3/3 reading

Orthodox Perspective on Reform: Orthodox Judaism does not recognize Reform Judaism as a legitimate expression of Judaism, a point of contention discussed in the text.

• Rejection of Reform Ideology: The Orthodox perspective views Reform teachings as tarnishing Jewish authenticity because they reject the truth of the Torah and the Talmud.

• Orthodox Outreach Efforts: Despite this rejection, the Orthodox community actively engages in outreach to secular Jews, aiming to bring them back to Torah observance.

  • Extensive Outreach Programs: These programs include classes, seminars, and tuition-free yeshivot, all designed to provide secular Jews with opportunities to explore Torah study.

  • Partners in Torah: The Partners in Torah program pairs secular Jews with Orthodox study partners for one-on-one learning sessions.

  • Organizations Involved: Organizations like Aish HaTorah, Ohr Somayach, and Chabad Houses are actively involved in outreach efforts.

• Concerns about Non-Orthodox Education: Orthodox individuals express concern about investing in non-Orthodox Jewish day schools, citing instances where Torah stories are discredited.

  • Anecdotal Evidence: An anecdote is shared about a Reform rabbi who allegedly told children that the stories in the Torah are not true.

  • Torah as the Foundation: The Orthodox perspective emphasizes the Torah as the foundation of Jewish continuity, arguing that it is the only way to inspire lasting commitment.

• Commitment to All Jews: The Orthodox community provides support services to all Jews, regardless of their level of observance, through organizations like Chai Lifeline.

  • Support for Russian Immigrants: Enormous sums are donated to Russian immigrants, even those who are not religiously observant.

  • Historical Rescue Efforts: The Orthodox community has a history of heroic rescue efforts, including during the Holocaust and for Soviet Jewry.

• Burial Practices: Halakhah calls for grouping in the cemetery according to the level of observance.

  • Rabbi Feinstein's Ruling: Reform Jews, should they want to be buried in an Orthodox cemetery, would be grouped in yet another section, as Rabbi Feinstein explains in an earlier responsum.

  • Holiness of the Covenant: It is forbidden to bury non-observant Jews among gentiles, since they have kedushat Yisrael , the holiness of the covenant.

Reform Perspective and Critique: The Reform perspective critiques the Orthodox community for misunderstanding, exaggerating, and simplifying Reform beliefs.

• Need for Certainty: The Orthodox community is perceived as having a psychological and emotional need for certainty, leading to the construction of a worldview with clear parameters.

• Autonomy: Autonomy is considered to be a central component of the covenant.

  • Free Will: An indispensable element in this marriage is the autonomy of the people - their freedom to accept or reject what God was offering them.

  • Mekhilta Bakhodesh: It is the very exercise of free will that gives validity to the covenant between God and the Jewish people and our pledge to each other.

• Mischaracterization of Reform: Reform Judaism is misrepresented as promoting freedom from obligation and legitimizing nonobservance as a final destination.

  • Autonomy and Obligation: The Reform perspective emphasizes autonomy as the free and voluntary acceptance of the yoke of commandments, not as freedom from obligation.

  • Rabbi Schindler's Statement: Rabbi Schindler's statement about the tragedy of Reform Jews opting to do nothing is misinterpreted as encouraging nonobservance.

• Challenging God: Challenging God is one of the great Jewish habits.

  • Abraham: Yes, Abraham challenged God - not during the binding of Isaac, but before.

  • Influence: The implication of this passage is that God can even be persuaded by human beings.

• Talmudic Rulings: Talmudic rulings are not decided by the prevailing political or social fashions.

  • Established Practice: [ A talmudic ruling ] "must be consistent with established practice among the observant.

  • Social Conditions: If we are to observe what the people are doing, does that not imply that a ruling is at least in part dependent upon or informed by the prevailing political or social conditions.

Jewish Peoplehood and Unity: Both perspectives express a commitment to Jewish peoplehood, but differ on how to achieve unity.

• Holiness of the Jewish People: The Orthodox perspective emphasizes the holiness of the Jewish people and the importance of beliefs in maintaining sanctity.

  • Concerns about Assimilation: Concerns are raised about the assimilation of Jews into the gentile world.

  • Rejection of Intermarriage: The Orthodox community does not accept intermarriage.

• Autonomy and Diversity: The Reform perspective values autonomy and embraces diversity within the Jewish community.

  • Inclusivity: The Reform movement seeks to include all Jews, regardless of their level of observance.

  • Critique of Orthodox Exclusivity: The Orthodox community is criticized for marginalizing themselves by refusing to engage in dialogue with other streams of Judaism.

  • Legitimacy of Non-Orthodoxy: The Reform movement asserts its legitimacy, regardless of Orthodox recognition.

Israel and Zionism: The dialogue extends to the topic of Israel and Zionism, revealing differing perspectives on the Jewish state.

• Orthodox View of Israel: The Orthodox perspective views Israel as a divine gift and an everlasting inheritance, emphasizing the importance of Torah observance in maintaining its legitimacy.

  • Concerns about Secularism: Concerns are raised about the secularization of the state and the potential demographic threat posed by Israeli Arabs.

  • Demographics: Within forty years or so, they could conceivably constitute a majority of the population of Israel.

• Reform View of Israel: The Reform perspective emphasizes the importance of Israel as a place of refuge and hope, but also stresses the need for a Jewish and democratic state that upholds equality and justice.

  • Rejection of Theocracy: A theocratic Jewish state would be quickly abandoned by the enlightened world and would collapse under its own intolerance and narrow - mindedness in short order.

  • Law of Return: The Law of Return is defended as a historically just measure that provides refuge for Jews facing persecution.

  • Promotion of Jewish Values: The state, in promoting Jewish religious values, must do so in a manner consistent with democracy - that is, equally and in a non-discriminatory manner.

Concluding Thoughts: The dialogue highlights the complex and often contentious relationship between Orthodox and Reform Judaism, revealing fundamental differences in beliefs and practices, as well as shared commitments to Jewish peoplehood and the future of Israel.

• Seeking Common Ground: Despite their differences, both perspectives express a desire for Jewish continuity and a thriving Jewish community.

• Importance of Dialogue: The dialogue underscores the importance of open and respectful communication in bridging divides and fostering understanding.

• The Future of Judaism: The future of Judaism depends on finding ways to navigate these differences and build a more inclusive and unified community.

This dialogue underscores the complex relationship between Orthodox and Reform Judaism, highlighting their differing perspectives on key issues such as Torah observance, autonomy, Jewish peoplehood, and the role of religion in the State of Israel. While disagreements persist, both sides share a common goal of ensuring Jewish continuity and a vibrant future for the Jewish people.