Speech Audiometry and Types of Speech Tests

Types of Speech Tests

  • Speech Recognition Threshold (SRT)
      - Some refer to it as "recognition," while others use the term "reception."   - Clinically defined as the softest level at which one can understand speech.   - Technically, it is the softest level at which one can identify half of the stimulus words.   - Spondees: Words used for determining SRT, which are two-syllable words with equal stress on each syllable.
        - Examples of Spondees:
          - Playground
          - Baseball
          - Snowman
          - Ice cream
          - Bathtub
          - Toothpaste
          - Whitewash
          - Hot dog
          - Birthday
          - Airplane
          - Cowboy

  • Speech Detection (Awareness) Threshold (SDT/SAT)
      - Important to note that SRT and SDT/SAT are NOT the same.

  • Word Recognition Score (WRS)
      - Also known as Speech Recognition Score (SRS) or Speech Discrimination Score (SDS).

  • Most Comfortable Loudness Level (MCL)
      - Sometimes referred to as Most Comfortable Listening Level.

  • Uncomfortable Loudness Level (UCL)
      - Also referred to as Loudness Discomfort Level (LDL).

Detailed Definitions and Procedures

  • Speech Recognition Threshold (SRT)
      - Specifies the softest sound level at which speech can be understood.   - Clinically determined by identifying the level at which half of a set of spondee words can be recognized correctly.

  • Procedure for Establishing an SRT
      1. Familiarize the client with spondee words at a comfortable listening level.
         - This involves presenting the list at a suprathreshold level first.
      2. Obtain a threshold using a method similar to pure-tone threshold: decrease level by 10 dB and increase by 5 dB.   

  • ASHA Method for SRTs
      1. Familiarize the client.   2. Start at 30-40 dB over the estimated SRT.
      3. Present one word, then adjust level:
         - Drop by 10 dB until a word is missed.
         - Present a second word; if two words are missed, increase by 10 dB to find the starting point.
      4. Present two words at the new starting point.
         - Drop by 2 dB and assess responses.
         - For a valid testing point, at least 5 out of 6 responses must be correct.
      5. Continue adjusting until five out of six responses are missed.
         - Subtract the number of correct responses from the starting point and add one for the final SRT.

Relationship of SRT & Pure Tone Thresholds

  • Intra-test reliability must be considered; typically, the three-frequency or two-frequency average is found to be within 10 dB of the SRT (noted ranges may vary: +/- 10 dB for some, while others cite +/- 12 dB).

  • Variations in techniques among audiologists include:
      - Using blocks of words (3-4)
      - Using two-word presentations
      - Employing standard protocols like the ASHA method
      - Utilizing the Hughson-Westlake method, similar to pure tone testing.

Additional Aspects of SRT

  • Various testing modifications and adaptations for children can include:
      - Multiple choice answers with visual aids (e.g., pictures)
      - Testing with body parts referenced for clarity.

  • If establishing SRT is unsuccessful, the audiologist may establish a Speech Detection Threshold (SDT):
      - Patients indicate when they hear speech or voice without having to repeat words.
      - SDT is typically found to be worse than the best pure-tone threshold measured.

Transition to Word Recognition Scores (WRS)

  • Word Recognition Scores (WRS)
      - These scores are measured in percentages and represent the proportion of one-syllable words identified correctly at a comfortable listening level (MCL).   - Testing is performed at MCL, calculated as SRT + 30 dB or 40 dB above a predetermined sensation level (dBSL).   - Phonetically balanced lists of one-syllable words are used for the assessments.

  • Procedure for SRS/SDS
      1. Find the comfortable listening level (MCL).   2. Present 10 words.
         - Dr. R indicates that this may be insufficient for reliable assessment.
      3. If any words are missed, present an entire half-list (25 words).
      4. If the listener misses more than four words, present the complete list (50 words) to assess comprehension.   

  • SRT vs. WRS Distinctions
      - SRT utilizes spondee words, while WRS involves a carrier phrase (e.g., "Say the word…" or "Point to…").   - No pause is maintained between carrier phrase and target word; it should sound natural, resembling a conversation.
      - Various research institutions and universities have created different standardized lists for testing, such as:
        - CID W22
        - NU-6
        - PBK (specifically for children).

Impact of Hearing Loss on WRS and Other Measures

  • Word Recognition and Site of Lesion
      - Conductive Hearing Loss:
         - Tend to not significantly affect discrimination abilities as the cochlea remains intact and distortion is absent.   - Cochlear Hearing Loss:
         - Associated with decreased word discrimination due to damage and distortion within the cochlea.
      - Retrocochlear Losses:
         - May present as discrimination rollover with worse scores at elevated intensity levels.
         - These losses may appear differently from sensorineural hearing loss (SNHL) due to markedly low WRS.

  • Other Important Measures
      - Most Comfortable Loudness Level (MCL).
      - Uncomfortable Loudness Level (UCL).
      - Dynamic Range or Range of Comfortable Loudness (RCL):
        - Defined mathematically as: extRCL=extUCLextSRText{RCL} = ext{UCL} - ext{SRT}.
        

Recruitment Phenomenon in Cochlear Hearing Loss

  • Recruitment:
      - A perceptual phenomenon where a mere slight increase in sound intensity results in a disproportionate increase in perceived loudness, leading listeners, especially those with hearing loss, to say things like, "You don’t have to yell at me" when sound levels are minimally elevated.

Real-World Applications: Speech-in-Noise Testing (SPIN)

  • Importance of SPIN Testing:
      - Traditional SRT and WRS testing is typically performed in quiet sound booth environments, which do not mimic real-world noisy surroundings.   - Acknowledges that everyday environments often have variable noise levels that can impede auditory comprehension.

  • SPIN Testing Goals:
      - Evaluating a person's ability to function within realistic listening situations.   - Assesses the signal-to-noise ratio between the spoken words and background noise.

  • Types of Background Noises:
      - Speech babble (e.g., restaurant ambiance).   - White noise (wideband and narrowband).

  • SPIN Test Variants:
      - SIN Test
      - QuickSIN Test
      - BKB-SIN Test

  • Auditory Figure-Ground Testing:
      - Within the central auditory processing domain, this testing assesses the ability to distinguish auditory signals in noise, further confirming its significance in auditory assessments.