Measuring Instruments - Unit 5

Overview of Measuring Instruments

  • Scope of Electrical Indicating Instruments:
    • Measuring instruments quantify essential electrical parameters including current, voltage, power, and electrical energy across both direct current (DC\text{DC}) and alternating current (AC\text{AC}) domains.
    • Primary instrument classifications covered include:
      • Analog Indicating Instruments
      • Permanent Magnet Moving Coil (PMMC\text{PMMC}) Ammeters and Voltmeters
      • Moving Iron (MI\text{MI}) Ammeters and Voltmeters
      • Dynamometer-type Instruments
      • Range Extension Systems (Shunts and Multipliers)
      • Wattmeters
      • AC\text{AC} Watt-hour Meters (Induction-type Energy Meters)
      • Digital Measuring Instruments (Digital Voltmeters, Ammeters, and Multimeters)

Damping Systems in Indicating Instruments

  • Necessity and Function of Damping Torque:

    • Damping torque is necessary to prevent oscillations of the instrument's moving system about its final deflected position caused by the mechanical inertia of the moving components.
    • In the absence of damping torque, the moving pointer and assembly oscillate continuously about the equilibrium position where the deflecting torque (TdT_d) equals the restoring/controlling torque (TcT_c).
    • The primary functional objective of any damping mechanism is to absorb kinetic energy from the oscillating moving system, bringing the pointer rapidly to rest at its steady-state reading.
  • Air Friction Damping:

    • Operating Mechanism: Utilizes a light aluminium piston that moves with minimal clearance inside a stationary air chamber closed at one end.
    • Action: When the pointer deflects and drives the piston rapidly into the chamber, the air trapped inside is compressed, generating a pressure differential that opposes the forward piston motion. Conversely, when moving outward, suction opposes the motion.
    • Advantages: Simple and inexpensive construction; avoids the use of permanent magnets, thereby preventing unwanted distortions of the operating magnetic field.
    • Applications: Primarily deployed in Moving Iron (MI\text{MI}) and Electrodynamometer-type instruments.

Air friction damping system with piston and chamber

  • Fluid Friction Damping:

    • Operating Mechanism: Light vanes are mounted directly onto the central spindle of the moving system and immersed completely in a damping pot filled with high-viscosity damping oil.
    • Action: The motion of the rotating assembly is continuously opposed by the shear friction and viscous drag exerted by the liquid against the submerged vanes.
    • Applications: Exclusively utilized in high-voltage electrostatic instruments.
  • Eddy Current Damping:

    • Operating Principle: Operates on the electromagnetic induction principle: when a non-magnetic, electrically conducting sheet or disc (such as copper or aluminium) moves through a stationary magnetic field, it cuts magnetic lines of force. This movement induces eddy currents within the conductor, which, in accordance with Lenz's Law, generate an opposing force that dampens the motion.
    • Characteristics: Represents the most efficient and responsive form of damping available.
    • Applications: Applied in instruments where an intense permanent magnetic field is already an integral part of the operating structure, most notably in Permanent Magnet Moving Coil (PMMC\text{PMMC}) instruments.

Fluid friction damping and eddy current damping configurations

Permanent Magnet Moving Coil (PMMC) Instruments

Permanent Magnet Moving Coil instrument schematic

  • Structural Components:

    • Moving Coil: Consists of multiple turns of fine enamelled copper wire wound onto a light, rectangular aluminium former pivoted between jewel bearings.
    • Magnetic System: Composed of permanent magnets made from high-coercivity magnetic alloys such as Alcomax and Alnico, which enable compact physical lengths while maintaining high magnetic field intensities. Operates at elevated magnetic flux densities typically spanning from 0.1 Wb/m20.1\,\text{Wb/m}^2 to 1 Wb/m21\,\text{Wb/m}^2.
    • Control System: Controlling torque is produced by a pair of phosphor bronze hairsprings. These hairsprings serve a dual role:
      • They act as electrical lead-in and lead-out conductors for passing the operating current into and out of the moving coil.
      • They supply the calibrated mechanical restoring (controlling) torque.
    • Damping System: Provided by eddy currents induced in the conductive aluminium former as it swings through the permanent magnet's radial field.
    • Pointer Assembly: A lightweight pointer mounted to the central spindle travels over a calibrated, graduated scale, balanced by counterweights.
  • Torque Equation and Mathematical Derivation:

    • The deflecting torque (TdT_d) developed by current interacting with the magnetic field:         Td=NBIAT_d = N B I A
      • Where:
        • NN = Number of turns in the moving coil
        • BB = Magnetic flux density in Wb/m2\text{Wb/m}^2
        • II = Current flowing through the coil in A\text{A}
        • AA = Effective area of the coil
    • The controlling torque (TcT_c) exerted by the phosphor bronze springs:         Tc=KθT_c = K \theta
      • Where:
        • KK = Spring constant
        • θ\theta = Deflection angle in radians
    • At the final steady-state equilibrium position (Tc=TdT_c = T_d):         Kθ=NBIAK \theta = N B I AI=(KNBA)θI = \left(\frac{K}{N B A}\right) \theta
    • Because the term KNBA\frac{K}{N B A} is constant, the steady-state deflection is strictly linear:         θ∝I\theta \propto I
  • Operational Advantages:

    • Provides the highest measurement accuracy for direct current (DC\text{DC}) quantities.
    • Possesses an inherently linear, uniform scale calibration across its entire range.
  • Limitation:

    • Restricted strictly to DC\text{DC} measurements; alternating current (AC\text{AC}) causes a net torque of zero due to rapid directional reversal, leading only to pointer vibration around zero.

Moving Iron (MI) Instruments

Attraction type moving iron instrument

  • General Characteristics:

    • Standard equipment in laboratories and industrial switchboards for measuring alternating currents and voltages at commercial power frequencies (nominally 50 Hz50\,\text{Hz}).
  • Operating Principle (Attraction Type):

    • When the measured current flows through a stationary coil winding, an internal electromagnetic field is established.
    • A soft iron disc or vane attached to the moving spindle is attracted from the weaker field region outside the coil into the stronger magnetic field region situated in the coil interior.
    • Control Torque: Provided via calibrated control springs.
    • Damping Torque: Implemented using air friction damping, where a light aluminium piston moves inside an enclosed cylindrical air damping chamber.
  • Torque Equation and Mathematical Derivation:

    • Deflecting torque derived from the stored magnetic field energy:         Td=12I2dLdθT_d = \frac{1}{2} I^2 \frac{dL}{d\theta}
      • Where dLdθ\frac{dL}{d\theta} represents the rate of change of self-inductance with angular deflection.
    • Controlling spring torque:         Tc=KθT_c = K \theta
    • At final steady-state deflection (Td=TcT_d = T_c):         12I2dLdθ=Kθ\frac{1}{2} I^2 \frac{dL}{d\theta} = K \thetaθ=I22KdLdθ\theta = \frac{I^2}{2K} \frac{dL}{d\theta}
    • Deflection relationship:         θ∝I2\theta \propto I^2
    • Because deflection is proportional to the square of the operating current, the instrument indicates true root-mean-square (RMS\text{RMS}) values, but produces a non-uniform scale that is cramped at lower readings and broader at higher readings.
  • Advantages:

    • Substantially lower manufacturing cost compared to other AC\text{AC} measuring instruments of equivalent accuracy.
    • Highly robust and reliable mechanical construction, containing no current-carrying moving parts or delicate lead-in ligaments.
    • Minimal frictional bearing errors as a consequence of a high operating torque-to-weight ratio.

Electrodynamometer Type Instruments

Electrodynamometer type instrument schematic

  • Structural Configuration:

    • Architecturally identical to PMMC\text{PMMC} instruments, with the permanent magnet replaced by a fixed air-cored electromagnet to eliminate hysteresis errors.
    • Fixed Coils: The main operating field is produced by a stationary coil divided into two symmetrical halves, separated by an air gap to maintain a uniform central magnetic field. Wound with heavy cross-section conductor to carry full load current in ammeters and wattmeters.
    • Moving Coil: Wound as a self-supporting unit or mounted on a non-metallic, non-conducting former. Metallic formers cannot be used because alternating magnetic fields would induce circulating eddy currents within them.
    • Control: Supplied by two control springs, which simultaneously serve as the electrical connection leads to the moving coil.
    • Damping: Air friction damping is standard.
  • Torque Equations:

    • Direct Current (DC\text{DC}) Operation:Td=I1I2dMdθT_d = I_1 I_2 \frac{dM}{d\theta}
      • Where I1I_1 and I2I_2 are the instantaneous currents in the fixed and moving coils, and dMdθ\frac{dM}{d\theta} is the spatial rate of change of mutual inductance.
    • Alternating Current (AC\text{AC}) Operation:Td=I1I2cos⁡(ϕ)dMdθT_d = I_1 I_2 \cos(\phi) \frac{dM}{d\theta}
      • Where I1I_1 and I2I_2 represent the RMS\text{RMS} values of the alternating currents, and ϕ\phi represents the electrical phase angle between them.
  • Advantages:

    • Air-cored construction renders the instrument completely free from magnetic hysteresis and eddy current errors.
    • Operates on both AC\text{AC} and DC\text{DC} circuits with precision (usable as transfer standards).
    • Provides accurate RMS\text{RMS} voltage measurements regardless of waveform distortions.
  • Disadvantages:

    • Significantly higher manufacturing cost than PMMC\text{PMMC} or MI\text{MI} alternatives.
    • Susceptible to damage from electrical overloads and mechanical shocks, necessitating delicate handling.

Extension of Instrument Range

  • Need for Range Extension:

    • Basic meter movements have delicate coils that safely carry only minute currents (milliamperes). Measurements of heavy currents, high line voltages, or industrial power levels require circuit adaptations.
    • Four primary devices used for meter range extension:
      • Shunts (for Ammeters)
      • Multipliers (for Voltmeters)
      • Current Transformers (CT\text{CT})
      • Potential Transformers (PT\text{PT})
  • Ammeter Shunts:

    • Definition: An ammeter shunt is a precision low-resistance resistor connected in parallel with the instrument's moving coil circuit to bypass the bulk of the line current.

Ammeter shunt circuit connection

*   **Mathematical Derivation:**
    *   Let ImI_m = Full-scale deflection current of the meter coil
    *   Let II = Total circuit line current to be measured
    *   Let RmR_m = Internal resistance of the meter coil
    *   Let RshR_{sh} = Resistance of the parallel ammeter shunt
    *   The multiplying power of the shunt (mm) is defined as:

            m=IImm = \frac{I}{I_m} * Since the meter and shunt are connected in parallel, the voltage drops across them are identical:             Vm=ImRm=IshRshV_m = I_m R_m = I_{sh} R_{sh} * Applying Kirchhoff's Current Law (I=Im+Ish  ⟹  Ish=I−ImI = I_m + I_{sh} \implies I_{sh} = I - I_m):             ImRm=(I−Im)RshI_m R_m = (I - I_m) R_{sh}Rsh=ImRmI−Im=RmIIm−1R_{sh} = \frac{I_m R_m}{I - I_m} = \frac{R_m}{\frac{I}{I_m} - 1}Rsh=Rmm−1R_{sh} = \frac{R_m}{m - 1} * Material Requirements for Shunts: * Extremely low temperature coefficient of resistance to avoid thermal drift. * Negligible thermoelectric EMF\text{EMF} against copper terminals. * High current-carrying capacity without appreciable internal heating. * Standard Material: Manganin.

  • Voltmeter Multipliers:
    • Definition: A voltmeter multiplier is an ultra-stable, high non-inductive resistance placed in series with the moving coil of the voltmeter.

Voltmeter multiplier circuit connection

  • Mathematical Derivation:
    • Let VmV_m = Rated voltage drop across the instrument coil at full deflection
    • Let VV = Total input potential difference to be measured
    • Let RmR_m = Internal resistance of the instrument
    • Let RsR_s = Resistance of the external series multiplier
    • The voltage multiplication factor (mm) is defined as:         m=VVmm = \frac{V}{V_m}
    • Total circuit current through the series string:         Im=VmRm=VRm+RsI_m = \frac{V_m}{R_m} = \frac{V}{R_m + R_s}V=Vm(1+RsRm)V = V_m \left(1 + \frac{R_s}{R_m}\right)m=1+RsRmm = 1 + \frac{R_s}{R_m}Rs=Rm(m−1)R_s = R_m (m - 1)
  • Material Requirements for Multipliers:
    • Resistance value must not drift over prolonged operating lifespans.
    • Must possess an exceptionally low temperature coefficient of resistance.

Electrodynamometer Wattmeters

Connection diagram and electrical symbol of an electrodynamometer wattmeter

  • Power Relations:

    • In a DC\text{DC} circuit: Power is given by P=VIP = V I, easily measured by a separate voltmeter and ammeter.
    • In an AC\text{AC} circuit: True active power is given by:         P=VIcos⁡(ϕ)P = V I \cos(\phi)
      • Where VV is the RMS\text{RMS} voltage, II is the RMS\text{RMS} current, and cos⁡(ϕ)\cos(\phi) is the circuit operating power factor.
    • Direct power determination requires an electrodynamometer wattmeter.
  • Coil Architecture:

    • Current Coil (CC\text{CC}): Consists of two fixed, heavy-gauge coil sections connected in series with the electrical load to carry the full line current.
    • Pressure Coil (PC\text{PC}): A delicate, lightweight moving coil connected in series with an internal high non-inductive resistor. This series combination is connected in parallel across the load or voltage source terminals.
  • Torque and Response:

    • Operating Deflecting Torque: Generated by the magnetic interaction between the flux of the fixed current coil and the flux of the moving pressure coil:         Td=KVIcos⁡(ϕ)T_d = K V I \cos(\phi)
    • Control Torque: Sourced from two phosphor bronze control springs.
    • Damping Torque: Supplied by an air friction damping system.
    • Reading Response: The meter deflection directly indicates true average power, irrespective of whether the unit is energized by AC\text{AC} or DC\text{DC}.
  • Advantages:

    • Maintains a uniformly calibrated power scale.
    • Delivers high measurement accuracy.
  • Disadvantages:

    • The absence of an iron core yields a weak operating magnetic field.
    • Exhibits a low torque-to-weight ratio, increasing susceptibility to bearing friction errors.

Induction Type Energy Meters (Watt-Hour Meters)

Induction type energy meter construction

  • Definition and Units:

    • Electrical energy is defined as the integral of instantaneous power consumed over time:         Energy=Power×Time\text{Energy} = \text{Power} \times \text{Time}E=∫0tv⋅i dtE = \int_0^t v \cdot i \, dt
    • Standard SI Unit: Kilowatt-hour (kWh\text{kWh}).
    • Universally utilized for energy metering in domestic, commercial, and industrial AC\text{AC} power systems.
  • Functional Operating Systems:

    • Driving System: Features two distinct laminated core electromagnets:
      • Series Magnet: Wound with heavy wire having few turns (Current Coil), excited directly by the line load current.
      • Shunt Magnet: Wound with fine wire having thousands of turns (Pressure Coil), energized across the main line supply voltage.
    • Moving System: A thin circular aluminium disc mounted on a vertical, low-mass alloy shaft, positioned directly in the air gap between the poles of the series and shunt electromagnets.
    • Braking System: Formed by a permanent magnet placed near the outer rim of the rotating aluminium disc. Disc rotation through this permanent magnetic field induces eddy currents that exert a dynamic retarding (braking) torque strictly proportional to rotor speed.
    • Registering Mechanism: A mechanical gear train and cyclometer register coupled to the shaft that continuously records cumulative disc revolutions.
  • Meter Constant (KK):

    • Defined as the fixed ratio of complete disc revolutions corresponding to one kilowatt-hour of registered energy consumption:         K=Number of RevolutionskWhK = \frac{\text{Number of Revolutions}}{\text{kWh}}
  • Operating Merits:

    • High operating torque-to-weight ratio minimizing frictional errors.
    • Low manufacturing expense paired with high long-term operational accuracy over wide fluctuations in load magnitude and environmental temperature.

Digital Multimeters (DMM) and Digital Voltmeters (DVM)

Block diagram of a digital multimeter

  • Digital Multimeter (DMM) Architecture:

    • A versatile instrument built upon the core platform of a Digital Voltmeter (DVM\text{DVM}), designed to measure AC\text{AC} and DC\text{DC} voltage, current, and electrical resistance.
    • Core Operating Principle: All electrical input quantities other than direct voltage are converted into an equivalent proportional DC\text{DC} voltage prior to digital processing.
  • Signal Processing Subsystems:

    • AC{\text{AC}} Voltage Measurement: The raw AC\text{AC} input passes through an internal precision rectifier stage that converts it into a calibrated, proportional DC\text{DC} potential difference.
    • Resistance Measurement (Ω\Omega): A regulated constant current source forces a stable, known test current through the unknown resistance (RxR_x). The resultant voltage drop developed across the resistance (V=IconstantRxV = I_{\text{constant}} R_x) is measured and scaled directly to display ohms.
    • Current Measurement (A\text{A}): The unknown line current is directed through precision internal shunt resistors. The millivolt drop produced across the low-tolerance shunt is read by the DVM\text{DVM} stage and calibrated in units of current.
    • DC{\text{DC}} Voltage Attenuator: Scales high-voltage DC\text{DC} inputs down into the standardized input voltage window of the internal converter.
  • Digital Voltmeter (DVM) Signal Chain:

    • A DVM\text{DVM} displays measured potential as discrete alphanumeric numerals, eliminating reading interpolation, parallax error, and mechanical pointer inertia.
    • Conversion and Display Sequence:
      • Analog Input Voltage →\rightarrow Analog-to-Digital Converter (ADC\text{ADC}) →\rightarrow Digital Counter →\rightarrow LCD\text{LCD} Display.
      • The conditioned analog voltage is converted into a binary/digital count by the ADC\text{ADC}.
      • The digital output pulses increment a high-speed digital counter circuit.
      • The final accumulated register count is mapped to driver circuits that output the numerical voltage magnitude directly onto a liquid crystal display (LCD\text{LCD}).