EP

Price Controls

Price Controls Introduction

  • Price controls: Government-imposed legal restrictions on prices.

  • Policymakers implement price controls when they believe market prices are unfair to buyers or sellers, which can often generate inequities.

  • In contrast, taxes are used by governments to raise revenue for public purposes or to influence market outcomes rather than directly control prices.

Types of Price Controls

  • Price Ceiling: A legal maximum on the price at which a good or service can be sold.

    • Examples: Rent-control laws.

  • Price Floor: A legal minimum on the price at which a good or service can be sold.

    • Examples: Minimum wage laws.

Price Ceilings

How Price Ceilings Affect Market Outcomes

  • Not binding: If the price ceiling is set above the equilibrium price.

    • It has no effect on the market price or quantity sold.

    • The market can still reach its natural equilibrium where supply equals demand.

  • Binding constraint: If the price ceiling is set below the equilibrium price.

    • It becomes a binding constraint.

    • Causes a shortage: Quantity demanded exceeds quantity supplied.

    • Sellers are forced to ration the scarce goods among buyers.

Example: Market with a Price Ceiling (Ice-Cream Cones)

  • Panel (a): Price ceiling of 4$. Equilibrium price is 3$. Since 4 > $3, the ceiling is not binding. The market price remains at 3$, and 100$ cones are demanded and supplied.

  • Panel (b): Price ceiling of 2$. Equilibrium price is 3$. Since 2 < $3, the ceiling is binding. The market price becomes 2$. At this price, 125$ cones are demanded, but only 75$ are supplied, resulting in a shortage of 125 - 75 = 50$$ cones.

Historical Example: Gas Lines in 1973

  • Cause: The Organization of the Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC) significantly raised the price of crude oil, which reduced the supply of gasoline.

  • Immediate Effect: This reduction in supply, coupled with U.S. government regulations that had imposed a price ceiling on gasoline, led to long lines at gas stations.

  • Pre-OPEC situation: Before the price hike, the equilibrium price for gasoline was below the price ceiling, so the ceiling had no effect.

  • Post-OPEC situation: When the supply decreased, the new equilibrium price rose above the existing price ceiling. This made the price ceiling binding, leading to a severe shortage of gasoline.

  • Resolution: Eventually, laws regulating the price of gasoline were repealed, allowing the market to adjust.

Rent Control: A Price Ceiling Example

  • Definition: Local government ordinances that limit rent increases for rental housing units (e.g., in New York and San Francisco).

  • Goal: To help the poor by making housing more affordable.

  • Critique: Many economists view rent control as a highly inefficient way to achieve this goal and often has negative long-term consequences.

Rent Control in the Short Run
  • Supply and demand elasticity: In the short run, both the supply and demand for housing are relatively inelastic.

    • This means changes in price don't lead to large changes in quantity supplied or demanded quickly.

  • Effect: A binding rent control (