al., 2008)
Patella Dislocation
Problem & Signs & Symptoms
5.8-7.0 /100,000 people.
29/100,000 10-17 year olds.
Females > males.
Younger > older.
Signs and Symptoms
Traumatic MOI – twisting, jumping.
Severe pain++ and immediate swelling++.
Deformity (can relocate with extension).
“Popping out”.
Differential diagnosis – ACL rupture (MOI S&S).
Weakness/reluctance to use quads (Brukner & Khan, 2017) p763.
Diagnosis
Clinical:
Ottawa knee rules.
Patella apprehension test.
Pain on palpation of the medial border.
Pain during compression.
Imaging:
X-ray (bony deformities).
CT or MRI (bony and soft tissue).
MPFL (ruptured).
Management
Phase 1(0-2 weeks)
Goal of Phase:
Control of Swelling
Maintain knee extension
Isometric quadriceps strength
Physiotherapy treatment:
Extension splint (removal dependent on surgeon/physician)
Cryotherapy
Electrotherapy
PFJ taping
Manual therapy
Exercise program
Quadriceps drills (supine)
Bilateral calf raises
Foot and ankle
Hip abduction
ROM drills
Phase 2 (2-6 weeks)
Goal of Phase:
No swelling
Full extension
Flexion to 100°
4+/5 quadriceps strength
5/5 hamstring strength
Physiotherapy treatment:
Cryotherapy
Electrotherapy
Compression
Manual therapy
Gait re-education
Exercise modification
Exercise program
Quadriceps/VMO setting
Mini-squats and lunges
Bridges (double, then single-leg)
Hip abduction and extension with rubber tubing
Single-leg calf raises
Gait re-education drills
Balance and proprioceptive drills (single-leg)
Phase 3 (6-8 weeks)
Goal of Phase:
Full ROM
Full strength and power
Return to jogging, running, and agility
Return to restricted sport-specific drills
Physiotherapy treatment:
Manual therapy
Exercise/activity modification and supervision
Exercise program
As above increase difficulty, repetitions, and weight, where appropriate
Single-leg squats
Single-leg press
Jump and land drills
Agility drills
Functional/sport-related activity
Progress to FWB
Walking
Exercise bike
Straight-line jogging
Swimming (light kick)
Phase 4 (8-12 weeks)
Goal of Phase:
Return to sport
Physiotherapy treatment:
As above
Exercise program
Road bike
Straight-line running
Progressing to sport-specific running and agility (progressively sequenced) (e.g. running forwards, sideways, backwards, sprinting, jumping, hopping, changing directions, kicking)
Progressive return to sport (e.g. restricted training, unrestricted training, match play, competitive match play)
Patella Fracture
Problem
Fractures of the distal femur, proximal tibia and patella make up 6.7% of all LL fractures.
47% proximal tibia.
32% distal femur.
21% Patella.
Cause (e.g. fall, RTA).
Patella – direct blow.
Tibial plateau – compression.
Stress fracture (Vun et al., 2013).
Diagnosis
Clinical diagnosis:
Instant PAIN+.
Swelling++/Heamarthrosis.
Quads weakness, or inability to extend leg.
Pain++ on palpation, depending on fracture type might be able to feel gap.
A knee x-ray series is only required for knee injury patients with any of these findings:
age 55 or older.
isolated tenderness of patella (no bone tenderness of knee other than patella).
tenderness of head of fibula.
inability to flex to 90°.
inability to bear weight both immediately and in the emergency department for 4 steps (unable to transfer weight twice onto each lower limb regardless of limping).
Percutaneous repair was associated with shorter surgical time, less pain, better mobility angle (flexion > extension), better KSCRS at 4 and 8 weeks follow up.
Knee society clinical rating scale was greater in the percutaneous group at 12 and 24 months (Luna-Pizarro et al., 2006).
Causes of Knee Pain – Chronic/idiopathic
OA
PFP
Patellar tendinopathy
Iliotibial band friction syndrome
Fat pad impingement
Sinding-Larsen-Johansson lesion (in adolescents)
Osgood schlatter disease (in adolescents)
Synovial plica
Pre-patellar bursitis
Quadriceps tendinopathy
Infrapatellar bursitis
Tenoperiostitis of upper tibia
Referred pain from the hip
Osteochondritis dissicans
Slipped capital femoral epiphysis
Perthes’ disease
Tumour (especially in the young)
Stress fracture of patella
Osteoarthritis (OA)
Problem
Significant problem (older population) – 1.4 million Australians (2009).
Two types:
Primary – idiopathic, gradual deterioration, affects many joints (older age).
Secondary – following injury, localised to one joint (younger age).
Diagnosis
Clinical diagnosis (Think age, main symptoms: pain, stiffness, limited movement of the affected joint).
X-ray (Kellgren & Lawrence OA Grades).
Outcomes: WOMAC, KOOS, LLTQ, 6MWT, TUG, STS.
Treatment
12 Non-pharmacological therapies – advice and education, self-management, regular telephone contact, referral to a physical therapist, aerobic, muscle strengthening, water-based exercises, weight reduction, walking aids, knee braces, footwear and insoles, thermal.
5 Surgical modalities (arthroscopy, partial joint replacement, total joint replacement) (Zhang et al., 2008).
Evidence
RCT exercise vs. no exercise
Both groups received the same treatment except exercise.
Exercise group had > improvement in pain, disability, walking, stair climbing, and sit up speed at all time points (1, 3, 12 months) (Deyle et al., 2005).
Physiotherapy program vs. home exercise program
2 Groups – supervised exercises with manual therapy vs. home exercise program over 4 weeks.
Both groups improved.
Supervised group had significantly greater improvements on 6MWT and WOMAC (Western Ontario and McMaster Universities Osteoarthritis Index) (Nejati et al., 2015).
PatelloFemoral Pain (PFP)
Problem
23% of the general population.
29% in adolescents.
Females > Males.
6-13% in military.
Risk factors:
Quadriceps weakness (military recruits).
Greater hip abductor strength (adolescents).
Not a Risk Factor age, height, weight, BMI, body fat, Q-angle (Neal et al., 2019).
Signs and Symptoms
Clinical presentation (think age):
Anterior knee pain: Peripatellar pain, hard to describe.
Pain on loaded or prolonged flexion (running,stairs, sitting).
Weak medial and tight lateral.
Poor patellar tracking (observation).
Weak/poor control of hip muscles/altered hip and/or foot biomechanics.
Crepitus (severe cases).
Giving way due to weak quads.
No scans in early stages (may scan if not improving).
Outcomes: VAS, Anterior Knee Pain Scale (AKPS) (Valid and Reliable, Crossley et al., Arch. Phys. Med. Rehabil. 2004 85(5) p815), GROC, Functional outcomes (ROM, strength, running).
Diagnosis
Clinical tests:
Palpation (might be hard to feel).
Compression (caudal/cephalad/medial/lateral).
Pain/Crepitus.
VMO coordination test.
Eccentric step test (Nijs et al., 2006).
Quick test: Pick a provocative test (steps) have the patient complete (establish pain) this and then apply a medial glide to the patella and repeat. If pain decreases during the task it is a positive test and indicator for further treatment.
Treatment
Guidelines for non-operative treatment – Individualised exercise dependant on P/E findings.
Hip Glutes Intrinsic Foot Hip retraining Hip Tape Correct deficit Othoses (Brukner & Khan, 2017) p784/5.
Evidence
RCT arthroscopy + exercise vs. exercise alone (9 month follow-up) (Kettunen et al., 2007).
Both groups treated with 8 week exercise program.
No difference between groups at follow-up (Kujala Score and VAS).
Arthroscopy cost exceeded exercise group by €901/patient.
179 participants (18-40 years)
Six weeks intervention
Physio
Joint mobs
Taping
Quadriceps retraining
Education Collins et al.
PFP vs. Patellar Tendinopathy
PFP
Onset: Running, steps/stairs, hills, any weight-bearing activities involving knee flexion.
Pain: Non-specific or vague; may be medial, lateral or infrapatellar; aggravated by activities that load the PFJ.
Tenderness: Usually medial or lateral facets of patella but may be tender in infrapatellar region; may have no pain on palpation due to areas of patella being inaccessible.
Swelling: May have small effusion, swelling, suprapatellar or infrapatellar.
Clicks/clunks: occasional.
Crepitus: Occasionally under patella.
Giving way: Rarely, due to quadriceps weakness/inhibition or subluxation.
Knee range of motion: May be decreased in severe cases but usually normal.
Quadriceps contraction in extension: Can be painful, often normal.
PFJ movement: May be restricted in any direction. Commonly restricted medial glide due to tight lateral structures.
Functional testing: Squats, stairs may aggravate. PFJ taping should decrease pain.
Pain: At the inferior pole of patella, aggravated by energy storage loads such as jumping.
Tenderness: Localised to inferior pole of patella; this tenderness can exist in jumping athletes without patellar tendinopathy.
Swelling: Tendon may be increased in thickness; no joint swelling.
Clicks/clunks: No.
Crepitus: No.
Giving way: Rarely, due to quadriceps weakness/inhibition.
Knee range of motion: Normal.
Quadriceps contraction in extension: Often painful.
PFJ movement: Normal PFJ biomechanics.
Functional testing: Decline squats aggravate pain; PFJ taping has less effect.
Patellar and Quadriceps Tendinopathy (Jumper’s Knee)
Patellar tendon > quads tendon.
High prevalence in jumping sports (basketball, volleyball).
Younger population (<40 years old).
Localized pain on the inferior pole of the patellar.
Pain during loading of the tendon (jumping, running, decline squat).
VISA - P Diagnosis is clinical.
Pt history and site of symptoms (specific).
Pain on palpation.
Pain during loading.
Thickening on palpation.
Imaging is not very reliable and should be used to confirm diagnosis if patient not progressing.
4 Stage process
Stage 1 Isometrics.
Stage 2 Isotonics.
Stage 3 Energy storage.
Stage 4 Energy storage and release.
Brukner and Khan (2017) Clinical Sports Medicine p50
Acute Management
Isometrics (70% 1RM 5 x 45 seconds) v Isotonic (4 x 8 reps 8RM) (Rio et al., 2015) (Holden et al., 2019).
Management
Heavy slow resistance training vs. corticosteroid injection vs. eccentric declined squat training.
N = 39 - 12 weeks of treatment.
All groups improved from 0 – 12 weeks.
CSI group had greater pain and poorer outcomes at 6 month follow up.
HSR had better patient satisfaction at follow-up.
Take home message: HSR better than ECC for patellar tendinopathy in terms of patient satisfaction but both groups improved (Kongsgaard et al., 2009).
ITB Friction Syndrome
Overuse condition – rubbing of the ITB over the lateral femoral epicondyle.
ITB switches from extensor 0-20° to flexor 20-90°.
Predominantly thought to be bursa but now consider it a fat pad impingement.
Marathon runners.
Military personal 1-12%.
Cyclists – ITBFS accounts for up to 25% of overuse injuries (Brukner & Khan, 2017), p810.
Signs and Symptoms
Pain over the lateral aspect of the knee.
Exacerbated by sporting activities (running or cycling).
Tenderness 2-3 cm above lateral joint line.
Crepitus & local swelling.
Repeated flexion/extension ↑ knee pain.
Positive Ober’s test – pain – pulling – burning.
Muscle shortening – glutes/TFL.
Weakness of hip abductors.
? Look for internal rotation of the tibia.
Treatment
Focus should be on the entire kinetic chain.
Foot alignment – orthotics – intrinsic control.
Hip biomechanics and strength/neuromuscular control.
Oral NSAIDs in early stages.
Electrotherapy – Cryotherapy/shock wave.
Soft-tissue therapy – proximal ITB.
Stretching of the ITB is limited (due to anatomy).
Stretching of glutes and TFL.
Hip and knee strengthening.
Bursitis – Pre-patellar and Infrapatellar
Inflammation of the bursae.
Pre-patellar bursa (most common) housemaid’s knee.
Superficial anterior knee pain – kneeling.
Superficial swelling anterior knee.
Infrapatellar bursa
Anterior knee pain – similarly to patellar tendinopathy.
Difficult to treat.
NSAID (oral, topical).
Aspiration and infiltration with corticosteroid/local anaesthetic agent (Brukner & Khan, 2017), p803.
Fat Pad Impingement
Impingement between tibia and femur.
Trauma or physiological.
Common and relatively unrecognised.
Extreme pain – highly innovative.
Pain during hyperextension of the knee.
Straight leg raises, prolonged standing.
Pain during quads contraction.
Pain during PROM – knee extension.
Quads weakness – inhibition.
Swelling/puffiness of the anterior knee.
Deep to patellar tendon.
Treatment
Activity modification.
Neuromuscular control of quads.
Strength and endurance.
Quads/hamstrings.
Proximal muscles - hips.
Distal muscles – ankle and foot.
Therapeutic tape.
Unload fat pad.
Superior tilt of patellar.
Improve lower limb biomechanics - orthoses.
Osgood-Schlatter Disease
Osteochondritis of the growth plate of the tibial tuberosity.
Common in adolescents.
Males > females.
Associated with high level of physical activity during growth spurts.
Forced knee extensions (jumping, running e.g. basketball, gymnastics).
TOP – tibial tuberosity.
Pain during exercise.
Clinical reasoning.
Thickening of the tibial tuberosity.
Clinical diagnosis – limited need for imaging.
Treatment
Activity modification
A reduction in activity will help reduce pain.
Full rest is not required.
Stretching
STT – quadriceps.
Correction of biomechanical causes.
No CSI or surgery.
References
Brukner, P. & Khan, K. Clinical sports medicine (5th ed). McGraw Hill Education, Sydney, Australia.
Janssen, K.W., J.W. Orchard, T.R. Driscoll, and W. van Mechelen, High incidence and costs for anterior cruciate ligament reconstructions performed in Australia from 2003-2004 to 2007-2008: time for an anterior cruciate ligament register by Scandinavian model? Scand J Med Sci Sports, 2012. 22(4): p. 495-501.
Katz et al. (2013). Surgery versus physical therapy for a meniscal tear and osteoarthritis. New England Journal of Medicine, 368(18), 1675-1684. doi: 10.1056/NEJMoa1301408
Karanikas et al., Sportverletzung-Sportschaden 2005, 19(1) p15
Kise et al. (2016). Exercise therapy versus arthroscopic partial meniscectomy for degenerative meniscal tear in middle aged patients: randomised controlled trial with two-year follow-up. BMJ .354 :i3740
Sihvonen et al. (2017). Arthroscopic partial meniscectomy versus placebo surgery for a degenerative meniscus tear: a 2-year follow-up of the randomised controlled trial. Annals of the Rheumatic Diseases Published Online First: 18 May doi: 10.1136/annrheumdis-2017-211172
Shiraev, T., S. Anderson, and N. Hope, Meniscal tear Presentation, diagnosis and management. Australian Family Physician, 2012. 41: p. 182-187.
Vun S.H., Aitken S.A., McQueen M.M., & Court-Brown C.M. (2013). Adult fracture patterns: Epidemiology of fractures around the knee. Orthopaedic Proceedings 95(B:SUPP