M

Bio Radiometric Dating

Dating fossils: relative dating and radiometric dating

  • Purpose of dating fossils: determine the order of events in life's history and understand what came before what, to decipher the history of life on Earth and support evolution by natural selection.
  • Absolute vs relative dating:
    • Relative dating identifies which fossils are older or younger based on the layers of rock (stratigraphy) where the fossil was found.
    • Absolute dating uses radioactive isotopes to assign numerical ages to fossils.
  • Carbon-14 dating (a key radiometric method mentioned):
    • In living organisms, the ratio of carbon-12 to carbon-14 stays relatively constant as C-14 is continually formed in the atmosphere and incorporated during life.
    • After death, C-14 decays, changing the ratio of C-14 to C-12 over time.
    • The graph discussed shows time vs. the fraction of the parent isotope remaining, with half-life being the time it takes to reach half of the initial amount.
    • The general relationship for radioactive decay (fraction remaining) can be written as:
      f(t) = iggl(\frac{1}{2}\biggr)^{\frac{t}{T{1/2}}} where $T{1/2}$ is the half-life.
  • Time scales mentioned:
    • Life began approximately between 3.4 \times 10^9 \text{ and } 3.8 \times 10^9\ \text{years ago}.
    • Humans are described as roughly 4.0 \times 10^5\ \text{years old} in the context of discussing recent appearances and relative timescales.
  • Takeaway: Absolute dating provides numerical ages for fossils, complementing the relative dating provided by stratigraphy, and together they support a long history of life and evolution.
  • Philosophical/narrative link: These dating methods build the empirical backbone for evolution by demonstrating long timescales over which life changes can accumulate.

Fossil record: extinction, transitional forms, and vestigial traits

  • Extinction as evidence for change over time:
    • Not all species persist; extinction is a universal fate for lineages, including humans.
    • Historical debate: early views of special creation resisted extinction; evidence from fossils led to acceptance that species can go extinct.
    • Example: Georges Coupier (Georges Cuvier) found fossils of the Irish elk, a megafauna species whose size implied it could not exist today, providing undeniable evidence of extinction and supporting the idea that species change over time.
  • Fossil succession and relatedness:
    • Fossils in a stratigraphic column show related species appearing in a sequence; higher layers contain younger fossils and often related species to those in lower layers.
    • Geological processes like plate movements can complicate layering, but the overall pattern supports descent with modification.
  • Transitional features: evidence of gradual change over time
    • Transitional features are traits that are intermediate between ancestral and derived species.
    • Example: the transition from aquatic fin to terrestrial limb in tetrapods, evidenced by fossil sequences dated around 385 Ma to 365 Ma (million years ago).
    • Description notes: in earlier fossils, limb morphology is less differentiated; in later fossils, the morphology resembles later limbs more closely, illustrating an intermediate form.
    • These transitional arrangements provide explicit evidence that species change through time.
  • Law of succession (historical context):
    • Fossil species tend to resemble living species in the same geographic regions, supporting a shared ancestry and gradual change over time.
  • Vestigial traits and their significance:
    • Vestigial traits are reduced or incompletely developed structures that no longer serve their original function but remain recognizable.
    • Examples cited include goosebumps (arrector pili muscles that raise hairs) and the coccyx.
    • Vestigial traits illustrate that while some structures persist, their function may change or be lost, which is inconsistent with special creation and supportive of evolutionary history.
  • Vestigial traits as evidence of change:
    • The presence of vestigial traits indicates that organisms have inherited features from ancestors that had a function in those ancestors, but that function has diminished or changed over time.
  • Concept recap: three key fossil-record concepts for evolution and change over time
    • Extinction demonstrates that species come and go.
    • Transitional features show stepwise change between ancestral and derived forms.
    • Vestigial traits reveal remnants of past functionality and common ancestry.

Direct observation and contemporary examples of evolution

  • Direct, observable evolution in real time:
    • A powerful line of evidence is observing evolutionary change in populations with short generation times.
    • Examples include fruit flies and moths showing population-level changes over generations.
  • COVID-19 pandemic as a clear example of ongoing evolution:
    • The global emergence of SARS-CoV-2 variants demonstrated rapid evolution and mutation.
    • Variants (e.g., Omicron) shifted in frequency over time, as shown by CDC graphs tracking the percent of different variants from Jan 2001 to Dec 2021 (note the 2001-2021 range mentioned in the text; the exact years in the transcript reflect a framing, not a precise dataset).
    • Mutations are discrete changes in the viral genome that alter the virus's characteristics (e.g., transmissibility, immune escape).
    • The virus continues to evolve as it reproduces rapidly in large populations.
  • Other observed evolutionary processes in the modern world:
    • Insecticide resistance in pest populations (evolutionary response to human actions).
    • Changes in migration patterns and timing (phenology) of birds and insects (response to environmental changes).
  • Practical implications for medicine and public health:
    • A solid understanding of evolution is essential in medicine; misuse or misunderstanding of evolution can hinder patient care.
    • Drug resistance in pathogens arises through evolutionary processes; anticipating and countering resistance requires evolutionary thinking.
    • The ongoing mutation of viruses underscores the importance of surveillance and adaptable treatment strategies.
  • The big takeaway about direct observation:
    • Evolutionary change can be directly observed in nature when generation times are short and selection pressures are present.
    • This observational evidence complements fossil and comparative data to support evolution by natural selection.

Biogeography, phylogenetics, and homology as lines of evidence

  • Biogeography: the geographic distribution of species
    • The distribution patterns across archipelagos (e.g., Galápagos) show that related species can diverge when populations become isolated on different islands.
    • Darwin's mockingsbirds and finches illustrate how a single ancestor can radiate into multiple related species under different habitat conditions (island biogeography).
    • Islands provide a setting for rare dispersal events that initiate allopatric divergence and adaptive radiation.
  • The role of phylogenetic trees (biogenetic trees) in understanding relationships
    • Phylogenies summarize evolutionary relationships inferred from shared traits, genetics, and fossil data.
    • Reading phylogenetic trees is a foundational skill for understanding relatedness among species and the timeline of divergences.
    • A modern twist: DNA analysis supports historical inferences (e.g., Galápagos mockingbirds show closer relationships consistent with Darwin's biogeographic observations).
  • Homology vs homoplasy (convergent similarity)
    • Homology: similarity due to descent from a common ancestor; homologous traits reflect shared evolutionary origin.
    • Structural and genetic homologies are common forms of evidence for common ancestry.
    • Not all similarities are homologous: some arise by convergent evolution where similar environments select for similar features independently (homoplasy).
    • Example discussion: whether a particular similarity (e.g., fins with strong tails) is homologous; this requires tracing the common ancestry and developmental pathways.
    • Distinction example: Ichthyosaurus and dolphins may show superficial similarity due to running into similar ecological roles, but the underlying ancestry and development determine whether that similarity is homologous or a product of convergent evolution.
  • Genetic homology and developmental genetics (briefly introduced)
    • Genetic homology: similarities in DNA sequences that reflect shared ancestry and can explain conserved developmental pathways.
    • Developmental genetics can explain macroevolutionary changes by turning genes on or off during development (e.g., tail development in certain lineages).
    • The tail example (from the transcript) illustrates how changing gene expression can alter morphology over evolutionary time.
  • Practical takeaway about homology and biogeography:
    • Homology provides a testable link to common ancestry, which supports the tree of life.
    • Biogeography provides a geographical context for lineage splits and dispersal events that shape phylogenies.
    • Convergent evolution (homoplasy) explains why some traits look similar across distant taxa but do not reflect close common ancestry.

Putting it all together: evidence for evolution and foundational ideas

  • Four main kinds of evidence discussed in the material:
    • Fossil record evidence: extinction, transitional features, and vestigial traits collectively demonstrate change over time and common ancestry.
    • Direct observation: real-time evolutionary changes observed in populations (e.g., viruses, pests, and other organisms with short generation times).
    • Biogeography: geographic distribution of related species supports common ancestry and adaptive radiations in isolated environments.
    • Homology (and phylogenetics): similarities due to descent from a common ancestor and the reconstruction of evolutionary relationships.
  • Foundational idea: natural selection drives evolution
    • The combination of fossil, observational, biogeographic, and genetic evidence supports the view that species change over time through natural selection and other evolutionary processes.
  • Ethical and practical implications:
    • In medicine and public health, understanding evolution informs vaccine design, antibiotic stewardship, and anticipating pathogen evolution.
    • In conservation biology, recognizing historical extinction patterns and adaptive radiations helps prioritize habitat protection and species management.
    • In education, presenting multiple lines of evidence strengthens understanding and counters misconceptions about creationist viewpoints.
  • Note on terminology and ongoing learning:
    • The course will continue to cover how to read phylogenetic trees, understand homology vs homoplasy in more depth, and explore the processes that generate biodiversity (e.g., mutation, gene flow, genetic drift, selection).
  • Quick reference to key numbers and terms mentioned:
    • Absolute dating: uses radioactive decay to assign numerical ages to fossils.
    • Relative dating: places fossils in a sequence based on strata.
    • Carbon-14 dating concept: living organisms maintain a constant C-12/C-14 ratio; post-mortem decay changes the ratio.
    • Fraction remaining: f(t) = \left(\frac{1}{2}\right)^{\frac{t}{T_{1/2}}}
    • Timeline examples: 385 Ma, 375 Ma, 365 Ma (transitional limb evidence in tetrapod evolution).
    • Life origin timescale: 3.4 \times 10^9 \text{ to } 3.8 \times 10^9\ \text{years ago}.
    • Human presence: 4.0 \times 10^5\ \text{years}.
    • Term abbreviations: vestigial traits (VT).
  • Closing thought: The fossil record, modern observations, biogeography, and homologous structures together provide a coherent, testable framework for understanding evolution by natural selection, with direct relevance to science, medicine, and everyday life.

Notes summary and study cues

  • Understand the difference between relative and absolute dating and why both are important.
  • Be able to explain how carbon dating works and write the decay relation formula.
  • Remember key fossil-record concepts: extinction, transitional features, vestigial traits, and law of succession.
  • Recognize real-world examples of evolution in action (COVID variants, insecticide resistance, migration/phenology changes).
  • Distinguish between homology and homoplasy; know why biogeography and phylogenetics are powerful tools for inferring relatedness.
  • Be able to describe how island biogeography can drive adaptive radiations (e.g., mockingbirds and Darwin’s finches).
  • Prepare to discuss the practical implications of evolution in medicine and public health.