IR307 guest speaker Refugee Resettlement and HIAS History
Understanding Refugee Resettlement
Asylum in the United States
Individuals in the U.S. or at its border with a well-founded fear of persecution based on race, religion, nationality, social group, or political opinion have the right to apply for asylum.
This right stems from the U.S. being a party to the Refugee Convention of 1951 and its 1967 Protocol, codified into international law in 1980.
Crucially, this right does not extend to individuals outside the U.S. (e.g., at an embassy).
Refugee settlement from abroad typically requires an invitation from the U.S. government, meaning individuals are 'handpicked'.
The Meskhetian Turk Resettlement Program
The Meskhetian Turks, living as refugees in Krasnodar, Southern Russia, could not directly apply for asylum from there.
They were invited by the U.S. government to apply for refugee settlement as a group of special humanitarian concern.
Approximately 15,000 Meskhetian Turks were resettled to the U.S. through this program.
Benefits of Refugee Status in the U.S.
Upon arrival, refugees immediately gain the right to work and the right to family unity (to bring immediate relatives).
After 1 year, they are expected to apply for a green card.
After 5 years, they can apply for U.S. citizenship.
Transformation of the Meskhetian Turks
The Meskhetian Turks transitioned from being stateless individuals, expelled from Georgia in 1944, living in Uzbekistan, and then persecuted in Russia, to becoming American citizens within their own community.
Critique of Refugee Program Shutdown
The speaker strongly criticizes the shutdown of the refugee settlement program by the Trump administration on January 20.
This program is described as a safe and legal migration route, preventing desperate individuals from risking their lives through unauthorized border crossings.
Even 128,000 refugees, already approved for refugee status by Homeland Security, were unable to enter due to an executive order issued on January 20.
Historical Bi-partisanship
In the 1980s, refugee issues were largely bipartisan, with both Republicans and Democrats supporting the program.
The Refugee Act of 1980, which established the modern refugee program, passed unanimously in the Senate and almost unanimously in the House of Representatives, a level of consensus unimaginable in today's political climate.
HIAS: History and Evolving Mission
Founding and Early Mission (Pre-1920s)
HIAS (Hebrew Immigrant Aid Society) was founded on Valentine's Day, 1903, in response to violent pogroms against Jews across the Russian Empire (e.g., the Kishinev pogrom in April 1903).
Its initial purpose was to provide refuge in the U.S. for Jews fleeing persecution in Eastern Europe.
Operating from Ellis Island in New York, HIAS assisted Jewish refugees with immigration authorities, provided kosher food, and offered shelter (the Joseph Papp Theater on Lafayette Street served as a headquarters and shelter for decades).
This period saw the largest mass migration of Jews since their expulsion from the Iberian Peninsula 400 years prior.
At this time, advanced permission to enter the U.S. was not required; immigrants only needed to prove they were 'invisible' (self-sufficient) upon arrival at Ellis Island.
Shift to International Agency (Early 1920s onwards)
In the early 1920s, HIAS transformed into a more international agency due to new U.S. immigration laws that were intentionally discriminatory.
The 1921 and 1924 Quota Acts instilled very low quotas for Eastern and Southern Europeans (Catholics and Jews), explicitly aimed at preventing their large-scale immigration.
Legislators used openly racist and antisemitic language, expressing concerns about losing the U.S.'s
Understanding Refugee Resettlement
Asylum in the United States
Individuals present in the U.S. or at its border possess a fundamental right to apply for asylum. This right is granted if they can demonstrate a "well-founded fear of persecution" based on five specific grounds: race, religion, nationality, membership in a particular social group, or political opinion. This legal protection is a cornerstone of humanitarian law.
This crucial right is derived from the U.S.'s commitment as a signatory to the 1951 Refugee Convention and its 1967 Protocol. These international agreements established the definition of a refugee and the principle of non-refoulement, preventing states from returning refugees to places where their lives or freedom would be threatened. The principles from these international documents were then codified into U.S. domestic law under the Refugee Act of 1980, solidifying the legal framework for asylum.
Importantly, this protection does not extend to individuals who are outside U.S. territory, even if they are at a U.S. embassy or consulate abroad. For those outside the U.S. seeking refuge, typical refugee settlement from abroad often requires a direct invitation from the U.S. government, meaning individuals are 'handpicked' for resettlement through specific programs rather than being able to apply unilaterally.
The Meskhetian Turk Resettlement Program
The Meskhetian Turks, an ethnic group with a complex history of displacement, were living as refugees in Krasnodar, Southern Russia. Due to their location outside U.S. territory, they were unable to directly apply for asylum as individuals from there.
Recognizing their unique vulnerability and ongoing persecution, the U.S. government extended an invitation to the Meskhetian Turks to apply for refugee settlement as a specific group of humanitarian concern. This was a targeted humanitarian initiative to address a pressing crisis for a stateless population.
Through this dedicated program, approximately 15,000 Meskhetian Turks were successfully resettled to the U.S., finding a new home and an opportunity to rebuild their lives in safety.
Benefits of Refugee Status in the U.S.
Upon their arrival in the United States, individuals granted refugee status immediately receive significant benefits. These include the right to work, providing them with economic independence and the ability to contribute to their new communities, and the right to family unity, which allows them to bring immediate relatives (spouses and unmarried children under 21) to join them, fostering social cohesion and support networks.
After residing in the U.S. for just 1 year with refugee status, they are legally mandated and expected to apply for a green card (permanent residency), marking the next step toward long-term stability.
Furthermore, after maintaining green card status for 5 years (which includes the initial year as a refugee), they become eligible to apply for U.S. citizenship, offering full integration, political participation, and the highest level of protection available in the country.
Transformation of the Meskhetian Turks
The resettlement program catalyzed a profound transformation for the Meskhetian Turks. This community had been expelled from their Georgian homeland in 1944, subsequently lived in Uzbekistan, and later endured persecution in Russia. Their journey was one of consistent statelessness and displacement.
Through the U.S. refugee program, they transitioned from being a stateless, persecuted population to becoming American citizens, establishing stable lives within their own vibrant communities in the United States. This provided them with legal standing, security, and a sense of belonging they had lacked for decades.
Critique of Refugee Program Shutdown
The speaker voiced strong criticism regarding the abrupt shutdown of the refugee settlement program by the Trump administration on January 20. This action significantly curtailed a vital humanitarian pathway.
This program was highly valued as a safe, legal, and orderly migration route, designed to prevent desperate individuals from being forced into dangerous, unauthorized border crossings, often involving significant risks to their lives at the hands of traffickers.
The impact of the executive order was immediate and far-reaching, affecting even those who had already successfully navigate the rigorous vetting process. A staggering 128,000 refugees, who had already been approved for refugee status by Homeland Security and undergone extensive background checks, were unable to enter the U.S. due to the sudden implementation of this executive order, leaving them in precarious situations globally.
Historical Bi-partisanship
In the 1980s, refugee issues were characterized by a remarkable degree of consensus and cooperation across the political spectrum. Both Republican and Democratic parties largely supported humanitarian refugee programs, viewing them as a moral imperative and a reflection of American values.
A testament to this bipartisan spirit was the passage of the Refugee Act of 1980, which codified the modern U.S. refugee program based on international standards. This landmark legislation passed unanimously in the Senate and nearly unanimously in the House of Representatives, a level of legislative consensus on a significant issue that is virtually unimaginable and rarely seen in the highly polarized political climate of today.
HIAS: History and Evolving Mission
Founding and Early Mission (Pre-1920s)
HIAS (Hebrew Immigrant Aid Society) was established on Valentine's Day, February 14, 1903. Its founding was a direct and urgent response to the widespread violence of pogroms against Jewish communities throughout the Russian Empire, most notably the devastating Kishinev pogrom in April 1903, which spurred a mass exodus.
The initial and primary purpose of HIAS was to provide sanctuary and assistance in the U.S. for Jewish individuals and families desperately fleeing persecution, violence, and systematic discrimination in Eastern Europe.
Operating from its strategic location at Ellis Island in New York, HIAS played a critical role in assisting Jewish refugees. They provided crucial aid in navigating complex immigration authorities, ensured access to kosher food to maintain religious observance, and offered vital temporary shelter. For many decades, the building that now houses the Joseph Papp Theater on Lafayette Street served as a central headquarters and shelter, providing a safe haven for countless newcomers.
This period represented one of the most significant and largest mass migrations of Jewish people since their traumatic expulsion from the Iberian Peninsula approximately 400 years prior, fundamentally reshaping Jewish life globally.
During this era, the process for entering the U.S. was different from today; advanced permission was not typically required. Instead, arriving immigrants only needed to prove they were 'invisible' upon arrival at Ellis Island, meaning they could demonstrate self-sufficiency and would not become a public charge, essentially showing they had the means or connections to support themselves.
Shift to International Agency (Early 1920s onwards)
In the early 1920s, HIAS underwent a significant transformation, evolving from a primarily domestic aid organization to a more robust international agency. This shift was necessitated by profound changes in U.S. immigration policy that were intentionally discriminatory.
The passage of the 1921 and 1924 Quota Acts marked a turning point. These legislative acts introduced highly restrictive and very low quotas specifically targeting immigrants from Eastern and Southern Europe, a demographic that included large populations of Catholics and Jews. The explicit aim of these laws was to prevent the continued large-scale immigration of these groups.
The legislative debates surrounding these acts were characterized by openly racist and antisemitic language, with policymakers expressing overt concerns about maintaining the perceived racial and cultural homogeneity of the U.S. and losing what they considered the country's dominant 'Anglo-Saxon' character. This discriminatory environment forced HIAS to broaden its scope beyond U.S. borders, working to resettle refugees in other countries as well.
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
Understanding Refugee Resettlement
Asylum in the United States
Individuals present in the U.S. or at its border possess a fundamental right to apply for asylum. This right is granted if they can demonstrate a "well-founded fear of persecution" based on five specific grounds: race, religion, nationality, membership in a particular social group, or political opinion. This legal protection is a cornerstone of humanitarian law.
This crucial right is derived from the U.S.'s commitment as a signatory to the 1951 Refugee Convention and its 1967 Protocol. These international agreements established the definition of a refugee and the principle of non-refoulement, preventing states from returning refugees to places where their lives or freedom would be threatened. The principles from these international documents were then formally codified into U.S. domestic law under the landmark Refugee Act of 1980, solidifying the legal framework for asylum and moving away from previous ad-hoc definitions based on Cold War-era 'escapees'.
Importantly, this protection does not extend to individuals who are outside U.S. territory, even if they are at a U.S. embassy or consulate abroad. For those outside the U.S. seeking refuge, typical refugee settlement from abroad often requires a direct invitation from the U.S. government, meaning individuals are 'handpicked' for resettlement through specific programs rather than being able to apply unilaterally.
The Meskhetian Turk Resettlement Program
The Meskhetian Turks, an ethnic group with a complex history of displacement, were living as refugees in Krasnodar, Southern Russia. Due to their location outside U.S. territory, they were unable to directly apply for asylum as individuals from there.
Recognizing their unique vulnerability and ongoing persecution, the U.S. government extended an invitation to the Meskhetian Turks to apply for refugee settlement as a specific group of humanitarian concern. This was a targeted humanitarian initiative to address a pressing crisis for a stateless population, consistent with the humanitarian principles established by the Refugee Act of 1980.
Through this dedicated program, approximately 15,000 Meskhetian Turks were successfully resettled to the U.S., finding a new home and an opportunity to rebuild their lives in safety.
Benefits of Refugee Status in the U.S.
Upon their arrival in the United States, individuals granted refugee status immediately receive significant benefits. These include the right to work, providing them with economic independence and the ability to contribute to their new communities, and the right to family unity, which allows them to bring immediate relatives (spouses and unmarried children under 21) to join them, fostering social cohesion and support networks.
After residing in the U.S. for just 1 year with refugee status, they are legally mandated and expected to apply for a green card (permanent residency), marking the next step toward long-term stability.
Furthermore, after maintaining green card status for 5 years (which includes the initial year as a refugee), they become eligible to apply for U.S. citizenship, offering full integration, political participation, and the highest level of protection available in the country.
Transformation of the Meskhetian Turks
The resettlement program catalyzed a profound transformation for the Meskhetian Turks. This community had been expelled from their Georgian homeland in 1944, subsequently lived in Uzbekistan, and later endured persecution in Russia. Their journey was one of consistent statelessness and displacement.
Through the U.S. refugee program, they transitioned from being a stateless, persecuted population to becoming American citizens, establishing stable lives within their own vibrant communities in the United States. This provided them with legal standing, security, and a sense of belonging they had lacked for decades.
Critique of Refugee Program Shutdown
The speaker voiced strong criticism regarding the abrupt shutdown of the refugee settlement program by the Trump administration on January 20. This executive action, as highlighted in