Renewable Resources notes revised

Deforestation

Meaning: Caused by various factors


Reasons for deforestation

Logging: using trees for lumber is justifiable

Often used trees to cut down and or left to rot or burned

Mining: trees are cleared to access resources underground

Hydroelectricity: Dams flood forests, and rotting trees underwater

Produce methane, a potent greenhouse gas.

Slash and burn agriculture:

  • People cut down trees for small vegetables gardens

  • Tropical rainforest soil is poor quality

Gardens quickly become unproductive

  • People must cut down more forest to expand their gardens

About 14 thousand square kilometers of forest are lost every year

 Example of Roads fragmenting the Amazon rainforest over time

Time period                  Description


Initial State                    Virgin rainforest with a couple of roads


A few years                    Smaller roads branch off the main roads, with homesteads

Later                               appearing and small towns establishing


Further Spreads              Roads extend, new centers with towns emerge, and the forest

                                        Becomes fragmented into smaller piece with little continuous

                                        Area.

Corporate Agriculture and Culture

Large-scale corporate agriculture drives significant deforestation.


Soybean Fields: Vast areas of the Amazon are converted into soybean fields owned by corporations

Palm Oil Plantations: Forests in places like Malaysia and Indonesia are replaced with palm tree plantations

Soybeans and palm oil are used in numerous food and non-food products, as well as to produce biofuel






Biofuel

Biofuel is a liquid fuel made from crops containing lots of sugar



Process of Making Biofuel

  1. Crush the crop: Start with a crop containing lots of sugar

  2. Add Yeast: Add yeast, which metabolizes the sugar, producing carbon dioxide and alcohol (Ethanol)

  3. Concentrate the Alcohol: Concentrate the alcohol through distillation or freezing


Quote: The less water in the alcohol, the better it burns


Environmental Impact

Carbon Cycle: Growing crops removes carbon dioxide from the atmosphere, and burning biofuel releases it back, creating a carbon- neutral cycle

Fossil Fuels: Biofuel is much better than fossil fuels, which carbon is extracted from the ground and released into the atmosphere in a one-way process


Government interest

Favors biofuel because it is a domestic product which is better for:

  • Fuel independence

  • National Security

  • The economy


Biofuel: A Theoretically Great Idea

  • Biofuel is environmentally neutral regarding greenhouse gas carbon dioxide

  • Significant improvement over fossil fuels

  • Extract carbon from the ground into the atmosphere

  • Disrupts the natural carbon cycle

Government favors biofuel because:

  • It is a domestic product

  • Boosts the economy

  • Improves the balance of payments

  • Enhances natural security by reducing dependence on foreign countries







Corn as Biofuel

  • Corn is primary crop used for biofuel

  • Rich in sugar and the government subsidizes its production for biofuel

  • Farmers are incentivized to grow corn for biofuel, due to subsidies

  • Leads to shortages and rising prices of corn as a food source

  • The amount of corn required to fill a car’s gas tank with biofuel could feed a family for a year

Problem with Corn-Based Biofuel Production

  • U.S agriculture is highly mechanized

  • Relying on heavy machinery to burn fossil fuels to plow, plant, spray and harvest corn

  • Amount of fossil fuel burned to produce biofuel, roughly the same as the energy obtained from the biofuel

  • Process into unproductive, does not save on imports, promote energy independence, or help with global warming

Biofuel Success in Brazil

  • Producing biofuel for years using sugar cane

  • A fast growing tropical grass that makes a lot of sugar

  • More abundant than needed for sugar production

  • Does not disrupt the food supply

  • More manual with people planting, tending, and harvesting sugar cane by hand

  • Results in a better balance between fossil fuel input and biofuel output

  • Most cars run on E85, (A blend of 85% ethanol and 15% gasoline)


Deforestation: Grazing

Primarily where forests are cleared and burned to create land for rearing animals and cattle

  • U.S. principally responsible for this due to its high demands for beef

  • Makes profit for tropical countries to cut down forests, raise cattle and export beef to the U.S.











Negative impacts of Grazing

  • Loss of forests: reducing the planet’s ability to absorb carbon dioxide

  • Burning of lumber: Releases carbon dioxide into the atmosphere

  • Methane production: cattle produce methane, a potent greenhouse gas, during digestion

  • Methane emissions: from cattle burps and farts, which are a significant contributor to atmospheric methane levels

  • Humanity maintains huge herds of cattle, exceeding any natural carrying capacity

  • Deforestation for grazing has a double negative effect:reducing carbon absorption and increasing methane emissions


Deforestation: Clear Cuts

Clear cuts in the USA

  • Deforestation occurs: in the US, primarily in the Pacific Northwest, through clear cutting

  • Clear cutting: The practice of cutting down all trees in an area for lumber and paper products

  • Clear cutting creates a checkerboard pattern of clear cuts and forests

  • Practice is cheaper and quicker than selective logging trees

  • Significant environmental consequences

Long-Term Concerns

  • Practice concerns about the future of forests

  • Widespread issue across corporate america

  • Long-term environmental impact of such practices

The Rise of MBAs in Corporate Leadership

Transition from field Professionals to MBAs 

  • Corporations are led by individuals who had worked their way up through the ranks

  • Possess expertise in the company’s specific industry

  • Logging companies: were headed by former loggers, arborists or sawmill supervisors

  • Oil companies: led by petroleum geologists and engineers

  • Many american corporations or CEOs: have MBAs (Masters in Business Administration)

  • Often lack specific knowledge or experience in the company’s field

  • Primarily focus on financial aspects such as money, stock prices, pensions plans and shareholder satisfaction 




MBA Curriculum and Short-Term Planning

  • MBA curriculum typically emphasizes short-term planning

  • Short-term planning is defined as looking one year ahead

  • Long term planning to five years

  • 10 years is irrelevant due to potential changes in conditions

Reforestation Practices: Tree Farms vs Forests

  • Corporations implement reforestation practices

  • Jurisdictions mandate replanting efforts

  • Efforts often result in tree farms rather than true forests

Tree variety

  • Diverse, with trees of all sizes , ages, and species 

(eg, seedlings to old, dead snags 20+ tree species)

  • Uniform, with trees of the same species, age, and size planted in straight lines at even spacing

Undergrowth

  • Rich in shrubs (eg, 50+ species) and herbaceous plants (eg, 200+ species)

  • Limited or absent

  • Layer of vegetation beneath the forest canopy

  • Significant part of a forest’s ecosystem

  • Influencing soil health, wildlife habitats

Biodiversity

  • Supports a complex ecosystem of animals and insects

  • Reduced biodiversity

Analogy

  • A natural, self-sustaining system

  • Similar to a cornfield on a grand scale

Planting

  • Naturally seeded

  • Seedlings are planted in a crude furrow ripped by a bulldozer with a hook, typically during the cooler, rainer months of the year











Deforestation Extent: A Global Overview

Deforestation in the United States

Northern California: Approximately 20% deforested

  • Visible clear cuts on dirt roads

Pacific Northwest (South-Central Oregon)

  • A checkerboard pattern of clear cuts observed on both sides of the Central Valley

  • Deforestation levels on areas and makes an dense geometric pattern

Washington (Mount Rainier) 

  • Clear boundaries between the national park (no tree cutting)

  • Surrounding areas with extensive clear cuts are watched

  • Estimated up to least 50% of deforestation

Historical Context

  • Over half of the eastern US and the mountain ranges of the west forested

  • Most of these forests were eliminated

  • Secondary regrowth and commercial trees plantings have increased tree cover

Colorado Example

  • Forests cut down to fuel the mining industry

  • Regrown as lodgepole pines

  • Pines of similar age now dying simultaneously, lead to widespread tree death


Global Deforestation Patterns

Key colors on Deforestation Maps

Green: Forest in good condition

Yellow-Brown: Degraded forests

Red: Forests that are gone


Europe

  • Forests are largely gone, triggering the Industrial Revolution due to firewood scarcity and the discovery of coal

Southeast Asia: forests mostly gone

Northern America: Predominantly degraded forests

  • Representing secondary regrowth and commercial paintings









Tropical forests

South America (Amazon)

  • Retains a significant area of good quality forests

African Rainforest

  • Degraded with remnants of good forest

Madagascar 

  • No more forests

Indonesian Rainforest

  • Decreasing due to palm oil plantations

Global Deforestation Rate: Approximately 50%


Boreal Forests

Location: Northern regions

Map Distortion: Maps distort the size of boreal forests

  • Appear larger than they are

  • Map projections shrinking the equator and enlarging polar regions

Tree type: taiga forests with small, evergreen trees that grow slowly

Taiga: a biome characterized by coniferous forests

  • Mostly of pines,spruces and larches 

Carbon Dioxide Absorption: Trees absorb very little carbon dioxide compared to tropical rainforests


Importance of Tropical Rainforests

High Carbon Dioxide Uptake

  • Lush vegetation with rapid growth

  • Large leaves absorbs amounts of carbon dioxide

Climate Change Mitigation

  • Plays a crucial role in mitigating climate change 

Groundwater Depletion

  • When pumping out water via wells in ground

  • The groundwater level decreases

  • With many wells and significant pumping

  • Commonly used for irrigating crops

  • Accounted for most water usage in United States







Ogallala Aquifer

  • Largest aquifer in North America

  • Ideal studying groundwater depletion

  • An underground layer of rock or soil 

  • Contains water that can be extracted

Location and scale

  • Beneath the High Plains (east of the Rocky Mountains)

  • Extends over 1,000 miles north-south and 500 miles east-west

  • Underlies parts of eight states (south dakota, texas and new mexico)

Water volume

  • The aquifer’s porous space (up to a third of the rock volume) filled with water

  • A lake up to 200 feet deep across eight states

Aquifer Dynamics

  • Consists of permeable sandstone containing water, overlaid by impermeable rock

  • Filled by rain soaking into the ground in the Rocky Mountains

  • Rainwater that runs off into rivers does not replenish the aquifer

Artesian Wells

  • Water level inside the ground matched the level in the nearby hills/mountains

  • Drilling a well created an artesian system,water rises to surface due to pressure

  • Water rises naturally above the top of the aquifer (due to pressure)

Depletion Over Time

  • Increased well usage lowered the water level

  • Level dropped below ground surface, requiring pumping

  • Invention of rotary electric pumps in 1940s and 1950s

  • Led to faster water extraction

  • The Ogallala Aquifer about 50% depleted

Uses and Irrigation Methods

Most extracted water used for irrigated agriculture

Center Point Irrigation

  • A pipe from the ground extends to the field’s edge

  • Mounted on wheels

  • Electric motor rotates the system around the field

  • Sprinklers continuously spray water

  • Area gets watered for an hour or two every day or two

  • System wastes water due to evaporation (up to a third)

  • Circular irrigation patterns leave the corners of fields dry





The Tragedy of the Commons

  • Over-pumping water will lead to ruin, 

  • phenomenon called the tragedy of the commons

  • No single entity owns or controls it, maximize their personal use, lead to the resource’s destruction

Drip irrigation: A potential Solutions

Drip irrigation: method to irrigate farms and grow crops while using quarter of water needed

Emitters: half-gallon, one-gallon, and two gallons per hour emitters

  • Used at the ends or sides of the tubes

Application: Water delivered to the plants through tubing with pinholes (soaker hose)

  • Porous tubing buried in the soil

Advantages of Drip Irrigation

Reduced Evaporation

  • Water delivered to the plants, minimizing water loss through evaporation  

Targeted Watering

  • Rows with crops watered, preventing the growth of weeds in between rows

Minimized Leaf Wetting

  • Leaves of plants stay dry, reducing risk of fungal diseases

Challenges of implementing Drip Irrigation on a Large Scale

  • Installing drip irrigation is expensive and labor intensive

  • Requires thousands of miles of tubing

  • Significant financial investment

  • Temporary workforce for installation

  • Neighbors use traditional sprinklers (Higher electricity bill)

  • Avoid the upfront costs 

Potential Solutions: Regulation

  • Incentivize drip irrigation

  • Rules to limit water usage per acres

  • Farmers use to irrigate their land

  • Use of sprinklers only irrigate a quarter of their land

  • No government entity to create said regulation









Over-Pumping Issues Beyond the Ogallala Aquifer

Salinas Valley Example

  • Excessive water pumping causes the ground level to sink

  • Ground subsidence leads to uneven surfaces, building damage and cracked roads, broken utilities

  • Land near ocean below sea level, creates significant problems

Water Sources for Southern California

  • Relies on long-distance aqueducts to supply water

Los Angeles Aqueduct: Brings water from the east side of the Sierra Nevada into the San Fernando Valley

Colorado Aqueduct: Transports water from Parker Dam/Lake Havasu on the Colorado River across the desert to Southern California and San Diego

California Aqueduct: Starts in the Bay Area and brings water down the Central Valley, over the mountains and into southern california

Background: Early 1900s Los Angeles

Los angeles - small growing city

Major incentives for growth

  • Railroad companies promoted tourism and settlement

  • State and city governments wanted population growth to boost tax revenue

Problem: Limited water supply threatened continued expansion

Owens Valley and the Owens River

Location: East of the Sierra Nevada, in a desert region

Climate: Cold winters, hot summers and dry weather

Owens River: allowed local agriculture to thrive: farms and orchards

Natural flow: Terminated in Owens Lake, a large saline lake with no outlet

The Water Grab: Los Angeles Secret Strategy

LA needed water > Targeted the Owens River

California water law: Whoever owns land along a river had rights to the water

City employees were sent undercover

  • Pose as settlers and farmers

  • Secretly purchase key riverbank properties

  • Only buy land adjacent to the river to gain water rights

  • Few years > LA owned all the river-access land, and the water








Construction of the Los Angeles Aqueduct (1913)

  • 233 miles long, gravity-powered (no pumps needed)

  • Starts at 5,000 feet above sea level in Owens Valley

  • Engineering marvel: Contoured to run along mountain faces

  • Uses siphons to cross valleys

  • Built manually-no heavy machinery

  • Hydroelectric stations were added to generate electricity from the water’s descent

Impact on Owens Valley

  • LA diverted the entire Owens River into the aqueduct

Result

  • Local agriculture collapsed

  • Health hazards due to toxic dust storms

Resistance

  • Local dynamited the aqueduct multiple times

  • LA respond with armed guards and gun battles

  • Owens Valley remains arid and dry today

Southern California’s Three Major Aqueducts

Los Angeles Aqueduct

  • First major aqueduct

  • Constructed to bring water from the Owens Valley

  • Built in the early 1900s

Colorado River Aqueduct

  • Built 20 years after the L.A Aqueduct (1930s)

  • Crosses the desert, passing Joshua Tree National Park

  • Water covered to prevent evaporation

  • Ends at Lake Matthews, between Corona and Riverside

California Aqueduct (State Water Project)

  • Built in the 1950’s

  • Transports water from Northern California down the San Joaquin Valley

  • Pumps water uphill for hundreds of miles, uses massive pump stations and power lines

  • Crosses over the grapevine and ends in Southern California

  • Southern California supported it, Northern California opposed

  • Due to water diversion







Semic Risk from the San Andreas Fault

  • All three aqueducts cross the San Andreas Fault 

  • Vulnerable to earthquakes

  • Fault is overdue for a major quake

  • Last moved in 1856

  • 30 feet of horizontal displacement

  • Next earthquake: all three aqueducts likely to be non-functional

  • Repair will take weeks to months

Ground Water Supply in Long Beach

  • Half of long beach’s water comes from groundwater

  • 20 water wells near LBC

  • Near Clark Ave, camouflaged in bougainvilla in small park

Problem: Seawater Intrusion

  • Over-pumping causes aquifer pressure to drop

  • Seawater begins seeping into the aquifer, ruins freshwater supplies

  • Salt levels rise too much, well must be abandoned

  • Several wells near coast been lost

Long Beach Groundwater Issue

  • Pumping groundwater too fast causes seawater intrusion (long Beach)

  • Saltwater moves into freshwater aquifers

  • Created the Alamitos Barrier Project, injects water into the ground

  • Through wells, maintains pressure and push seawater back

Solution: Recycled Water

  • LBC using recycled water to supply the barrier and for irrigation

  • Water comes from sewage treatment

Three levels

  • Primary Treatment: removes solids, leave the water foul and unsafe

  • Secondary treatment: Adds bacteria to break down organic matter

Water is still cloudy, contains pathogens

  • Tertiary Treatment: Further purification: clarifies, disinfects filters, and chemically treats the water

  • End product is very clean

  • Public stigma (“Toilet to tap”)

Use of Recycled Water

  • Recharging aquifers to stop saltwater intrusion

  • Dual plumbing systems (potable vs . non-potable water) 

  • Too expensive to install citywide



How to spot Recycled Water

Desalination vs. Recycled Water

  • Desalination: turning seawater into freshwater

  • Effective but very expensive

Irrigation systems with purple sprinkler heads

Natural Purification with Sand

  • Water purification uses sand filtration

  • Water passes through a 10-foot sand bed to remove impurities

  • Recycled water injected into the ground must travel through underground sand 

  • Goes through 10,000 feet of natural filtration before its reused - 1,000 times