Notes on Market Failures from 'How Markets Fail'
Introduction to Market Failures
- Market failure occurs when the allocation of goods and services by a free market is not efficient.
- Various forms of market failures exist, including monopoly power, externalities, public goods, and information problems.
The Impact of Global Warming
- Case study: Polar Bears
- In 2004, four polar bears drowned in the Beaufort Sea while swimming to land due to melting ice caused by climate change.
- Increased average temperatures since the 1950s have led to a significant retreat of ice that polar bears depend on for hunting seals.
- Mortalities among polar bears illustrate how climate change results in ecological and market impacts.
- The Stern Report (2006) highlights climate change as a significant market failure that presents economic risks similar to major wars or depressions:
- It raises concerns over food supply, health, and access to land and water.
- Calls for policy intervention have arisen to address the externalities of carbon emissions, which are viewed as negative spillovers affecting future generations.
Understanding Externalities
- Definition of Externalities:
- Externalities are costs or benefits incurred by third parties who are not involved in an economic transaction.
- Negative Spillovers:
- For example, a power plant burning coal emits carbon dioxide as a byproduct, without facing penalties for pollution, leading to greater ecological harm.
- Pigovian Taxes:
- Economist Arthur Pigou argues for government intervention through taxes to align social costs with private costs.
- Suggested taxes on carbon emissions can incentivize a shift towards cleaner energy sources.
The Role of Public Goods
- Public Goods:
- Defined as non-rivalrous and non-excludable, meaning one person’s use does not prevent others from using them.
- Examples include national defense, clean air, and public parks.
- Market Failure in Public Goods:
- Private markets under-provide public goods due to the free-rider problem, where individuals benefit without paying.
- Government intervention becomes necessary to ensure adequate provision of these goods.
- Hidden Information:
- Akerlof's “Market for Lemons” illustrates how information asymmetry in the used car market can lead to adverse selection, where the presence of bad quality leads to market failure.
- Risks of this type of failure also exist in labor markets, insurance, and finance, where one party has more information than the other.
- Moral Hazard:
- Occurs when insured parties take on riskier behavior because they do not bear the full consequences of their actions, leading to higher costs for insurers.
The Importance of Government Interventions
- Need for Government Action:
- Without governmental measures, markets may not function efficiently due to the above failures.
- Potential Solutions:
- Implementing Pigovian taxes, regulations, or creating public goods can address inefficiencies in the market.
- Example: Medicare provides coverage for those who might be excluded in a private market due to high risk (hidden information).
Conclusion
- Recognizing and responding to market failures is crucial for sustaining economic welfare.
- Efforts to correct these failures must balance economic incentives with public good provisions and regulatory oversight to mitigate adverse outcomes in health care, environment, and economic stability.