Psych 006 Midterm 1
Week 1:
9/28 Monday - History, unity of knowledge, evolution
Listen for lecture 2:
Comte
Ww 2 - prejudice, obedience to authority, persuasion, war, intergroup violence, cooperation, relations
Hierarchy of knowledge (comte)
Evolution by natural selection
How nat selection builds cog systems for solving social problems
Floyd allport - one of founders of notion of social psych
Stimulates other individuals - how we affect
Reaction to their behavior - how they affect us
Conscientiousness of social objects and relations - how we think about others
Gordon allport - social psych
Understanding how influenced by actual, imagined, or implied presence of others
Actual: ppl can affect us directly in their presence
Imagined: ppl can affect us thru stored mental representations of them even when we arent in their presence
Implied: ppl affect us when institutions or norms remind us of ppls ability to influence us
cameras remind you that ur being viewed and perceived
Social psychology : scientific study of the way individuals think, feel, and behave in social contexts
Personal experience or intuition can start- but answers from scientific evidence
Follow scientific goals and methods
Objectivity
Generality
Validity and reliability
Explanation!! Is the goal
Theory based and ruled by evidence and logic
No contradictory, always explainable
Themes for the course
Human mind was designed by natural selection to solve social problems
Natural selection shaped basic psychological processes, including attention, perception, categorization, memory, learning, concept formation, valuation, emotional, motivation, and decision making
Small window for perception - threshold, frequencies to perceive and understand
We evolved to make other ppl predictable, building models of our social worlds and ourselves.
We evolved to care deeply abt what others think of us
Cooperation\
We have two track minds, behavior is driven by both automatic ( unconscious, unintended, spontaneous) and controlled ( conscious, intended, deliberate) activity
System 1 - fast unconscious automatic everyday decisions error prone
System 2 - slow conscious effortful complex decisions, reliable
We learn how to be social
Reinforcement learning
Social learning
Can understand punishments and awards happening to others and learn from that
Cultural learning
9/30 Wednesday - The Unity of Knowledge
August Comte - first sociologist - science - founded unity of knowledge
Steps: math, astronomy, physics, chemistry, biology, sociology, moral (psych)
Consilience: linking together of principles of diff disciplines especially when forming a comprehensive theory
Knowledge obtained at ant level of analysis should be consistent with the knowledge obtained at any other level of analysis
Charles darwin- origin of species - natural selection
Variation, differential reproduction, heredity (3 forces of natural selection)
Evolutionary Foundations of Social Behavior
Natural selection builds brains in the right way
Solve specific problems our ancestors faced
Solutions exist as brain circuits
Take in info about the world, compare it to representations of desired states, and then producing behavior that creates appropriate responses to the world
Endowments in areas of attention, sensation, perception, categorization, and memory - process right social info
Lecture 3: The evolution of human social life
Listen for:
What we know about ancestors forming mating relationships
Why we mostly sure monogamy ancestors
Why we can prodigy primates mating systems from size of males testes
Difference between monogamy, polygymy,
What we know abt ancestors living:
Reproduced sexually had offspring
Had family
Lived in small temp bands of mult families
Lives in societies with own customs, languages, beliefs
Very diff from ours
Large testes good in eyes of natural selection as they create more sperm- and higher sex drive
Multi male multi female systems - larger testes per weight - more sex drive
Genome library reveals when common ancestor was shared and how closely
Humans pretty avg testes- evolved monagmish
2.6 mean offspring
Week 1 exam question: A researcher studying human sexual behavior argues that a trait could become common through natural selection in its ancestral environments if it consistently increased reproductive success. Which statement best reflects this evolutionary reasoning?
1. Any behavior today that exists has to have been directly selected for.
2. If a psychological trait increases reproductive success, it can be potentially favored by natural selection, although modern expression may be influenced by culture and environment.
3. Natural selection only affects physical characteristics and not psychological traits.
4. Behavior is only adaptive if it increases an individuals happiness and esteem.
Answer : 2
10/2 Friday - continued
Humans have higher life rate, so even though produce less children, the children are more likely to reproduce themselves
Orangutans have larger gaps between babies, but have more, cuz higher mortality rates
Human women live for decades outside of reproduction age
Grandmother hypothesis: Humans live longer post reproduction cuz thet still contribute to reproductive success
Grandparents take care of kids, so that mom can have more reproductive success
Ancestor hunter gatherer -> 50 ppl need 79 square miles to make a living
Now we live very densely populated, import materials, stack housing
Bodies adapted to love sugar - cuz in real world sugar attached to fruit and vitamins, and was hard to get
Our evolutionary past influences present behavior
mating, childbearing, family, small groups, friendships, large groups
Evo
Evolutionary mismatch
Consider how our ancient evolved psychology produces the social psychological phenomena we see today
Lecture 4: Science, experimentation, causation
Listen for:
7 ways humans look for truth, along with strengths and weaknesses
What IAATOPE means
Hallmarks of science
Nullius in verba
2 correlated things cant tellus abt causation
Why experiements important
3 key features of experiment
How do we know when we know IAATOPE:
Intuition (what feels true)
Anecdote (tell stiry)
Authority (what did respected/prestigious ppltell us)
Tradition (wjay jabe we always believed
—--------------------------------------------
Observation (systematic) count and describe : __% is X
Prediction: ___ is true
Experimentation: if then
Below red line more accurate and true and good to focus there
What are hallmarks of science?
Searches for casual forces that create the things we can sense
Based on evidence logic and reason
Drawls conclusions that are subjected to critique and always held tentatively
Conducted in communities
Must be consilient
Week 2:
10/5 Monday - Correlation & Ethics, Validity, and Replication
Science is theoretical conjecture, based on evidence and logic, about the forces that cause the phenomena we can detect using our senses
We’re ultimately trying to figure out what causes what
Experiments give us a way to isolate individual forces in order to manipulate those forces with less casual ambiguity
Reciprocal causal relationship - one leads to other which in turn leads back to first cyclical
CORRELATION =/= CAUSATION
Compounding - affects 2 variables in causal ways, gives look to a potential relationship between then two even when not
Experiment to isolate causal relationship : random assignment,
Lab experiment - random, lots of control over IV, lots over DV, observe resukts
Field experiment - random, some ctrl over IV and DV, out in world, randomly observe some reactions
Quasi experiment - yes rando, no control over DV or IV, natural experiment,
Dont take anybodies word
Listen for:
How experiments on pricer, tuskegee syphilis study famous social psych experiments influenced ethics in pscyh research
Belmont report three ethical principles (respect, beneficent, justice)
Institution review board
Definition of validity - what has validity, IV vs DVs
How berkowitz & lepage study illustrates why we care abt validity
Listen replication
Decline effect, impossible results abt ESP, scientific fraud, p-hacking
How well/poor social psych findings have replicated
Ethical considerations
Historically
Nazi medical experiments ww2
Tuskegee syphilis study, research follow 399 men with syphilis for 40 years comparing to 201 men without syphilis
Study natural hsitory of disease
Never offered treatment
Never told them they had syphilis
Worries that social psuch studies will cause long term psuch stress
Belmont report 1979 IRBS
3 basic principles of modern to protect human subjects]
Respect for persons, - inform consent, privacy, debriefing
Beneficience - maximize benefits and minimize risk
Justice - benefits and burdens should be equitable across population
Institutional review board IRB - review researchers plans for experiments in context of these principles for ethical research
10/7 Wednesday- Correlation & Ethics, Validity, and Replication
Things that can have validity: independent variables, dependent variables, relations between IV and DV
Operationalization : Anger provoked —---> aggression cue —> violence
More shocks with access to weapon = most agression
Less shocks no weapon = least agression
Provoked ppl when given license to use violence retatliate against provokers
amused people when given license to have fun try to amuse those who amused them
Replication important, anyone should be able to do it in their lab over and over (key point of validity)
Exact replication
Conceptual replication - identifying the features of people and situations over which the phenomenon can be expected to occur
Ruling out alternative interpretations of what the variable relationship refers to
Help with validity of generalizations
Conformity - ppl will go against what they know
As Majority gets bigger - number of times to commit error also increases
Failures to replication in social psychology
Shrinking results - many phenomena gets weaker over time
Impossible results - darlyn bem publishes he has found evidence ESP exists
Fraudulent results - investigating scientific fraud
P hacking - as data being analuzed, researchers make them look better fpr hypothesis and for statistical significance
10/9 Friday - Nature and Nurture - Genes and Environment
About 40-75% of findings we read about in a social psych journal will not replicate in direct replication - inflated estimates
Pre 2011 much social psychology may be invalid
Look for replications of classic findings
Look for questionable research practices
Emphasize experiments with principles of open science
Listen for:
The nature further distinction and importance
Huge emphasis on nurture in western thought
How we can evaluate effects of nature and nurture using twin experiments
4 laws of behavioral genetics and what weve learned from twin studies
Homozygous and heterozygous twins differ genetically
What hereditability (Additatie genetic effects), shared (common) environment and unshared environment refer to
Variance and how accounting for the effects of genes and environment reduces it
Explanation for how contribution of genes and environment
John locke : blank slate - nature makes blank slate to be written on
Adam smith : different in talents - from habit custom and education, not as much from nature
John watson: behaviorism
4 laws of behavioral genetics:
All human behavioral traits are heritable, affected by genetic variation
The effect of being raised in same family is smaller than effect of genes
Substantial portion of the variation in complex human behavioral traits is not accounted for by effects of genes or families
A typical human behavioral trait is associated with very many genetic variants, each of which accounts for a very small percent of the behavioral variation
Correlation between trait of monozygotic twins is higher than correlation of dizygotic twins
Additive genetic effect (A, a^2, or h^2)
Common or shared enviro effect (C)
Unique or unshared enviro effect (E)
40% of variation of extraversion intraversion from genetic effects
10% of “ “ “ “ from shared environment
Environment affects ppl diff depending on their genes
For religiousness : shared environment has more effect when younger, less older
Genetic has little effect when young, way more when old
Week 3:
10/12 Monday- the self
Propensity scores not always predictor or best, even with a positive r
Genes don't cause behavior directly - they cause the mind, which processes and responds
Genetic unity: genes build species typical brains with universal psychological capabilities
Diversity : genes affected how those evolved capacities operate - most ppl have genes that enable them to see green’ others don't. Effects of those genes create diversity
Environments influence bejavior - genes in specific environments - diff effects diff ppl
What twins dont share in common makes them diff
Dna coppy errors
Unique experiences
Unique relationsups
Unique social interactions
They come to perceive and respond to new environments in diff ways- even more dissimilar
Unit 4: The Self
Self knowledge - represeentations and evaluations of urself
Self ctl: homeostatic cr- intervening own mental process
Self presentation
Listen for:
Mirror self recognition test:
How performance on ^^ develops
What chimpanzee research suggeets - recognize onself
Definition of schema and self schema
Self esteem
Sociometer theory of self esteem - validity>
Social comparison theory
Upward downward
Assimilation ande contrast
What humans do cognitive when comp[aring themselves ot others
Erving goffman
What recent study suggests abt childrens sensitivity to social observation
Can make judgements abt what we see in mirror - not all animals od that
(MSR) Mirror self recognition test: baby under 18mo cant make conneciton between self and mirror reflection
Marked the forehead
By around 18+ months, notices link between self and mirror image - can see the mark
By 24 months 90%+ of kids recognize themselves
Birthrights “ just happens in process of becoming”
Chimps may rexognize own reflection - sense of identity
Not all can do this
Around 50% fail test - ¼ iffy, ¼ CAN rexognize
Psychical cognition task : object permanence, spatial memory, rotation, visual casualty, auditory causality, quantity discromination
Social cognition tasks: comprehension pointing, attention etting behavior, gaze following
Self recognition is for social tasks! - not for psychical tasks
Self as a schema- we gather info we need to organize in a way we can obtain again when needed
We store in memory and retrieve it when we encounter person/onkect/ concept at later time
One of these organizational systems is called a schema - for the ideas of what things are
Representations of self - come to mind to create self - more accessible and retrievable -
Self reference effect: tests idea self is smth we use to organize and make sense of world
Self is tool we use to figure out what matters
Structural, phonemic, semantic, self reference
Social self: knowledge of ones own attirtbutes acquired from social interaction
William james social me
Charles cooley looking glass self
Self esteem: seeing how ineratcting with others and how they evaluate yoy - self esteem is how much u value urself
Sociometer theory of self esteem - leary
Self esteem internal gauge of social acceptance
Doesnt affect performance, but indicates how much of resource is available
Organism can implement strategies to increase availability of the resource
Measures with gauge how well you are doing social relationships
Social acceptance incr, rejection reduces,
Experimental manipulation of social acceptance increases self esteem
Experimental manipulation of social rejection do NOT reduce state self esteem
Sciometer theory not fultl accurate - half seems to work, half not,
Social comparison theory - people compare themselves to others in order to obtain information on their abilities and internal states
Upward comparison: comparing to someone superior - can make u happy to be close to them, or sad to be below them still
downward comparison : comparing to someone lesser - make you feel superior
10/14 Wednesday- self control
Social comparison theory - we tend to want to compare ourselves upwardly to those better
Adjust our sel perception dowjward’
When ppl compare - they contrast
Self presentation - erving goffman
When in presence of others, look to acquire info about them
Tries to control how others perceive themself
Want to specify the impression they have upon others
Monitoring affects socially desired behavior
Listen For:
1. Definitions of self-control and self-regulation
2. An explanation of the cylinder test and what it can teach us about self-control
3. Some of the life outcomes that are correlated with self-control
4. The marshmallow test and what it teaches us about self-control in children
5. How the subjective importance of behaviors and the subjective enjoyment of
behaviors can lead to self-control conflict
6. Delay discounting (including the concept of indifference).
7. How we test delay discount in rats and humans
8. Why delay discounting makes us look like irrational decision-makers
Cylinder tes- in face of tempting reinforcer, sometimes forget the hard way
Reward so potent we try another way
Self control: self initiated regulation of thoughts, feelings, and actions when enduringly valued goals conflict with momentarily more gratifying goals
Reality principle: seeks pleasure but more realistic, even if its slightly diminished by reality
Long term - thinking about long term larger goal, can help to deter that seeking of immediate pleasure - requires self control
Immediate enjoyment vs future importance
Marshmallow test- forsaking pleasure of now for larger later pleasure
Typical kid waited 5 mins for 2 treats rather than 1
2 treats after 5 was worth less than 1 treat before 5 mins
Delay discounting- decline in value of reward as delay increases
Subjective value : value over time depending on timing and reward
What point ppl are indifferent
10 dollars today vs 10 tmrw…
Indifferent at 5 dollars today vs 10 tmrw