knowt logo

When Will We Care About Domestic Violence_ _ Caroline Fraser _ The New York Review of Books

Overview of Domestic Violence

  • Recent spikes in domestic violence due to the COVID-19 pandemic.

  • Increased calls to police and crisis centers globally.

  • Specific case examples illustrate the severity of the issue.

Surge in Domestic Violence Cases

Global Context

  • Reports of domestic abuse killings rising sharply during isolation periods:

    • 16 domestic violence killings in the UK within three weeks (March-April).

    • 30% increase in domestic violence calls in France.

  • Health care workers and advocates express concerns over lost contact with victims during quarantines.

Regional Data

  • United States:

    • National Domestic Violence Hotline reports increased calls.

    • Need for safety strategies, such as advice for women to find safe spaces during confrontations.

  • Other Countries:

    • China: Reports of severe beatings during lockdown.

    • Italy: Hotels requisitioned for victims when shelters closed.

Prevalence of Domestic Violence

Statistical Data

  • 137 women are killed daily by domestic partners worldwide.

  • 50% of women experience domestic abuse in their lifetime in certain countries.

  • Many nations still have laws that allow spousal violence.

Domestic Violence as a Public Health Crisis

  • Identified as a global epidemic by the World Health Organization.

  • Correlation between domestic violence and societal issues such as mass shootings.

  • Homicide statistics for African-American women and pregnant women in the US highlight vulnerability.

Relationship Between Domestic Violence and Mass Shootings

Key Findings

  • 54% of mass shootings in the US were associated with domestic violence.

  • Notable case studies of mass shootings linked to prior domestic abuse incidents.

  • Domestic violence recognized as a contributing factor to larger patterns of violence in society.

Economic and Social Costs

Financial Implications

  • The estimated economic burden of domestic violence: $3.6 trillion in the US.

    • Breakdown includes $2 trillion for medical expenses and $73 billion for criminal justice costs.

  • Domestic violence often underreported, misunderstood, and dismissed as a trivial issue.

Societal Perceptions

  • Language surrounding domestic violence can downplay its seriousness.

  • Terms like “intimate partner violence” or “intimate partner terrorism” are gaining traction.

Insights into the Perpetrators

Case Study: Jimmy Espinoza

  • Exploration of the mindset of a perpetrator and the cycle of abuse.

  • Espinoza’s rehabilitation efforts and the struggle of recognizing harmful behaviors.

Patterns of Abuse

  • Language and psychology used by abusers to manipulate and control.

  • Historical context of violence can lead to normalization of aggressive behaviors.

Victim Perspectives

Case Example: Michelle Monson Mosure

  • Chronicles the last days of Michelle’s life and her struggle with domestic violence.

  • Highlighted systemic failures in the legal response to her situation.

Systemic Challenges

  • Recantation of statements by victims often misinterpreted as unreliability, leading to fatal outcomes.

  • Importance of understanding victim behavior as a response to fear and lack of protection.

Policy and Legislative Efforts

Violence Against Women Act (VAWA)

  • Overview of VAWA since its introduction in 1994 and its bipartisan support over time.

  • Recent challenges to its reauthorization and the “boyfriend loophole” affecting gun possession.

Ongoing Advocacy

  • Calls for increased awareness and nuanced approaches to domestic violence.

  • Advocacy shifts towards understanding systemic issues rather than victim-blaming.

Conclusion

Need for Change

  • The urgency for societal change in attitudes towards domestic violence.

  • Acknowledgment that solving domestic violence requires recognizing it as a serious societal issue.

When Will We Care About Domestic Violence_ _ Caroline Fraser _ The New York Review of Books

Overview of Domestic Violence

  • Recent spikes in domestic violence due to the COVID-19 pandemic.

  • Increased calls to police and crisis centers globally.

  • Specific case examples illustrate the severity of the issue.

Surge in Domestic Violence Cases

Global Context

  • Reports of domestic abuse killings rising sharply during isolation periods:

    • 16 domestic violence killings in the UK within three weeks (March-April).

    • 30% increase in domestic violence calls in France.

  • Health care workers and advocates express concerns over lost contact with victims during quarantines.

Regional Data

  • United States:

    • National Domestic Violence Hotline reports increased calls.

    • Need for safety strategies, such as advice for women to find safe spaces during confrontations.

  • Other Countries:

    • China: Reports of severe beatings during lockdown.

    • Italy: Hotels requisitioned for victims when shelters closed.

Prevalence of Domestic Violence

Statistical Data

  • 137 women are killed daily by domestic partners worldwide.

  • 50% of women experience domestic abuse in their lifetime in certain countries.

  • Many nations still have laws that allow spousal violence.

Domestic Violence as a Public Health Crisis

  • Identified as a global epidemic by the World Health Organization.

  • Correlation between domestic violence and societal issues such as mass shootings.

  • Homicide statistics for African-American women and pregnant women in the US highlight vulnerability.

Relationship Between Domestic Violence and Mass Shootings

Key Findings

  • 54% of mass shootings in the US were associated with domestic violence.

  • Notable case studies of mass shootings linked to prior domestic abuse incidents.

  • Domestic violence recognized as a contributing factor to larger patterns of violence in society.

Economic and Social Costs

Financial Implications

  • The estimated economic burden of domestic violence: $3.6 trillion in the US.

    • Breakdown includes $2 trillion for medical expenses and $73 billion for criminal justice costs.

  • Domestic violence often underreported, misunderstood, and dismissed as a trivial issue.

Societal Perceptions

  • Language surrounding domestic violence can downplay its seriousness.

  • Terms like “intimate partner violence” or “intimate partner terrorism” are gaining traction.

Insights into the Perpetrators

Case Study: Jimmy Espinoza

  • Exploration of the mindset of a perpetrator and the cycle of abuse.

  • Espinoza’s rehabilitation efforts and the struggle of recognizing harmful behaviors.

Patterns of Abuse

  • Language and psychology used by abusers to manipulate and control.

  • Historical context of violence can lead to normalization of aggressive behaviors.

Victim Perspectives

Case Example: Michelle Monson Mosure

  • Chronicles the last days of Michelle’s life and her struggle with domestic violence.

  • Highlighted systemic failures in the legal response to her situation.

Systemic Challenges

  • Recantation of statements by victims often misinterpreted as unreliability, leading to fatal outcomes.

  • Importance of understanding victim behavior as a response to fear and lack of protection.

Policy and Legislative Efforts

Violence Against Women Act (VAWA)

  • Overview of VAWA since its introduction in 1994 and its bipartisan support over time.

  • Recent challenges to its reauthorization and the “boyfriend loophole” affecting gun possession.

Ongoing Advocacy

  • Calls for increased awareness and nuanced approaches to domestic violence.

  • Advocacy shifts towards understanding systemic issues rather than victim-blaming.

Conclusion

Need for Change

  • The urgency for societal change in attitudes towards domestic violence.

  • Acknowledgment that solving domestic violence requires recognizing it as a serious societal issue.

robot