knowt logo

Howard Goodall's Big Bangs, Part 2: Equal Temperment

Chapter 1: The Evolution of Music

  • The musical landscape of Western Europe was transformed by a unique evolutionary development

  • Our relationship with music rooted in nature goes back over 40,000 years

  • Man started to create a musical scale by arranging notes into some kind of natural order

  • Western musicians tampered with the natural structure of music to create their own tuning system

  • Big-name composers have been able to make big-scale music thanks to the Big Bang temperament

Chapter 2: Pythagoras and Natural Harmonics

  • Pythagoras discovered that musical notes harmonize together when they have a simple mathematical relationship

  • He heard a harmonious chord of chimes coming from a blacksmith's shop and discovered that they were simple ratios of each other

  • Pythagoras believed that the universe had its own music, a harmony created by the movement of the planets

  • He set to work creating a scale of notes by dividing metal into simple ratios

Chapter 3: The Pythagorean Scale and the Pythagorean Comma

  • Pythagoras' influence on early Western music was profound

  • The Pythagorean scale was created by dividing pieces of metal by two-thirds

  • The scale created an infinite sequence or spiral of notes

  • The 13th note created a dissonance and resulted in the Pythagorean comma

  • The comma affected the distance between every note in the octave

Chapter 4: The Limitations of the Pythagorean Scale

  • Musicians played it safe by using only the first seven notes of the Pythagorean scale

  • European music made do with the eight-step version of the Pythagorean scale

  • Church music required a more sophisticated approach and experimented with adding new musical lines

  • Combining notes created strange and evil-sounding combinations due to the Pythagorean comma

  • Musicians tended to avoid certain notes and played basic tunes with fifths and fourths for harmony

Chapter 1: The Influence of Sacred Music

  • Sacred music was meant to mirror the perfection of God's creation

  • Evil-sounding note combinations derived from impure ratios were prohibited by the church

  • Experimenting with chords including sixths was considered heresy

Chapter 2: John Dunstable and his Revolutionary Music

  • John Dunstable, an English composer, challenged the traditional note combinations

  • He experimented with dissonances and sixths in his compositions

  • Dunstable used the flexible tones of the human voice to create new harmonies

Chapter 3: Dunstable's Influence in Europe

  • Dunstable's music was highly regarded by Continental composers

  • French composers quickly imitated his daring style and harmonic technique

  • The use of thirds and sixths became commonplace in compositions

Chapter 4: The Craze for Experimentation

  • Composers began throwing different sounds together in ambitious compositions

  • The experimentation led to the strain on Pythagoras's 12-note scale

  • The comma, a tuning problem ignored by Pythagoras, resurfaced and caused difficulties in creating harmonious keys

Chapter 5: The Concept of Equal Temperament

  • Equal temperament, a tuning system dividing the octave into 12 equal parts, was sought after

  • Johann Sebastian Bach played a significant role in finding a mathematically perfect scale

  • Bach's composition, "The Well-Tempered Keyboard," became a crucial collection of keyboard pieces

Note: The transcript has been condensed and summarized to fit within the 2000 token limit.

Chapter 1: The Well-Tempered Keyboard

  • Bach found himself in the employ of a wealthy count who loved secular music

    • Bach had plenty of time to concentrate on challenges and exercises for his pupils

    • He wrote the 48 preludes and fugues, which contained pieces in all the keys of the keyboard

  • The collection of tunes was a breakthrough in music

    • Bach had found a way to play all the pieces for the first time

    • The system was perfected and written up by Bach's pupil, Johann Philipp Kirnberger

  • The well-tempered keyboard revolutionized classical music in Europe

    • Composers could easily move from key to key and explore new sounds

    • The well-tempered system spread all over western Europe

Chapter 2: The Spread of Equal Temperament

  • Victorian engineering made the well-tempered system technically possible and universally available

    • Precision engineering allowed for the implementation of the tuning system

    • The formula for equal temperament, the 12th root of two, could be applied accurately

  • Instruments could be mass-produced and exported all over the world

    • The global invasion of equal temperament began

  • The accordion played a significant role in spreading equal temperament

    • It was portable and fixed to the equal temperament system

    • The accordion's popularity forced other instruments to conform to its tuning

Chapter 3: The Impact on Ethnic Music

  • The arrival of the accordion had an insidious effect on ethnic music

    • Ethnic tuning systems were replaced by equal temperament

    • The accordion's loud sound made it perfect for accompanying dancing

  • Romanian Gypsy music adapted to the equal temperament system

    • The old harmonies and scales were replaced by the Western style

    • The tension between the old and new produced a unique sound

Chapter 4: The Dominance of Equal Temperament

  • Equal temperament has become the dominant tuning system worldwide

    • Other alternative temperaments have been drowned out

    • Traditional weddings and music are becoming less common

  • Chinese music has maintained a different tuning system

    • The Chinese value the relationship between music and nature

    • Traditional Chinese music has a tranquility and natural stillness

  • Western tuning is starting to influence Chinese music

    • Young people in China are exposed to Western tuning and their own music is sounding out of tune

  • The future of non-Western tuning systems is uncertain

    • The last stronghold of non-Western sound may eventually adopt equal temperament

    • The connection with the natural world has been lost in the pursuit of equal temperament

Conclusion

  • Equal temperament has become the dominant tuning system in the Western world

  • European music relies on equal temperament and it is impossible to imagine a world without it

  • The rewards of equal temperament outweigh its flaws

  • Individual pieces, like Bach's 48 preludes and fugues, justify the invention of

EH

Howard Goodall's Big Bangs, Part 2: Equal Temperment

Chapter 1: The Evolution of Music

  • The musical landscape of Western Europe was transformed by a unique evolutionary development

  • Our relationship with music rooted in nature goes back over 40,000 years

  • Man started to create a musical scale by arranging notes into some kind of natural order

  • Western musicians tampered with the natural structure of music to create their own tuning system

  • Big-name composers have been able to make big-scale music thanks to the Big Bang temperament

Chapter 2: Pythagoras and Natural Harmonics

  • Pythagoras discovered that musical notes harmonize together when they have a simple mathematical relationship

  • He heard a harmonious chord of chimes coming from a blacksmith's shop and discovered that they were simple ratios of each other

  • Pythagoras believed that the universe had its own music, a harmony created by the movement of the planets

  • He set to work creating a scale of notes by dividing metal into simple ratios

Chapter 3: The Pythagorean Scale and the Pythagorean Comma

  • Pythagoras' influence on early Western music was profound

  • The Pythagorean scale was created by dividing pieces of metal by two-thirds

  • The scale created an infinite sequence or spiral of notes

  • The 13th note created a dissonance and resulted in the Pythagorean comma

  • The comma affected the distance between every note in the octave

Chapter 4: The Limitations of the Pythagorean Scale

  • Musicians played it safe by using only the first seven notes of the Pythagorean scale

  • European music made do with the eight-step version of the Pythagorean scale

  • Church music required a more sophisticated approach and experimented with adding new musical lines

  • Combining notes created strange and evil-sounding combinations due to the Pythagorean comma

  • Musicians tended to avoid certain notes and played basic tunes with fifths and fourths for harmony

Chapter 1: The Influence of Sacred Music

  • Sacred music was meant to mirror the perfection of God's creation

  • Evil-sounding note combinations derived from impure ratios were prohibited by the church

  • Experimenting with chords including sixths was considered heresy

Chapter 2: John Dunstable and his Revolutionary Music

  • John Dunstable, an English composer, challenged the traditional note combinations

  • He experimented with dissonances and sixths in his compositions

  • Dunstable used the flexible tones of the human voice to create new harmonies

Chapter 3: Dunstable's Influence in Europe

  • Dunstable's music was highly regarded by Continental composers

  • French composers quickly imitated his daring style and harmonic technique

  • The use of thirds and sixths became commonplace in compositions

Chapter 4: The Craze for Experimentation

  • Composers began throwing different sounds together in ambitious compositions

  • The experimentation led to the strain on Pythagoras's 12-note scale

  • The comma, a tuning problem ignored by Pythagoras, resurfaced and caused difficulties in creating harmonious keys

Chapter 5: The Concept of Equal Temperament

  • Equal temperament, a tuning system dividing the octave into 12 equal parts, was sought after

  • Johann Sebastian Bach played a significant role in finding a mathematically perfect scale

  • Bach's composition, "The Well-Tempered Keyboard," became a crucial collection of keyboard pieces

Note: The transcript has been condensed and summarized to fit within the 2000 token limit.

Chapter 1: The Well-Tempered Keyboard

  • Bach found himself in the employ of a wealthy count who loved secular music

    • Bach had plenty of time to concentrate on challenges and exercises for his pupils

    • He wrote the 48 preludes and fugues, which contained pieces in all the keys of the keyboard

  • The collection of tunes was a breakthrough in music

    • Bach had found a way to play all the pieces for the first time

    • The system was perfected and written up by Bach's pupil, Johann Philipp Kirnberger

  • The well-tempered keyboard revolutionized classical music in Europe

    • Composers could easily move from key to key and explore new sounds

    • The well-tempered system spread all over western Europe

Chapter 2: The Spread of Equal Temperament

  • Victorian engineering made the well-tempered system technically possible and universally available

    • Precision engineering allowed for the implementation of the tuning system

    • The formula for equal temperament, the 12th root of two, could be applied accurately

  • Instruments could be mass-produced and exported all over the world

    • The global invasion of equal temperament began

  • The accordion played a significant role in spreading equal temperament

    • It was portable and fixed to the equal temperament system

    • The accordion's popularity forced other instruments to conform to its tuning

Chapter 3: The Impact on Ethnic Music

  • The arrival of the accordion had an insidious effect on ethnic music

    • Ethnic tuning systems were replaced by equal temperament

    • The accordion's loud sound made it perfect for accompanying dancing

  • Romanian Gypsy music adapted to the equal temperament system

    • The old harmonies and scales were replaced by the Western style

    • The tension between the old and new produced a unique sound

Chapter 4: The Dominance of Equal Temperament

  • Equal temperament has become the dominant tuning system worldwide

    • Other alternative temperaments have been drowned out

    • Traditional weddings and music are becoming less common

  • Chinese music has maintained a different tuning system

    • The Chinese value the relationship between music and nature

    • Traditional Chinese music has a tranquility and natural stillness

  • Western tuning is starting to influence Chinese music

    • Young people in China are exposed to Western tuning and their own music is sounding out of tune

  • The future of non-Western tuning systems is uncertain

    • The last stronghold of non-Western sound may eventually adopt equal temperament

    • The connection with the natural world has been lost in the pursuit of equal temperament

Conclusion

  • Equal temperament has become the dominant tuning system in the Western world

  • European music relies on equal temperament and it is impossible to imagine a world without it

  • The rewards of equal temperament outweigh its flaws

  • Individual pieces, like Bach's 48 preludes and fugues, justify the invention of