Discussion questions 4

Definitions

What are the 3 levels of causality connecting unemployment to health?

  1. Proximal → individual

  2. Intermediate → household

  3. Distal → population

What are the differences between the demand-control model, the effort-reward model, the job demand resources model, and the transactional process model?

Demand-control

Karasek

Effort-reward

Siegrist

Job demand resources

Demerouti et al.

Transactional process

Lazarus and Folkman

  • High job demand (lots of work and responsibilities) + low job control (low autonomy) = exposure to stress

  • Can also include a 3rd dimension which is workplace social support from supervisors and colleagues

  • High job effort + low job rewards = exposure to stress

  • Concerns itself with organizational inequities

  • When people have excessive job demands and they exhaust their job resources (job security, rewards, pay…), they face stress

  • There are continuous interactions and adjustments between a person and their environment

  • There are 2 phases in this interaction: cognitive appraisal and coping

Explain the concept of isostrain?

  • When chronic stresses and excessive demands at work are not compensated by adequate social support

What is a metabolic syndrome?

  • It’s a cluster of conditions that increase the risk of heart disease, stroke, and type 2 diabetes

    → Employees in the lowest government jobs, clerical staff, are 2.7 times as likely to develop this syndrome than employees in the highest ranking government jobs

What is globalization?

  • Process of increased interdependence, rapid and inexpensive communications and transportation and the systematic removal of barriers to travel, communication, transporting goods and services, and moving money and other resources from one geographic place to another

What are knowledge economies?

  • Economies that focus on technical innovation and providing cutting-edge goods and services

What are the differences between de-industrialization, de-unionization, and de-skilling?

→ All caused by globalization

De-industrialization

De-unionization

De-skilling

The process of a decline in industrial activity marked by the shrinking of the manufacturing sector

The decline in the influence, membership, and presence of labor unions within a workforce or economy

Process by which workers' skills become less valuable or unnecessary → leads to jobs becoming more simplified + requiring less specialized knowledge

What is privatization?

  • Process of transferring ownership or control of businesses, industries, or services from the public sector (government) to the private sector (individuals or corporations)

    → Can lead to job losses and downsizing, shift to contract and temporary work, wage reductions and weakened worker protections, and skills/training shifts

Critical thinking questions

  1. The effort–reward model depends on our sense of fairness. In particular, it assumes that a sense of unfairness will cause considerable distress which in turn will affect our emotional, mental, and physical health. The demand–control model depends on our sense of self-efficacy. In particular, it assumes that we will experience our work life as “out of control” if other people or mechanical processes determine the amount and pace of work. A sense of lack of control over what we must respond to, in turn, will generate stress-causing emotional difficulties and illness. How adequate are these psychosocial models? What other assumptions about health-relevant mechanisms do they incorporate (or need to incorporate)?

 

 

  1. How do gender and employment interact? Which employment conditions typically affect mostly women? Men?

 

  1. How do ethnicity/race and employment interact? Which employment conditions typically affect mostly ethnic/racialized minorities?