LS

The United States Constitution - Principles of the Constitution (Video)

Key Concepts

  • Primary sources:

    • The U.S. Constitution

    • The Federalist Nos. 10 and 51

  • Terms and topics to study:

    • Articles of Confederation

    • Constitution

    • power

    • union

    • republic

    • representation

    • representative democracy

    • direct democracy

    • extended sphere

    • human nature

    • interest

    • faction

    • parties

    • majority tyranny

    • federalism

    • local government

    • state government

    • federal government

    • township

    • republic

    • enumerated powers

    • separation of powers

    • branch

    • checks and balances.

  • Questions for reflection (The American Mind):

    • explore weaknesses of the Articles

    • relationship between Declaration and Constitution

    • purpose of The Federalist

    • differences between representative democracy and direct democracy

    • how representation improves laws

    • virtues and limitations of human nature

    • tendencies of power

    • dangers of factions and parties

    • rationale for a larger country to curb majority tyranny

    • what is federalism and its advantages

    • distinctions among local, state, and federal governments

    • locating your own state and local governments

    • why the Constitution separates powers

    • purpose of checks and balances

    • balancing majority rule with minority rights

Historical Context and Primary Sources

  • Articles of Confederation: early federation with concerns about a strong central government; states valued independence; cautious about centralized power.

    • Article on sovereignty: each state retained sovereignty except where power explicitly delegated to the U.S. Congress.

    • Weaknesses: no strong national executive; no power to enforce laws; no power to levy taxes to pay for expenses.

  • The event that underscored reform: Shays’ Rebellion (1780s) demonstrated weaknesses of the Articles and urgency for reform.

  • The Federalist Papers: origins and purposes; key authors include James Madison and Alexander Hamilton; while they disagreed on some issues, they shared a common approach to the Constitution.

  • The texts and their roles: The Federalist Nos. 10 and 51 provide arguments about the problems of faction, human nature, and the design of government to mitigate those problems.

Foundational Concepts and The Framers’ Intentions

  • The Constitution is built on two core aims: freedom and self-government; the structure distributes power to protect rights while avoiding tyranny.

  • The Framers believed they were uniquely positioned to create a free, self-governing republic in 1787 due to experience, study of political science, and prudent judgment.

    • The improved science of politics included:

    • Separation of powers

    • An independent judiciary with lifetime appointments

    • Representatives chosen by the people

    • An extended sphere (geographic size) to incorporate diverse interests

  • Important caveat: The Framers did not expect human nature to change; they understood human nature as fixed and prone to faults, including the tendency toward power and corruption.

  • The Constitution does not deny or demonize human nature but channels its powers through constructive institutions and safeguards against its baser tendencies.

  • The Founders aimed to design a government that accounts for human nature and diverse interests while avoiding utopian expectations.

Structure, Representation, and the Extended Sphere

  • The design sought to balance people’s will with knowledgeable deliberation:

    • The form of government follows its function with respect to human nature and purposes of government.

    • The Constitution uses a republic model (representatives ruling on behalf of the people) rather than a pure direct democracy.

  • The dangers of democracy: majority tyranny—protecting minority rights is essential; majority rule must be reconciled with justice.

  • The extended sphere argument: a larger national territory helps prevent majority tyranny by embedding diverse opinions and interests; broad consensus is required for majority decisions.

  • The Constitution creates a system that refines and enlarges the will of the people through federal institutions and representation.

  • The separation of powers and the checks and balances between branches are central to limiting government power and preserving liberty.

Federalism and the Structure of Government

  • Federalism: the distribution of powers between federal and state governments; distinct roles and competencies for local, state, and federal levels.

  • Enumerated powers: the Constitution lists specific powers of the federal government, which narrows federal authority and supports limited government.

  • The system is designed to prevent the concentration of power in any one branch or level of government (Madison’s warning against tyranny).

  • The Constitution’s design includes a bicameral legislature with different representations to balance various interests and regions (e.g., the Great Compromise context implied by the references to debates and compromises on representation and slavery).

  • The federal system and separation of powers are designed to prevent the defects of earlier republican experiments (tyranny by the majority and inefficiency).

  • The rule of law is foundational: all governed and governors are subject to the same laws; the law governs, not personal whim; a constitution represents government by law, not by men.

  • Historical anchors for the rule of law include the Magna Carta and British constitutional history; John Adams summarized the idea as “a government of laws, not of men.”

The Preamble, Consent, and the Republic

  • The Preamble highlights two crucial elements: the purposes of government and the consent of the governed (the people establishing the government for these purposes).

  • The Constitution establishes a republic rather than a pure democracy; representatives deliberate and vote to reflect but refine popular will.

  • The source of governmental power is the free consent of the people (as claimed in the Declaration of Independence) and enacted by the Constitution through republican institutions.

The Federalist Papers and the Nature of Government

  • The Federalist Papers (Nos. 10 and 51) outline major points:

    • The problem of factions and how the Constitution aims to mitigate their effects.

    • The importance of separating powers and creating checks and balances to prevent tyranny by either the majority or the minority.

    • The relationship between human nature, political institutions, and the design of government.

  • The Federalist also explains the purposes of government and the nature of mankind, linking the Declaration of Independence to the Constitution.

The Rule of Law and Its Practical Implications

  • The rule of law is a central, historically rooted concept; it implies that:

    • All people are governed by the same laws and protected by them equally.

    • Those who govern are bound by the same laws as the governed.

    • It is a framework for stable and predictable governance, not the whim of rulers.

  • The law is above any one person or group; governance is bound to a common framework of rules.

  • This principle is tied to the Founders’ aim to prevent arbitrary governance and to protect liberty.

Slavery, Debates, and Compromises

  • The Constitution’s formation involved debates and compromises on slavery; these debates are part of the broader constitutional design and its challenges.

Local, State, and Federal Distinctions

  • The Constitution distinguishes the powers and duties of local, state, and federal governments; the distribution of powers is essential to federalism and to limiting central authority.

  • The extended sphere, proportional representation, and bicameralism were all designed to reflect the varied interests of different regions and states while protecting minority rights.

The Role of History, Experience, and the “Science of Politics”

  • The Founders argued their success relied on lessons from history, experience, and a developing science of politics.

  • They emphasized the importance of:

    • The separation of powers

    • An independent judiciary with lifetime appointments

    • Representatives chosen by the people

    • The extended geographic size of the nation

Post-lesson Reflection and Assignment

  • Strengthening Understanding: Post-lesson assignment asks students to describe the main ideas the Framers kept in mind as they designed the government through the Constitution (1–2 paragraphs).

The U.S. Civics Test Questions (Representative List)

  • Question 1: What is the form of government of the United States?

  • Question 2: What is the supreme law of the land?

  • Question 3: Name one thing the U.S. Constitution does.

  • Question 4: The U.S. Constitution starts with the words “We the People.” What does “We the People” mean?

  • Question 10: Name two important ideas from the Declaration of Independence and the U.S. Constitution.

  • Question 13: What is the rule of law?

  • Question 14: Many documents influenced the U.S. Constitution. Name one.

  • Question 15: There are three branches of government. Why?

  • Question 16: Name the three branches of government.

  • Question 58: Name one power that is only for the federal government.

  • Question 59: Name one power that is only for the states.

  • Question 82: What founding document was written in 1787?

  • Question 83: The Federalist Papers supported the passage of the U.S. Constitution. Name one of the writers.

  • Question 84: Why were the Federalist Papers important?

  • Question 86: George Washington is famous for many things. Name one.

  • Question 88: James Madison is famous for many things. Name one.

  • Question 89: Alexander Hamilton is famous for many things. Name one.

Strengthening Understanding: Post-lesson Assignment

  • Assignment: What are the main ideas the Framers kept in mind as they designed the government through the Constitution? (1–2 paragraphs).