Chapter 2: Ancient Greek Philosophers 1: Plato
Chapter 2: Ancient Greek Philosophers 1: Plato
Introduction
Discussion focuses on ancient Greek philosophers, specifically Socrates and Plato.
Western philosophy originated in ancient Greece around 2500 years ago.
Presocratic Philosophers
A group of thinkers from the 5th and 6th centuries B.C.E.
Laid the groundwork for scientific inquiry and philosophical thought.
Socrates
Life span: 470 to 399 B.C.E.
Importance: Did not write down his teachings; instead, his ideas are recorded in Plato's dialogues.
Focus: Understanding human nature and the ethics of living a good life.
Method: Socratic dialogues; questioning individuals about their beliefs.
Engaged discussions with various social classes in Athens, particularly aristocrats and Sophists.
Sophists
Paid teachers who instructed students, primarily aristocrats, in rhetoric, argumentation, and public speaking.
Moral Instruction Based on Ethical Relativism:
Definition: The belief that what is considered right or wrong varies according to cultural or social circumstances.
Sophists argued that success and happiness could be attained by adopting conventional societal values.
Socrates opposed this belief, arguing for absolute truths in ethical standards.
Athenian Society and Politics
Athens and Sparta as dominant city-states during the Peloponnesian War.
Socrates questioned authority during troubled political times, leading to his perception as a threat by those in power.
Accused of corrupting the youth and atheism; ultimately sentenced to death by drinking hemlock.
Socrates' Trial and Death
Significantly influenced philosophical discourse around beliefs and values.
Plato
Life Span: 427 to 348 B.C.E.; member of the Athenian aristocracy.
Acknowledged as one of the most influential figures in Western philosophy; known for his dialogue writing.
Philosophical contributions encompass key domains: reality, ethics, psychology, politics, and education.
Described as the first comprehensive system of Western philosophy.
Writings influenced subsequent philosophy, often regarded as "footnotes" to his work.
Critique of Democracy
Blamed the fall of Athens on the democratic government, criticizing it for not being governed by wisdom but by emotions and greed.
Condemned ethical relativism, particularly its role in Socrates' execution.
In The Republic, Plato outlines his ideal state:
Governed not by the masses but by a few educated individuals possessing true knowledge and understanding of human nature.
The Academy
Founded by Plato around 388 B.C.E., modeled after modern universities.
Aimed to cultivate knowledgeable rulers who understood human nature.
Plato's Worldview
Believed in an inherent human nature that is essential for understanding how to live well.
Understanding human nature requires comprehension of reality—discussed further in metaphysics and epistemology.
Metaphysical and Epistemological Assumptions
Plato believed ordinary experiences often mislead; philosophical understanding is necessary for true wisdom.
Used literary devices—metaphors, analogies, and allegories—to clarify his theories.
Allegory of the Cave
Depicts prisoners confined in a cave, seeing only shadows on the wall, representing their perceived reality.
One prisoner escapes and discovers the outside world, realizing that shadows were mere copies of real objects.
Implications: Suggests that ordinary perceptions may mislead, and that true knowledge requires intellectual insight.
The Divided Line
Presents a graphical representation of Plato's metaphysical and epistemological beliefs:
Division of Reality:
Lower Level (Becoming): World of appearances known through sensory experience.
Upper Level (Being): World of Forms known through intellectual reasoning.
Objects ranked in importance:
Images (e.g., shadows)
Material Objects (e.g., trees, rocks)
Mathematical Objects (e.g., numbers, shapes)
Forms (e.g., concepts of justice, beauty).
Theory of Forms
Forms represent the highest reality in Plato’s philosophy:
These concepts are known by higher understanding, unlike material objects perceived through the senses.
Mathematical concepts are more real than physical objects as they exist independently of individual minds.
Properties of Forms
Universal, unchanging, and eternal.
Material objects reflect or participate in these Forms but are inherently flawed.
The Role of the Demiurge
The Demiurge is a divine craftsman shaping the world according to Forms and mathematical principles, ensuring that material objects are imperfect copies of ideal Forms.
The Good
The ultimate goal of existence, analogous to the sun, illuminating understanding and the Forms.
Interpretation of the Good may vary; either as the light of reason or the unity among Forms.
Human Nature
Defined by Plato as a dualist perspective:
Composition of body and soul.
The soul, seen as the essence of a person, endures beyond physical existence.
Parts of the Soul
Plato describes three parts of the soul:
Rational Part (driver of the chariot): Seeks wisdom and knowledge of the Forms.
Spirit Part (calm horse): Associated with emotions, needing wise channeling.
Appetitive Part (unruly horse): Desires bodily pleasures and material gain.
A harmonious balance among these parts is essential for a flourishing life.
Implications for Society
Societies reflect the structure of the soul, consisting of different classes:
Rulers (driven by reason)
Warriors (driven by spirit)
Producers (driven by appetites).
Ideal societal structure requires that each class fulfills its role to achieve harmony and excellence.
Paternalism in Plato's State
Argues for restrictions on individual liberties to promote the collective good, akin to parental guidance.
Rulers, having the most knowledge, govern to ensure the best outcomes for society as a whole.
Education and Ethics
Plato emphasized education as the means to understand the Forms and achieve moral virtues.
The pursuit of true knowledge is essential for the good life and happiness.
Philosophy and Death
In Phaedo, Socratic view posits that philosophers seek to understand the Forms, seeing death not as an end but as a release of the soul to return to the world of Forms.
Conclusion: Plato's Vision of the Good Life
Ideal existence centers around the pursuit of wisdom and understanding, shaped by a structured society led by philosopher-kings who ensure a flourishing life for all citizens, balancing the needs of the soul's parts.
Rationalism and Plato's Philosophy
Definition of Rationalism:
A philosophical viewpoint suggesting knowledge is gained primarily through reason rather than empirical evidence.
Rationalists show less dependence on sensory experience to determine what is true.
Plato's Viewpoint:
Critiques reliance on senses, believing that the material world is in a constant state of flux.
Real knowledge comes from reason, not from shifting material objects that may deceive.
Allegory of the Cave: Literary Device
Description:
Depicts prisoners in a cave, chained to only see the wall before them, unaware of the true forms behind them.
Context of Shadows: Shadows of objects projected on the wall by a fire, representing the prisoners' reality; prisoners interpret these shadows as the entirety of reality.
Escape from the Cave:
One prisoner breaks free and realizes the shadows are mere reflections of real objects, leading to true reality awareness.
Plato's Message:
Different levels of reality exist; individuals must seek knowledge beyond material appearances.
Illustrates the philosopher's role in leading others to enlightenment.
The Divided Line: Visual Representation
Sections illustrate different levels of understanding and reality:
Visible Realm: Sections C and D.
D: Epistemic state of illusion involving perceptions and shadows, leading to misinterpretations.
C: Epistemic state of belief concerning physical objects perceived through senses, seen as inferior to knowledge.
Intelligible Realm: Sections A and B.
B: Epistemic state involving mathematical reasoning; higher reality due to abstract and unchanging nature compared to material objects.
A: Epistemic state of intelligence, allowing comprehension of the forms, which are unchanging ideals beyond the physical world.
Concepts Explained
Appearance vs. Reality:
Material and sensory experiences lead to a less reliable form of reality (appearances).
Forms:
True reality is the world of forms—perfect, unchanging ideas like beauty, justice, and essence of things (e.g., what makes an apple an apple).
Implications of the Allegory and Divided Line
Critique of Conventional Wisdom
Encourages questioning societal norms and appearances; challenges the naive realism of the scientific worldview.
Plato argues knowledge gained through senses cannot be entirely trusted; rational inquiry is essential for genuine understanding.
The Role of Philosophers
Plato’s philosopher kings understand the forms and integrate this knowledge into the physical world, enhancing societal understanding of ideals.
Educators guide others toward realization, supporting the development of critical and independent thinking.
Existential Reflections
Allegory and divided line raise questions about reality and knowledge—what is true knowledge versus mere belief?
Engaging with deeper philosophical concepts can lead to enlightenment but may also be painful, requiring reassessment of long-held beliefs.
Conclusion
Philosophical Method of Education
True knowledge must be actively sought, causing discomfort; not merely injected into passive minds.
Critiques models of education positioning students as passive recipients, endorsing active participation and desire in educational journeys.
Allegory serves as a metaphor for the journey toward enlightenment, emphasizing the importance of pursuing deeper understanding over comfortable illusions.
Tradition and Innovation
By discussing the allegory's societal applications (e.g., governance, media influence), students appreciate its relevance to contemporary issues in philosophy and education.
Additional Topics
Plato’s Central Doctrines
The world appearing to our senses is defective and error-prone; there is a more real realm filled with entities (Forms) that are eternal and changeless.
Important abstract objects: goodness, beauty, equality, bigness, likeness, unity, being, sameness, difference, change, and changelessness.
Plato’s Puzzles
Many writings display dissatisfaction with doctrines they advocate, exploring questions of forms, knowledge, and naming without overt answers.
Dialogue, Setting, Character
Nearly all writings take the form of dialogue; significant exceptions: Apology and a collection of possibly spurious letters.
Philosophical discussions depicted are not fictional narratives but lively debates among identifiable historical figures.
Many dialogues comment on and criticize the social milieu of interlocutors.
Socrates
Socrates speaks in nearly all dialogues except Laws; plays a prominent role as the dominant speaker.
Authentic portrayal of Socrates' philosophical methods—engaging yet indirect.
Plato’s Indirectness
Choice of Socrates as the dominant speaker reveals a deep engagement with his ideas; however, Plato's dialogues are not mere reflections of Socratic thought.
Plato’s Mind
Important questions arise regarding how to interpret authorial intent; differentiating between character assertions and Plato's philosophical beliefs is complex.
Links Between Dialogues
Connections can be traced across dialogues but require familiarity with previous works for understanding new arguments.
Does Plato Change His Mind about Forms?
Ongoing inquiry into whether and how Plato's conception of forms evolved throughout his writings is critical to understanding his philosophy.
Does Plato Change His Mind about Politics?
Examination of political views across dialogues suggests a potential evolution of thought concerning governance and societal structure.
Historical Socrates
Distinctions made between early, middle, and late dialogues signify how Socrates shifts from historical figure to vehicle for Plato's philosophical ideas.
Why Dialogues?
Exploring the reasons behind the dialogue form reveals multiplicity in purposes and enhances reader engagement with philosophical issues.
Bibliography
Primary Literature:
Cooper, J.M. (ed.), 1997, Plato: Complete Works, Indianapolis: Hackett.
Burnyeat, M., and Frede, M., 2015, The Pseudo-Platonic Seventh Letter, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Secondary Literature:
Ahbel-Rappe, S., and Kamtekar, R. (eds.), 2006, A Companion to Socrates, Oxford: Blackwell.
Allen, D., S., 2010, Why Plato Wrote, Malden, MA: Wiley-Blackwell.
Annas, J., 2003, Plato: A Very Short Introduction, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Benson, H. (ed.), 2006, A Companion to Plato, Oxford: Blackwell.
Blondell, R., 2002, The Play of Character in Plato’s Dialogues, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
… [List continued for all cited literature]