In the 1920s, it was falsely believed that frequency modulation (FM) could eliminate sidebands inherent in amplitude modulation (AM), leading to zero-bandwidth signals.
The idea was to modulate the carrier frequency ω(t) with m(t) such that ω(t)=ωc+km(t).
By making k arbitrarily small, the maximum and minimum frequencies of ω(t) would approach ωc, theoretically resulting in zero bandwidth.
This approach was unsuccessful.
Concept of Instantaneous Frequency
FM signals vary the instantaneous frequency in proportion to m(t).
Instantaneous frequency definition over less than one cycle of a sinusoid.
Frequency definition using a sinusoidal signal with a generalized angle θ(t): ϕ(t)=acosθ(t)
For a generalized angle θ(t) as a linear function: ϕ(t)=acos(ωct+θ0)
Relationship Between Phase and Frequency
Instantaneous frequency and generalized angle are related:
ωi(t)=dtdθ(t)
θ(t)=∫−∞tωi(α)dα
Phase Modulation (PM):
Modulating θ0(t) with m(t)
Frequency Modulation (FM):
Modulating ωi(t) with m(t)
Both PM and FM are types of angle modulation or exponential modulation.
Phase Modulation (PM)
Angle varied linearly with m(t): θ(t)=ωct+θ0+kpm(t), where kp is a constant and ωc is the carrier frequency.
Without generality loss, let θ0=0, then θ(t)=ωct+kpm(t).
The PM waveform: ϕ(t)=Acos(ωct+kpm(t))
Instantaneous frequency ωi(t)=dtdθ=ωc+kpm˙(t)
In PM, the frequency varies linearly with the derivative of m(t).
Frequency Modulation (FM)
Frequency varied linearly with m(t): ωi(t)=ωc+kfm(t), where kf is a constant regulating the magnitude of frequency modulation.
Angle θ(t) is given by: θ(t)=∫<em>−∞t[ωc+kfm(α)]dα=ωct+kf∫</em>−∞tm(α)dα
Assuming constant term in θ(t) to be zero (without loss of generality).
The FM waveform: ϕ(t)=Acos(ωct+kf∫−∞tm(α)dα)
FM and PM Relationship
PM and FM are similar and interchangeable.
Replacing m(t) with ∫m(α)dα changes PM into FM.
Replacing m(t) with m˙(t) changes FM into PM.
General Angle Modulation
Consider the angle θ(t) in PM (Fig 5.2b): H(s)=s
Use any linear function H(s) to filter m(t), i.e., ϕ<em>EM(t)=cos[ωct+ψ(t)]=cos[ωct+∫</em>−∞tm(α)h(t−α)dα]
H(s) must be reversible, i.e., one can obtain [H(s)]−1.
PM and FM are special cases with h(t)=kpδ(t) and h(t)=kpu(t) respectively.
Power of Angle Modulated Wave
Always 2A2
PM and FM Example - Indirect Method
Example 5.1: Sketch FM and PM waves for the modulating signal m(t)
Constants: kf=2×105 and kp=10π, carrier frequency fc=100 MHz.
The equation in terms of the variable f (frequency in hertz):
f<em>i=f</em>c+2πkfm(t)=108+105m(t)
(f<em>i)</em>min=108+105[m(t)]min=99.9 MHz
(f<em>i)</em>max=108+105[m(t)]max=100.1 MHz
Because m(t) increases and decreases linearly with time, the instantaneous frequency increases linearly from 99.9 to 100.1 MHz over a half-cycle and decreases linearly from 100.1 to 99.9 MHz over the remaining half-cycle of the modulating signal.
Because m˙(t) switches back and forth from a value of -20,000 to 20,000, the carrier frequency switches back and forth from 99.9 to 100.1 MHz every half-cycle of m˙(t).
PM and FM Example - Direct Method
Example 5.2: Sketch FM and PM waves for the digital modulating signal m(t)
Constants: kf=2π×105 and kp=π/2, and fc=100 MHz.
For FM:
f<em>i=f</em>c+2πkfm(t)=108+105m(t)
Because m(t) switches from 1 to -1 and vice versa, the FM wave frequency switches back and forth between 99.9 and 100.1 MHz.
Frequency shift keying (FSK) is a scheme of carrier frequency modulation by a digital signal, where information digits are transmitted by keying different frequencies.
For PM:
f<em>i=f</em>c+2π1kpm˙(t)=108+41m˙(t)
The derivative m˙(t) is zero except at points of discontinuity of m(t) where impulses of strength ±2 are present.
The frequency of the PM signal stays the same except at these isolated points of time.
Phase shift keying (PSK) is a scheme of carrier PM by a digital signal, because information digits are transmitted by shifting the carrier phase. Note that PSK may also be viewed as a DSB-SC modulation by m(t).
Phase discontinuities in 4PM(t) occur at instants where impulses of m˙(t) are located. At these instants, the carrier phase shifts by π instantaneously. A finite phase shift in zero time implies infinite instantaneous frequency at these instants.
The amount of phase discontinuity in PM(t) at the instant where m˙(t) is discontinuous is k<em>pm</em>d, where m<em>d is the amount of discontinuity in m˙(t) at that instant. In the present example, the amplitude of m˙(t) changes by 2 (from -1 to 1) at the discontinuity. Hence, the phase discontinuity in PM(t) is k</em>pmd=(π/2)×2=π rad
When m˙(t) is a digital signal, 4<em>pm(t) shows a phase discontinuity where m˙(t) has a jump discontinuity. To avoid ambiguity in demodulation, in such a case, the phase deviation k</em>pm(t) must be restricted to a range (−π,π). For example, if kp were 3π/2, then
Bandwidth of Angle Modulated Waves
Angle modulation is non-linear, and standard Fourier analysis can’t be used to determine bandwidth.
The signal ejβsinω<em>mt is a periodic signal with period 2π/ω</em>m, and can be expressed as an exponential Fourier series:
ejβsinω<em>mt=∑</em>−∞∞D<em>nejω</em>mt
D<em>n=2πω</em>m∫<em>−π/ω</em>mπ/ω<em>mejβsinω</em>mte−jnω<em>mtdt=2π1∫</em>−ππej(βsinx−nx)dx
*No analytic solution for the integral or the RHS, but can be approximated by an infinite series, the nth order Bessel function of the first kind Jn(β), i.e. eq (45) becomes
ejβsinω<em>mt=∑</em>−∞∞J<em>n(β)ejnω</em>mt
Tone FM Analysis (4)
Substituting into (44):
ϕ^<em>FM=A∑</em>−∞∞J<em>n(β)ej(ω</em>ct+nωmt)
ϕ<em>FM=A∑</em>−∞∞J<em>n(β)cos(ω</em>c+nωm)t
FM signal has carrier component and also infinite number of sidebands at ω<em>c±ω</em>m,ω<em>c±2ω</em>m,...,ω<em>c±nω</em>m
The strength of the nth sideband is Jn(β)
Jn(β) decreases with n, resulting in a finite number of significant spectral lines.
Single Tone FM Bandwidth
Jn(β) negligible when n > β + 1, hence the number of significant sideband impulses is β+1
The bandwidth of single tone FM is given by
B<em>FM=2(β+1)f</em>m=2(Δf+B)
This corresponds to the previous result.
When β << 1 (NBFM) then there is only one significant sideband and the bandwidth is 2B
Example 5.3
Estimate B<em>FM and B</em>PM for the modulating signal m(t) in Fig. 5.4a for kf=2×105 and kp=5. Assume the essential bandwidth of the periodic m(t) as the frequency of its third harmonic.
Repeat the problem if the amplitude of m(t) is doubled.
The peak amplitude of m(t) is unity. Hence, mp=1. Determine the essential bandwidth B of m(t).
The Fourier series for this periodic signal is given by
m(t)=∑C<em>ncosnω</em>0t
ω0=2×10−42π=104π
C_n = \frac{\begin{cases} \frac{8}{πn^2} & n \text{ odd} \ 0 & n \text{ even} \end{cases}
The harmonic amplitudes decrease rapidly with n. The third harmonic is only 11% of the fundamental, and the fifth harmonic is only 4% of the fundamental. This means the third and fifth harmonic powers are 1.21 and 0.16%, respectively, of the fundamental component power. Justified in assuming the essential bandwidth of m(t) as the frequency of its third harmonic, that is,
B=3×2π104=15kHz
For FM:
Δf=2π1k<em>fm</em>p=2π1(2π×105)(1)=100kHz
BFM=2(Δf+B)=2(100+15)=230kHz
Alternatively, the deviation ratio β is given by
β=BΔf=15100=6.66
BFM=2B(β+1)=30(6.66+1)=230kHz
For PM: The peak amplitude of m˙(t) is 20,000 and
Δf=2π1k<em>pm˙</em>p=50kHz
BPM=2(Δf+B)=130kHz
Example 5.4
Repeat Example 5.1 if m(t) is time-expanded by a factor of 2: that is, if the period of m(t) is 4×10−4.
Time expansion of a signal by a factor of 2 reduces the signal spectral width (bandwidth) by a factor of 2. This is verified by observing that the fundamental frequency is now 2.5 kHz, and its third harmonic is 7.5 kHz. Hence, B=7.5kHz, which is half the previous bandwidth. Moreover, time expansion does not affect the peak amplitude and thus m<em>p=1. However, m˙</em>p is halved, that is, m˙p=10,000.
For FM:
Δf=2π1k<em>fm</em>p=100kHz
BFM=2(Δf+B)=2(100+7.5)=215kHz
For PM:
Δf=2π1k<em>pm˙</em>p=25kHz
BPM=2(Δf+B)=65kHz
Note that time expansion of m(t) has very little effect on the FM bandwidth, but it halves the PM bandwidth. This verifies our observation that the PM spectrum is strongly dependent on the spectrum of m(t).
Example 5.5
An angle-modulated signal with carrier frequency wc=2×105π is described by the equation
ϕ<em>EM(t)=10cos(ω</em>ct+5sin3000πt+10sin2000πt)
Find:
the power of the modulated signal
the frequency deviation Af
the deviation ratio B
the phase deviation Aø.
Estimate the bandwidth
The signal bandwidth is the highest frequency in m(t) (or its derivative). In this case
B=2π2000π=1000Hz
The carrier amplitude is 10, and the power is
P==210250
To find the frequency deviation Af, find the instantaneous frequency @i, given by
The carrier deviation is 15,000cos3000t+20,000πcos2000πt.
The two sinusoids will add in phase at some point, and the maximum value of this expression is 15,000+20,000π. This is the maximum carrier deviation Δw. Hence,
Δw/=15,000+20,000π
Δf=2πΔω=12,387.32 Hz
(c)
B=BΔf=100012,387.32=12.387
The angle 0(t)=wt+(5sin3000t+10sin2000πt). The phase deviation is the maximum value of the angle inside the parentheses, and is given by A=15 rad.
Bem=2(Δf+B)=26,774.65Hz
FM and PM Generation
Two methods for generating FM:
Direct and Indirect
First consider indirect narrowband FM generation
NBFM Generation
NBFM and NBPM signals:
ϕ<em>FM=A[cosω</em>ct−k<em>fa(t)sinω</em>ct]
ϕ<em>PM=A[cosω</em>ct−k<em>pm(t)sinω</em>ct]
Both expressions are linear and similar to AM
Use DSB-SC modulators to perform NB-FM/PM modulation
NBFM has distortion and some amplitude modulation owing to approximation/omission of higher order terms
A nonlinear device called a bandpass limiter can remove most of the distortion
Bandpass Limiter
Consider a variable amplitude angle modulated signal:
vi(t)=A(t)cosθ(t)
where
θ(t)=ω<em>ct+k</em>f∫−∞tm(α)dα
The output of the hard limiter is
vo(θ)={+1amp;cos θ≥0−1amp;cos θlt;0
which is a rectangular wave with Fourier series expansion: vo(θ)=π4(cosθ−31cos3θ+51cos5θ−...)
The output of the hard limiter is angle modulated with
Discuss the nature of distortion inherent in the Armstrong indirect FM generator.
Two kinds of distortion arise in this scheme: amplitude distortion and frequency distortion.
The NBFM wave is given by:
ϕ<em>FM(t)=A[cosw</em>ct–k<em>fa(t)sinw</em>ct]
=AE(t)cos[wct+θ(t)]
where
E(t)=1+k2a2(t)
and
θ(t)=tan−1[kfa(t)]
Amplitude distortion occurs because the amplitude AE(t) of the modulated waveform is not constant. This is not a serious problem because amplitude variations can be eliminated by a bandpass limiter, as discussed earlier in the section (see also Fig. 5.9).
Ideally, θ(t) should be kfa(t). Instead, the phase θ(t) in the preceding equation is
=k<em>fm(t)[1–k2</em>fa2(t)+kf4a4(t)–…..]
Ideally, the instantaneous frequency should be kfm(t). The remaining terms in this equation are the distortion.
Let us investigate the effect of this distortion in tone modulation where
m(t)=acoswmt
a(t)=a(sinw<em>mt)/w</em>m
β=(ak<em>f)/w</em>m
Immunity from non-linearity: primary reason for use of FM in microwave relay systems (use of efficient class C high power non-linear amplifiers)
Constant amplitude FM provide immunity from rapid fading through AGC
FM was also used in 1G cellular, owing to immunity to fading
Effect of Interference on FM/PM
*FM/PM less vulnerable than AM to small signal interference from adjacent channels
Consider interference of unmodulated carrier A cos wct by another sinusoid I cos(wc + w)t.