Chapter 2 Review: Early American Settlements and Key Concepts
Colonial Settlement Types in English North America
Virginia (Jamestown): Founded almost entirely for economic profit, establishing isolated farmsteads rather than tightly knit communities.
New England: Established by religious dissidents seeking to remake civilization according to their own religious beliefs.
Protestant Dissidents: The New England settlers dissented from the Church of England and belonged to two primary groups:
Saints: Also known as Pilgrims.
Puritans.
Shared Theological Beliefs:
Individual interpretation of Holy Scripture.
Freedom of the individual conscience.
Total Depravity: The doctrine asserting that humans were completely loathsome to God due to the fall of Adam, and that God created or predestined specific individuals to populate Heaven and others to suffer in Hell.
Role of Virtue: A virtuous life was viewed as a sign of predestination, not as cooperation in the work of redemption.
New England Governance, Education, and Indian Relations
Mayflower Compact:
Signed by the Saints (Pilgrims) after leaving England without a formal royal charter.
Served as a written constitution that omitted any mention of tradition or custom.
Derived its authority directly from the consent of the governed.
Education System:
New England established the first free, public education (grammar schools) in the New World.
Founded the first college in English America in 1636.
Native American Interactions:
Multiple Indian tribes inhabited New England.
Micmac Tribe: Possessed a written language, received the Catholic faith, and intermarried with Europeans.
Internal and External Conflict: Puritans experienced internal disagreements and active warfare with local tribes.
King Philip's War: Fought between Englishmen and Native Americans, named after King Philip, the leader of the Wampanoag tribe. His Wampanoag name was Metacomet.
Colonial Legal Codes:
Massachusetts Body of Liberties (1641): Set of principles rooted in English law. Guaranteed free elections, trial by jury, protection against arbitrary seizures by authorities, prohibition of taxation without citizen input, and prohibition of self-incrimination in trials.
New Haven Colony: Contrastingly prohibited trial by jury and imposed the death penalty for adultery convictions.
The Southern and Middle Colonies
Virginia Colony:
Social enforcement legislation was influenced by Puritanism but was far less effective than in New England.
Head-Right System: Settlers received 50 acres of land for themselves and for every person they brought to Virginia, causing inhabitants to live widely separated on farmsteads.
Slavery: African slaves were first sold in Virginia in 1619, but as late as 1681, Virginians held very few slaves.
Education: Failed to develop a system of free public education in the 17th century.
Maryland Colony:
Practicing the Catholic faith had been illegal in England since 1535.
Sir George Calvert: A friend of the king who converted to Catholicism in 1625. Over the next seven years, he procured a New World charter to serve as a haven for English Catholics.
Demographics: Had a sizable Protestant (Anglican) population from its inception due to a shortage of willing English Catholic settlers. Protestants eventually outnumbered Catholics and enacted anti-Catholic penal laws similar to those in England.
Pennsylvania Colony:
Founding: Founded in 1682 by William Penn, located north of Maryland and southwest of New England.
Capital: Philadelphia ("City of Brotherly Love").
Policy: Penn practiced religious toleration, treated Indians justly, and allowed for the education and marriage of slaves (though the colonial assembly did not enshrine all these practices into law).
Attraction: Religious tolerance attracted settlers from the British Isles, continental Europe, and provided a haven for Catholics in "Penn's Woods."
New York and Dutch/Swedish Settlements:
Dutch: Established settlements on the Hudson River and Manhattan Island beginning in 1614 (or early 1615 with Fort Nassau).
Swedes and Finns: Established Fort Christina on the Delaware River, which was conquered by the Dutch in 1655.
English Acquisition: In 1664, the English seized Dutch possessions. New Amsterdam was renamed New York City after King Charles II's brother, James, Duke of York, who held it as a personal domain.
Political Evolution: Became a royal province when James ascended the throne as James II. His successor, William III, granted New York a colonial assembly.
Other English Colonies:
New Jersey and Delaware: Established in the early 18th century.
Georgia: Established three decades later by General James Oglethorpe as a "refuge for debtors."
Carolina: Located between Virginia and Georgia, later dividing into North Carolina and South Carolina.
Demographics, Economy, and Social Order (1660–1754)
Immigration Expansion: Population growth in the thirteen colonies between 1660 and 1754 was largely driven by immigration of Germans, French, English, Scots, and Irish.
Agricultural Economy:
Plantations: A small number of landowners in Maryland, Virginia, and southern colonies owned large plantations producing rice and tobacco.
Slave Trade: Plantations relied on imported West African slave labor, establishing a lucrative slave trade.
Farms: Most colonists lived on small family subsistence farms or larger "middle-class" farms.
Urban Centers: Thriving coastal towns complemented the agrarian countryside.
Core Social Principles: Beyond English common law, three primary principles governed colonial English society:
Hierarchy: The ordering of society where members are designated as above or below based on honor, rank, power, and authority.
Paternalism: The proper care shown by superiors to subordinates, though it can carry negative connotations if executed with condescension or selfish motives.
Interdependence: The reliance of each member of society on all other members for social functioning and general welfare.
Key Concepts and Terminology
Depravity: Wickedness or a very bad way of behaving.
Covenant: A formal or solemn agreement between two parties.
Incriminate: To make someone appear guilty of a crime. Self-incrimination occurs when an accused person gives witness or testimony against himself in a court proceeding.
Suffrage: The right to vote.
Hierarchy: Derived from Greek roots meaning "holy order"; the structural ordering of society where individuals are categorized into higher and lower stations based on criteria like rank, honor, authority, and power.
Paternalism: Derived from the Latin pater ("father"). Positively, it represents the protective care displayed by fathers and superiors toward children and subordinates. Negatively, it refers to an individual acting superior toward peers or a government treating citizens as lacking moral agency or thoughtful capacity, or a nation assisting another out of self-interest while claiming altruism.
Interdependence: The social principle asserting that every member of a society depends upon other members for collective well-being and systemic operations.
Chronology of Key Dates
1614 (or early 1615): The Dutch establish Fort Nassau.
1619: Virginia establishes the House of Burgesses, the first representative assembly in the New World.
1620: The Pilgrims arrive in Cape Cod Bay.
1625: Sir George Calvert converts to Catholicism.
1629: King Charles I grants the Massachusetts Bay Company the right to settle on Massachusetts Bay.
1632: Lord Baltimore founds Maryland.
1636: First college in English America is founded in New England.
1641: Massachusetts adopts the Body of Liberties.
1655: The Dutch conquer the Swedish settlement of Fort Christina.
1664: The English capture Dutch territory, renaming New Amsterdam to New York City.
1682: William Penn founds Pennsylvania.
1691: Plymouth Colony is incorporated into the Massachusetts Bay colony.
Central Historical Figures
John Winthrop (1588–1649): Leader of the Puritans in Massachusetts Bay Colony who famously described the settlement as a "city on a hill."
Roger Williams (ca. 1603–1683): A Puritan dissident who founded the Providence colony.
Metacomet (1638–1676): Wampanoag Indian leader also known as King Philip; led Native forces during King Philip's War.
George Calvert, First Lord Baltimore (ca. 1578–1632): English gentleman who converted to Catholicism in 1625 and initiated the founding of Maryland as a Catholic refuge.
Cecil Calvert, Second Lord Baltimore (1605–1675): Son of George Calvert who completed the establishment of the Maryland colony.
William Penn (1644–1718): English Quaker and founder of the Pennsylvania colony.
General James Oglethorpe: Founder of the colony of Georgia as a debtor refuge.
Primary Source Analysis: The Mayflower Compact
Historical Context and Survival:
The original 1620 document is lost; current knowledge relies on a reconstruction recorded in 1622.
Governed Plymouth until the settlement was merged into Massachusetts Bay Colony in 1691.
Created as a temporary governance system because the Pilgrims lacked a formal royal charter upon leaving England.
Text Analysis & Legal Formulas:
Opening Text: "In the name of God, Amen. We whose names are underwritten, the loyal subjects of our dread sovereign lord, King James, by the grace of God, of Great Britain, France, and Ireland, King, Defender of the Faith, etc."
Significance of Formulas: The inclusion of "etc." indicates a standardized legal formula. The title "Defender of the Faith" was originally granted to King Henry VIII by the Pope; despite rejecting papal authority and Catholic doctrine, the formula remained in official legal preamble.
Statement of Purpose and Consent:
Preamble Statement: "Having undertaken for the glory of God, and advancement of the Christian faith and honor of our king and country, a voyage to plant the first colony in the northern parts of Virginia, [we] do by these present, solemnly and mutually, in the presence of God and one of another, covenant and combine ourselves together into a civil body politic, for our better ordering and preservation and furtherance of the ends aforesaid…"
Grammatical Usage: "Covenant" is used directly as a verb rather than a noun.
Source of Legitimacy: Legitimacy was grounded in the mutual consent of the governed, appealing to high motives to construct a civil society without formal royal chartering.
Enactment of Law and Obligation:
Text: "…and by virtue hereof to enact, constitute, and frame such just and equal laws, ordinances, acts, constitutions, offices from time to time as shall be thought most meet and convenient for the general good of the colony; unto which we promise all due submission and obedience."
Political Shift: Despite acknowledging King James as sovereign, signatories bound themselves to yield submission and obedience to the newly established self-governing civil body politic.
Questions & Discussion Topics
Questions for Review
Name both the major and minor nationalities represented in England's North American colonies.
Identify at least two ways in which the New England colonies differed from the colonists of Virginia.
Which was the only Native American tribe in the New New England region to have a written language?
How did the suffrage come to non-Puritans in New England, when, and why?
Who compared New England to "a city upon a hill"? What did he mean by this name?
How was Maryland different from Massachusetts, in terms of the charters by which each was established?
How did the various groups of colonists interact with the Indians? Give at least three examples of these interactions, positive or negative.
What rights were guaranteed to the residents of Massachusetts by the Body of Liberties, and why?
What was the largest city in the colonies by the early 1700s? How did it compare in terms of size to cities in England?
What is "hierarchy," and why is it important to understand it in the context of pre-revolutionary America?
Ideas in Action
Colonial Music Study: Group analysis of music across five colonial cultures (Puritan, Anglican, English Catholic, French, and Spanish).
Space Colonization Governance Model: Consideration of governance rules for human settlements on the Moon, Mars, or distant planets; timing of agreements (prior to departure, before arrival, or post-landing); and foundational principles for new society rules.
Religious Tolerance vs. Indifference: Comparing Quaker practices in Pennsylvania and Catholic policies in Maryland against Puritan exclusivity. Evaluating the boundary where religious tolerance shifts into religious indifference (the view that all religions are equivalent or equally pleasing to God).