What is forensic science- use of science to investigate crime and present unbiased scientific evidence in court. They draw knowledge from chem, bio, and physics. They assist authorities by techniques to analyze evidence in the laboratory
Part 1: forensics and the law
If you don't analyze it following the law or talk about it using the law then you can’t use it in court
Every pass of evidence that is passed by you will be in court
Who is present at a crime scene during the initial investigation:
Forensic analysts - do testing like is it blood, what happened here, and sends it to the lab
Police
Paramedics
Crime scene investigator/analyze
Not a forensic scientists
They need to be reported at any time
Hours are terrible, work conditions are terrible
Don't really have that much time
Forensic scientists
Analyze the physical evidence using scientific practices
Need a BS in lab based science
Lab research experience
MS in lab-based science or forensic sciences
Internships in FS lab
Bachelors or masters
They work in the lab and medical examiner’s office
Chain of custody- from the time evidence is 1st encountered until til appears in court, someone must maintain secure accountable possession of it.
(collection, examination, analysis, reporting)
(media, data, information, evidence)
Forensic Scientists don't collect evidence. But they need to be concerned about the chain of custody, why?
The defense can say the evidence was tampered with if the chain of custody is broken
You can have all the work but then it cant be used if chain is broken
Evidence analysis and prep for court may take many months
Without proper handling of evidence, judge can make it inadmissible in court IMPOSSIBLE
Time and effort goes to waste
Why do Forensic scientists have to testify in court?
Have to be good at talking about what they do
U gotta be good at science
Scientific Evidence(Court
What is scientific evidence???
Most often presented in court by an expert witness testifying on expert opinions
Included expert testimony
Expert is called to interpret results and draw conclusions
Rules of evidence
Frye Standard
You may use methods and approaches that has to accepted by the scientific community
Such as using a microscope or blood typing
Not fingerprints or dna analysis
What is Daubert v Dow Pharmaceuticals?
Case where someone was trying to hold the pharmaceutical company for a drug that affected someone really badly but it set the standard that scientific evidence may be admissible if it had been used for scientific research in the past and is a valid method for that purpose.
Need an expert witness
The Daubert standard often leads to a battle of the experts, what this mean?
Turns the jury off and you don't want this
The jury is listening to 2 people at the same time about scientific stuff
When both sides have opposite views about some scientific technology, they call experts to argue with either side.
Freye v Daubert
frye : generally accepted by the scientific community
Daubert: the testimony is based upon sufficient facts of data, the testimony is the product of reliable principles and methods and the witness has applied the principles and methods reliably to the facts of the case.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Part 2- analyzing the evidence
2 types of forensic analysis that forensic scientists do:
Identification- what it is
Comparison- what is it the same as/similar to
Exemplar- items of a known source and identify used for comparison(control) like collecting shoes to compare to footprints at the crime scene
What information can physical evidence provide?
Type of crime and level
Premeditated murder with intent to kill (first degree)
Not planned murder(2nd degree)
Man-Slaughter- someone dies by your actions but you didn't intend for them to die voluntary(you did something and you knew) and involuntary(self-defense) (3rd degree)
Analysis of Physical Evidence-
Determine the actions at the scene
Confirm verbal testimony
Identify the victim or Who was there( person of interest)
Provides leads to detectives
Validate or refute a claim
Rule out individuals usually not ruling people in. Classifying types of evidence
Class evidence: links to a group and has unique characteristics that links to a specific object but not a specific individual like shoe prints.
Individual evidence: high probability that the evidence from a specific individual
Identify evidence(ident): A type of individual evidence that links to a specific individual as the source like DNA, skin, poop
Types of physical evidence:
Body FLuids can tell you if drugs were involved or toxicity
Documents
Drugs
Explosives
FIbers
Fingerprints
Firearms/ammunition
Ponderous of evidence - level that is needed of evidence to convict someone for a civil case . linking physical evidence by ruling people out.
Comparing types of evidence:
Individual characteristics
Evidence associated to a unique source, blood DNA
Class
Evidence associated only with a common source like hair, footprint, blood for blood type
Divisions of the lab
Biologist: DNA and Blood evidence who also works with bodily fluids like is it blood, what type of blood, can you get DNA from it, and the spatter pattern of the blood.
Forensic chemist that identifies drugs and unknown substances found at a crime scene like Meth, Crack, Cocaine, Mariwana. They know which gangs can be associated and who is probably involved
Trace Evidence Analyst- identify and compare small pieces of physical evidence and often the “forgotten evidence”’(small evidence like hair and fibers) or excelerents some common ones are: automobile accidents or paint chips) they use mass spectrometry
Document examiner who examines handwriting analysis, forgeries, fake documents, and counterfeit money (lottery tickets are commonly forged).
They use different types of light and magnifying lens, chemical analyst
Firearms, toolmarks, and impressions- they identify guns, link bullets to specific guns, determine source of prints, marks, and causes of damage from tools.
Ballistics and Tool Marks & impressions examiner are in the same division as fire marks
Forensic Toxicologist- analyze fluid and tissue for signs of position, drugs, or other substances, can work with living or dead, often in medical examiner’s office
Specialists - employed in another field, called in for special cases, provide expert testimony in court such as:
Forensic Odontologist- dentists that come in for pieces and parts and come usually during plane crashes or bombs
Forensic Entomologist- look at insects
Forensic Anthropologist- bones can tell you age, gender, cause of death
Forensic Psychologist- PHD in psychology and work with criminals and counsel people can develop criminal file
Making the case:
Reasonable suspicion, probable case, preponderance of the evidence, proof beyond a reasonable doubt
Look at trifecta of investigation like the Means, motive(hardest to prove), opportunity
Blood notes:
Plasma: protein, water, solute
Red blood cells are around the size of a yeast
Hemoglobin gives the blood its color
Blood: orange/brown
Richer red blood cells: lack a nucleus and have no DNA
Glycoproteins: antigens
Hematocrit: ratio of red blood cells to plasma
Formed elements: red and white blood cells
Forensics:
Injury can cause blood loss
For a healthy adult: 20% loss of blood volume(1L) first system is restlessness
Then at 40%, hypovolemic shock sets in
Blood pressure- regulates blood volume and movement
Blood pressure- regulates blood volume and movement
Tissue perfusion(bruise) blood reaches tissue
Organs and tissues- need constant supply of blood, especially the brain
Brain- number 1 place that needs blood
Bruising- burst capillary beds under the skin cells
Alleles: letter representing genotype (I^A) (I^o)
Genotype: gene forms/types like homozygous recessive, heterogeneous dominant
Phenotype: the words
Luminol: good for trying to clean up
Cross linking: causes agglutination
-------------------------------------
Chromatography - separation method (paper, gass, then layer)(purpose: separate compounds in a mixture)
Separates a mixture into discrete components
Separation is based on chemical properties
Polarity differences or similarities are the key properties of this separation
PCR NOTES
What is PCR:
Applications of PCR:
Cancer research, fingerprinting, drug discovery, etc
natural obtained DNA is typically not concentrated enough for molecular analysis
Amplicon- you will have 2 different ones from mom and dad, but if the mom and dad is the same then you will have 1 amplicon.
Portion of DNA replicated during PCR, observable as a band in gel electrophoresis, requires primers to mark the start and end of the region being copied(amplified)
When making the primers you want to think about the organism because different organisms have different lengths of its genes based on how much you want to amplify you need to look at the primers
PCR- put gel towards negative end of electrophoresis box so it can run to red(positive)
Loading dye- colors sample and weighs the sample down in the buffer
What is true about STRs?
STR’s smaller pieces of DNA can be easily amplified by PCR
THey are less likely to degrade since they are small
Can be use with a tiny drop of evidence
Genome- complete set of genetic information that an organism carries in its DNA
PCR- technique that uses cycles of temperature changes to copy DNA sequences, amplifies a DNA sample.
Order: denaturation of double strand(over 90 degrees), binding primers(annealing when temperature cools), building double strand(extension)
Helicase is not apart of the actually PCR reaction
Taq Polymerase is used in PCR because the Human Polymerase would denature
Forensic Entomology- use of insects that feed on remains to help investigations dr
Medical examiner and forensic pathologist is the same person
Frye v. United States was the case to let scientific evidence be used in court
Physical evidence is any substance or artifact that tends to establish or disprove a fact
Replication form is when the helicases break the hydrogen bonds
The lagging strand of DNA is copied discontinuously and moves away from the replication fork
Okazaki fragments at the fragments that grow on the lagging strand 5’ to3’
Eukaryotes package DNA with histone proteins
There are 5 carbons in the sugar in DNA
The 5 prime carbon in DNA is not a part of the carbon ring structure
The phosphodiester bonds in the backbone of DNA have negative charge
Pyrimidine bases are single rings and purine bases are double rings
Class evidence- a link between a type of item and a group of people who have them
The biology branch of forensic science identifies body fluids
TLC- presumptive test
Stationary phase - silica on a glass plate
Mobile phase- of TLC is the solvent
The plate in TLC should be place upright and samples added on the non-shiny side 1 cm from bottom of plate