Geographical Personality Differences

Today’s Learning Goals

  1. Consider geographical personality differences across various constructs, countries, and spatial levels.

    • Explore how personality traits may vary between different regions and cultures.

  2. Learn about the causes of geographical personality differences.

    • Investigate underlying factors contributing to personality differences based on geography.

  3. Discuss the societal and individual consequences of geographical personality differences.

    • Understand the impact of regional personality traits on societal dynamics and individual experiences.

  4. Find out where in a country you would best fit in – based on your personality.

    • Self-assessment and exploration of geographical compatibility with personal traits.


Geographical Personality Differences

  • Geographic regions can reflect personality traits that correspond to cultural, environmental, and social factors.

  • Example: Canadian provinces exhibit unique personality traits which may lead to stereotypes.


Science or Stereotype?

  • Colloquial Personality Descriptions:

    • British Columbia: Characterized as having a relaxed lifestyle with an abundance of "hippies", dope-smokers, yoga enthusiasts.

    • Alberta: Generally perceived as conservative, with many oilmen and ranchers, reflecting a more Texan identity.

    • Saskatchewan: Regarded as rural and less stimulating with flat landscapes and extensive farmland.

    • Manitoba: Known for harsh winters, mosquitoes in summer, and a reputation for crime in Winnipeg.

    • Ontario: Home to major cities, including Toronto and Ottawa, known for its residents who strongly identify with the province.

    • Quebec: Stereotypes are prevalent about the French-speaking population and separatist sentiments.

    • Maritimes (New Brunswick, Prince Edward Island, Nova Scotia): Characters of hard-drinking culture and unemployment.

    • Newfoundland and Labrador: Often humorously regarded as inhabited by locals with distinctive accents and customs (e.g., kissing cod).

    • Territories (Yukon, Northwest Territories, Nunavut): Stereotypical representations of wilderness lifestyles are fading, reflecting changing societal structures.


Regional Personality Differences in the United States

  • Big Five Personality Traits Analysis Across States:

    • Extraversion, Agreeableness, Openness, Conscientiousness, Emotional Stability.

    • Findings based on N = 3,387,303 respondents across varied cities, identifying patterns of these traits.

    • Emotional Stability Z-Scores:

      • Classification ranges from high (e.g., z-score > 1.96) to low (e.g., z-score < -1.96).


Causes of Regional Personality Differences

  1. Selective Migration:

    • Extraverted individuals are more likely to migrate towards urban and metropolitan areas, creating personality clusters.

    • Studies referenced: Jokela (2020), Jokela et al. (2008), Yoshino & Oshio (2022).

  2. Sociocultural Influence:

    • Inhabitants of former frontier regions exhibit traits such as independence and resilience.

    • Studies referenced: Götz et al. (2020), Kitayama et al. (2006, 2010).

  3. Ecological Influence:

    • Climate conditions affect personality traits; individuals in warmer climates tend to exhibit extraversion and openness.

    • Studies referenced: Wei et al. (2017).

    • Urban areas correlate with openness due to density and cultural exposure.

    • Studies referenced: Atherton et al. (2023), Militaru et al. (2024).


Consequences of Regional Personality Differences

Societal Consequences
  • Political:

    • Regions with higher openness tend to support liberal policies (Garretsen et al., 2018).

    • Conservative support correlated with more conscientious regions (Rentfrow, 2010).

    • Regions with higher neuroticism show support for figures like Trump and Brexit (Talaifar et al., 2022; Obschonka et al., 2018).

  • Economic:

    • Open regions demonstrate greater economic resilience, innovation, and often possess higher median incomes (Garretsen et al., 2020; Rentfrow et al., 2015).

    • Courageous regions experience higher rates of entrepreneurial ventures, both setting up and failing (Ebert et al., 2019).

    • More agreeable areas may encounter financial hardships (Matz & Gladstone, 2020).

  • Social:

    • Agreeable regions exhibit greater social capital and reduced crime rates.

    • Greater extraversion is associated with higher crime rates (Rentfrow, 2010).

    • Neurotic regions are linked to lesser life satisfaction and social capital (McCann, 2017, 2018).

  • Health:

    • Neurotic regions report higher prevalence of chronic conditions yet lower Covid-19 case numbers (McCann, 2011, 2014).

    • Conscientious populations enjoy lower health mortality rates (Rentfrow et al., 2015).

    • Open regions experienced rapid behavioral adaptations during Covid-19.


Individual Consequences
  • Impact of Regional Personality:

    • Affects personal emotions, behaviors, and cognitive functions beyond individual personality traits.

    • Example study findings include:

      • Well-being: Integrating regional personality significantly predicts emotional satisfaction (Stavrova, 2015).

      • Spending Behavior: Correlation between individual spending and regional norms (Ebert et al., 2021).


Person-Environment-Fit

  • Hypothesis:

    • A person’s adaptation and flourishing are optimized within an environment that aligns with their personality traits (Fulmer et al., 2010).

  • Empirical Support:

    • Higher alignment (congruence) with regional personality improves subjective well-being, self-esteem, and relationship satisfaction (Bleidorn et al., 2016).

    • Lower congruence results in relationship difficulties (Chopik & Motyl, 2016).


Where To Live With Your Personality

  • Interactive Exercise:

    • Participants are encouraged to explore where they might be happiest based on their personality traits through an online test from BBC featuring postal code input (SW1A 2AB).

  • Suggested follow-up: Research locations and reflect on their fit with personal traits.