Crime Control and Prevention
Left Realist View of Crime
Crime is caused by social factors: marginalisation, relative deprivation, and subcultures.
Relative deprivation: People feel deprived compared to others, leading to marginalisation and deviant subcultures.
Right Realist View of Crime
Individualistic perspective: Crime is a rational choice; benefits outweigh the costs.
Criminals commit crimes due to opportunities.
Murray: Rise in single-parent families leads to a lack of socialisation and youth delinquency.
Situational Crime Prevention
Summary: Pre-emptive approach to prevent crime by designing it out.
Strategies:
Target hardening: bars, bolts, alarm systems, park benches, and preventing sleeping.
Increased CCTV and police presence.
Hostile architecture.
Studies:
Pease (2002): ‘Bars, Bolts and Barriers’.
Hostile Architecture examples.
Marcus Felson (1998): New York City Port Authority Bus Terminal.
Cornish and Clarke (2003): Notices.
Evaluation:
Displacement theory: Crime moves to a different area.
Doesn’t address corporate or white-collar crime.
Unfairly targets the working class due to the cost of target hardening.
Environmental Crime Prevention
Summary: Improving local areas and addressing low-level criminal activity.
Examples: vandalism, graffiti, and loitering.
Strategies:
Zero tolerance policing: Addressing small petty crimes to prevent escalation.
Studies:
Wilson and Kelling: Broken Windows Policy.
Evaluation:
Deals with the system, not the cause.
Targets working-class people and street crime.
Displacement theory.
Social and Community Crime Prevention
Summary: The Left realist approach addresses social inequalities to reduce crime.
Strategies:
Youth groups and community centres to create a sense of community.
Parenting groups to aid socialisation.
Increase community police officers to improve relations and solve crimes.
Studies:
Community action programs: Perry pre-school program.
Intervention programs: Troubled families program.
Evaluation:
Assumes a value consensus within a community.
Ignores issues like relative deprivation and institutional racism, which can limit effectiveness.