Geographical Personality Differences
Today’s Learning Goals
Consider geographical personality differences across various constructs, countries, and spatial levels.
Explore how personality traits may vary between different regions and cultures.
Learn about the causes of geographical personality differences.
Investigate underlying factors contributing to personality differences based on geography.
Discuss the societal and individual consequences of geographical personality differences.
Understand the impact of regional personality traits on societal dynamics and individual experiences.
Find out where in a country you would best fit in – based on your personality.
Self-assessment and exploration of geographical compatibility with personal traits.
Geographical Personality Differences
Geographic regions can reflect personality traits that correspond to cultural, environmental, and social factors.
Example: Canadian provinces exhibit unique personality traits which may lead to stereotypes.
Science or Stereotype?
Colloquial Personality Descriptions:
British Columbia: Characterized as having a relaxed lifestyle with an abundance of "hippies", dope-smokers, yoga enthusiasts.
Alberta: Generally perceived as conservative, with many oilmen and ranchers, reflecting a more Texan identity.
Saskatchewan: Regarded as rural and less stimulating with flat landscapes and extensive farmland.
Manitoba: Known for harsh winters, mosquitoes in summer, and a reputation for crime in Winnipeg.
Ontario: Home to major cities, including Toronto and Ottawa, known for its residents who strongly identify with the province.
Quebec: Stereotypes are prevalent about the French-speaking population and separatist sentiments.
Maritimes (New Brunswick, Prince Edward Island, Nova Scotia): Characters of hard-drinking culture and unemployment.
Newfoundland and Labrador: Often humorously regarded as inhabited by locals with distinctive accents and customs (e.g., kissing cod).
Territories (Yukon, Northwest Territories, Nunavut): Stereotypical representations of wilderness lifestyles are fading, reflecting changing societal structures.
Regional Personality Differences in the United States
Big Five Personality Traits Analysis Across States:
Extraversion, Agreeableness, Openness, Conscientiousness, Emotional Stability.
Findings based on N = 3,387,303 respondents across varied cities, identifying patterns of these traits.
Emotional Stability Z-Scores:
Classification ranges from high (e.g., z-score > 1.96) to low (e.g., z-score < -1.96).
Causes of Regional Personality Differences
Selective Migration:
Extraverted individuals are more likely to migrate towards urban and metropolitan areas, creating personality clusters.
Studies referenced: Jokela (2020), Jokela et al. (2008), Yoshino & Oshio (2022).
Sociocultural Influence:
Inhabitants of former frontier regions exhibit traits such as independence and resilience.
Studies referenced: Götz et al. (2020), Kitayama et al. (2006, 2010).
Ecological Influence:
Climate conditions affect personality traits; individuals in warmer climates tend to exhibit extraversion and openness.
Studies referenced: Wei et al. (2017).
Urban areas correlate with openness due to density and cultural exposure.
Studies referenced: Atherton et al. (2023), Militaru et al. (2024).
Consequences of Regional Personality Differences
Societal Consequences
Political:
Regions with higher openness tend to support liberal policies (Garretsen et al., 2018).
Conservative support correlated with more conscientious regions (Rentfrow, 2010).
Regions with higher neuroticism show support for figures like Trump and Brexit (Talaifar et al., 2022; Obschonka et al., 2018).
Economic:
Open regions demonstrate greater economic resilience, innovation, and often possess higher median incomes (Garretsen et al., 2020; Rentfrow et al., 2015).
Courageous regions experience higher rates of entrepreneurial ventures, both setting up and failing (Ebert et al., 2019).
More agreeable areas may encounter financial hardships (Matz & Gladstone, 2020).
Social:
Agreeable regions exhibit greater social capital and reduced crime rates.
Greater extraversion is associated with higher crime rates (Rentfrow, 2010).
Neurotic regions are linked to lesser life satisfaction and social capital (McCann, 2017, 2018).
Health:
Neurotic regions report higher prevalence of chronic conditions yet lower Covid-19 case numbers (McCann, 2011, 2014).
Conscientious populations enjoy lower health mortality rates (Rentfrow et al., 2015).
Open regions experienced rapid behavioral adaptations during Covid-19.
Individual Consequences
Impact of Regional Personality:
Affects personal emotions, behaviors, and cognitive functions beyond individual personality traits.
Example study findings include:
Well-being: Integrating regional personality significantly predicts emotional satisfaction (Stavrova, 2015).
Spending Behavior: Correlation between individual spending and regional norms (Ebert et al., 2021).
Person-Environment-Fit
Hypothesis:
A person’s adaptation and flourishing are optimized within an environment that aligns with their personality traits (Fulmer et al., 2010).
Empirical Support:
Higher alignment (congruence) with regional personality improves subjective well-being, self-esteem, and relationship satisfaction (Bleidorn et al., 2016).
Lower congruence results in relationship difficulties (Chopik & Motyl, 2016).
Where To Live With Your Personality
Interactive Exercise:
Participants are encouraged to explore where they might be happiest based on their personality traits through an online test from BBC featuring postal code input (SW1A 2AB).
Suggested follow-up: Research locations and reflect on their fit with personal traits.