ch22
Uniformitarianism and Deep Time
Context: End of the 18th century into the 19th century debates about natural theology and Earth’s age.
Lyell as a key challenger:
Charles Lyell argued against the notion of a very young Earth (thousands of years).
First volume of Principles of Geology (1833) argued for uniformitarianism and deep time.
His ideas influenced Darwin; Lyell’s work circulated widely, including on HMS Beagle during Darwin’s voyage.
Deep time meaning:
Not just “older fossils,” but an Earth shaped by processes operating over long timescales.
Fossil evidence and geomorphological processes suggested the Earth is vastly older than a few thousand years.
Uniformitarianism, in contrast to catastrophism:
The rate of erosion and other geological processes appear slow and gradual today, implying long timescales.
If past rates were the same, Earth must be old; if catastrophes were required, one would need evidence for past rapid changes.
To invoke catastrophism, one would need evidence for rapid, different past rates of change; otherwise, present rates should have operated historically.
Catastrophism and competing views:
Some argued for major catastrophes (e.g., a Great Flood) that rapidly altered Earth’s landscapes and life.
A local flood hypothesis existed (e.g., in the Paris Basin), suggesting multiple creation events, which Lyell and contemporaries pushed back against by demanding evidence for such rapid shifts.
Deep Time, Fossils, and Evidence for Old Earth
Fossil evidence was accumulating and contributing to the view that the Earth is much older than a few thousand years.
Lyell’s stance helped establish the idea that Earth’s history is measured in millions of years, not merely thousands.
Implication for biology and evolution: an old Earth provides the timespan needed for slow cumulative evolutionary change.
Lamarck and Early Evolutionary Ideas
Lamarck (Jean-Baptiste Pierre Antoine de Monet, le Chevalier de Lamarck)
Early evolutionist who proposed a mechanism for change in lineages.
Progression along what he called the “ladder of life,” which he recast as an escalator of ascent rather than a fixed ladder.
Proposed descent with modification from common ancestors and the idea of continuous creation alongside spontaneous generation (life arising from nonlife, especially for simple organisms).
Emphasized an environmental influence on inheritance via use and disuse (inheritance of acquired traits).
Key mechanisms:
Organisms descend from common ancestors.
Traits acquired due to use or disuse could be transmitted to offspring (environmental influence on heredity).
A simple-to-complex, less-to-more-perfect hierarchy of life.
Notable example: a blacksmith’s arms acquiring larger forearms through use and passing that trait to male offspring.
Decline and controversy:
Lamarck’s ideas were widely ridiculed and dismissed in his era; he died relatively poor and criticized.
Modern notes: epigenetics has sparked discussions about whether some environmental effects can influence heredity, offering a potential, partial nod to Lamarckian ideas, though the full mechanism is not Lamarckian as originally proposed.
Significance:
Lamarck was one of the first to propose a mechanism of evolution prior to Darwin, influencing subsequent debates about how evolution could occur.
His rejection by many contemporaries underscored the need for robust evidence and testable mechanisms.
Darwin, Beagle, and the Malthus Connection
Darwin on HMS Beagle (Voyage around 1831–1836):
Darwin joined largely to be a natural historian and conversational partner for the captain; he did not enjoy long sea voyages and suffered seasickness.
He used long periods ashore to collect specimens, take notes, and interact with local people.
The voyage lasted almost five years, not just two as sometimes quoted.
His experiences contributed to his becoming a renowned scientist upon return.
Thomas Malthus and population thinking:
Malthus’s essay (on population growth and resource limits) influenced Darwin’s thinking about competition for resources and the struggle for existence.
Malthus argued that human populations could grow geometrically while food production grows arithmetically, leading to potential disaster if not checked by limiting resources.
Darwin applied these ideas to all living organisms, leading to the core idea of competition and differential survival in populations.
Darwin noted this influence in his autobiography, identifying it as a catalyst for thinking about natural selection in 1838.
The core of Darwin’s early ideas:
1844: Darwin writes a formal essay on the topic of selection in evolving populations.
1844–1846: He shares this manuscript with a few colleagues and his wife Emma; Lyell is among those who know and support his thinking.
1844–1856: Darwin accumulates data, experiments, and observations to prepare a more comprehensive case for natural selection.
1856: Darwin begins planning a large, multi-volume work defending natural selection.
Wallace and the Simultaneous Credit Episode
Alfred Russell Wallace:
Wallace conducted fieldwork in Southeast Asia and arrived at ideas similar to Darwin’s: descent with modification and environmental shaping of traits, though he did not articulate a fully developed mechanism like natural selection.
Wallace sent his manuscript to Darwin, hoping it would be forwarded to Lyell or used to gain credit, because Darwin had been working on similar ideas for years.
The Linnean Society arrangement (1858):
A plan was made to present both Darwin’s and Wallace’s ideas in a joint paper to avoid conflict and share credit.
Darwin did not attend the meeting; Wallace was unaware of the plan at the time.
Darwin’s family tragedy at the time (the death of his tenth child at age 18) contributed to his absence from the meeting.
Publication outcome:
Darwin returned to London and prepared an Abstract that would lead to the Origin of Species.
The Darwin–Wallace notification resulted in simultaneous presentation of ideas, with Darwin ultimately taking the lead in publishing a full defense.
Origin, Descent with Modification, and Natural Selection
Publication timeline:
Origin of Species (1859) established the mechanism of natural selection as the primary driver of evolution and argued for descent with modification.
Core claims of Darwin’s theory (as summarized by Ernst Mayr):
All organisms have high reproductive potential, yet populations tend to be stable in size due to resource limitations (influenced by Malthus).
There is variation among individuals in populations; some of this variation is heritable (genetic).
Differential reproduction and survival arise because certain heritable traits confer advantages in given environments.
Result: differential reproductive success leads to gradual changes in populations over generations, i.e., natural selection and descent with modification.
Darwin’s ongoing hesitations and contributions:
He faced fear of attack from Lamarckian and other lines of argument; he sought strong evidence before making strong claims.
Mayr and other modern historians emphasize the logical sequence: variation, heritability, differential success, and descent with modification.
Evidence and Examples Supporting Natural Selection
Artificial selection (prelude to natural selection):
Plants and animals used by humans to illustrate how selection can lead to dramatic changes in form and traits within a species.
Brassica oleracea as a classic example: through artificial selection, a single species gave rise to kale, Brussels sprouts, cauliflower, broccoli, cabbage, and others.
This demonstrates how selection (human preferences) can produce major phenotypic changes without speciation, providing a model for natural selection in nature.
Natural selection demonstrations and examples:
Guppies in Central American streams show rapid, environment-driven changes when transplanted between predator-rich and predator-poor pools.
Reciprocal transplant experiments illustrate that juvenile coloration (and overall phenotype) shifts depending on predator presence, with rapid evolutionary responses in the wild.
Homology and analogy as evidence for descent:
Homology: similarity due to shared ancestry (descent with modification).
Example: tetrapod forelimbs (humans, cats, bats, whales) share a common bone plan (one bone, two bones, complex carpals, etc.), despite different functions.
Visual cue: a single limb plan persists across diverse lineages.
Analogy (convergent evolution): similarity not due to shared ancestry but to similar function or selective pressures.
Example: bird wings and bat wings are both used for flight but are not homologous in their skeletal arrangement; they evolved wings independently.
Insects also have wings but their wing structure is not homologous to vertebrate wings.
Molecular homology:
Hemoglobin sequence comparisons illustrate descent with modification at the molecular level.
Within humans: 100% sequence identity except for rare pathological mutations.
Humans vs rhesus monkeys: ~96% identical amino acid sequence in hemoglobin.
Humans vs mice: ~90% identical.
More distant relatives (e.g., lamprey): highly divergent sequences, illustrating deep evolutionary splits.
Transitional fossils and the law of succession:
Law of succession (Darwin): living species are found in the same geographic areas as their fossils suggest a historical lineage.
Armadillo and glyptodonts in South America: modern armadillos and their extinct glyptodont relatives occur in the same regions, supporting descent with modification in a geographic context.
Australia’s mammals: remarkably, a patchwork of marsupials (e.g., wombat) and a bear-like relative (extinct) exemplify the law of succession in a unique continental setting.
Cetacean origins and fossil evidence:
Cetaceans (whales, dolphins, porpoises) are closely related to even-toed hooved mammals (artiodactyls), especially hippos.
Transitional fossils from the late Paleocene to early Eocene include Ambulocetus (walking whale), Rodhocetus, and Dorudon, indicating movement from terrestrial to aquatic habitats.
Embryology evidence supports a tetrapod ancestry: early dolphin embryos display hind-limb buds that regress as development proceeds due to genetic regulation, consistent with a terrestrial ancestor.
The fossil record and molecular data together place cetaceans as nested within artiodactyls, with hippos as the closest living relatives.
Pakistani fossil finds (e.g., early cetacean ancestors like Rodhocetus and Pakicetus) illuminate the transition in time and habitat from land to sea.
Embryology, Development, and Genetic Insights
Embryonic evidence for ancestry:
Early-stage embryos of cetaceans show hind-limb buds that disappear as development proceeds, indicating a legged ancestor.
The presence and subsequent loss of hind limbs point to a shared developmental toolkit reusing ancient genetic programs.
Genetic and molecular data reinforce the narrative of shared descent and modification over time.
Key Figures and Concepts: Summary Notes
Charles Lyell: uniformitarianism; deep time; arguments against a young Earth; influence on Darwin.
Jean-Baptiste Lamarck: escalator concept; inheritance of acquired traits via use/disuse; spontaneous generation; early mechanism for evolution; legacy tempered by later evidence and criticism.
Charles Darwin: Beagle voyage; exposure to Malthus; development of natural selection and descent with modification; publication of Origin (1859); collaboration and coexistence with Wallace for credit.
Alfred Russell Wallace: independently conceived descent with modification; sent manuscript to Darwin; shared credit via Linnean Society proceedings.
Thomas Malthus: writer on population growth; geometric vs arithmetic growth; shaping Darwin’s struggle for existence concept.
Ernst Mayr: later Darwin scholar who summarized Origin’s core observations and implications.
Glossary of Key Terms
Deep time: concept that Earth’s history spans millions of years, far beyond a few millennia.
Uniformitarianism: the idea that current geological processes have operated in the same way throughout Earth’s history.
Catastrophism: belief that Earth’s features arise primarily from sudden, short-lived, violent events.
Descent with modification: offspring inherit traits from ancestors but may diverge over generations due to selection and variation.
Natural selection: differential survival and reproduction of individuals due to heritable traits that confer advantages in a given environment.
Artificial selection: human-directed selection of traits in domesticated species.
Homology: similarity due to shared ancestry.
Analogy: similarity due to convergent evolution, not shared ancestry.
Law of succession: living species reflect the same ancestral lineages as their fossils in a given region.
Transitional fossils: fossils showing intermediate features between ancestors and descendants.
Spontaneous generation: historical notion that life can arise from nonliving matter; largely discredited in modern biology.
Epigenetics: study of heritable changes in gene expression not caused by changes in the DNA sequence; cited as a potential modern nod to Lamarckian ideas.
Connections to Foundational Principles and Real-World Relevance
The uniformitarian view laid the groundwork for interpreting Earth’s history through gradual processes rather than dramatic catastrophes, a perspective essential to modern geology and paleontology.
Darwin’s theory links biology to Earth history, explaining how life adapts to environments over vast timescales; this informs fields from ecology to conservation biology.
The concept of common ancestry is central to modern biology, guiding comparative anatomy, genetics, and the study of human origins.
The cautionary tale of Lamarck emphasizes the importance of mechanisms and testable predictions in scientific theories.
The debate between uniformitarianism and catastrophism shaped the development of scientific methods, encouraging evidence-based arguments.
Important Dates and Figures to Remember
1833: Lyell’s Principles of Geology (first volume) popularizes uniformitarianism and deep time.
1831–1836: Darwin’s voyage on HMS Beagle (Beagle’s role and Darwin’s seasickness; five-year journey).
1838: Darwin’s realization of the struggle for existence influenced by Malthus.
1844: Darwin writes an essay on selection; shares it with colleagues and wife Emma.
1856: Darwin begins drafting a full defense of natural selection.
1858: Wallace sends manuscript with similar ideas; joint presentation planned at Linnean Society.
1859: Origin of Species published, presenting descent with modification and natural selection as core mechanisms.
Mayr (20th century): synthesizes Origin’s core observations into a concise framework (variation, heritability, differential reproduction).
Key Takeaways for Exam Preparation
Lyell’s uniformitarianism provides the geological timescale necessary for evolution to occur.
Darwin’s theory of natural selection rests on three main postulates: variation, heritability, and differential reproductive success.
Lamarck offers an early mechanism for evolution but is largely rejected in its original form; modern discussions of epigenetics periodically reopen related questions.
Evidence for evolution comes from multiple domains: direct observations (guppies, domestic plants), fossils, embryology, and molecular biology (protein sequences).
The whale–hippo relationship, Cetacea’s transition, and the law of succession illustrate how biogeography and paleontology support descent with modification.
The historical narrative includes the tension between competing interpretations and the social dynamics around publication and credit (Darwin vs Wallace, Linnean Society).
KEY TERMS
Darwin: Charles Darwin was a naturalist who developed the theory of evolution by natural selection and descent with modification, published in his 1859 work Origin of Species. His ideas were significantly shaped by his voyage on HMS Beagle and the work of Thomas Malthus.
Beagle: HMS Beagle was the ship on which Charles Darwin embarked on a nearly five-year voyage (1831–1836) as a natural historian. His observations and collections during this journey were crucial to the development of his theory of evolution.
Malthus: Thomas Malthus was an essayist whose work on population growth and resource limits influenced Darwin. Malthus argued that populations grow geometrically while resources grow arithmetically, leading to competition, which Darwin applied to all organisms in his concept of the "struggle for existence."
Selection (Artificial and Natural):
Artificial Selection: Human-directed selection of traits in domesticated species, used by Darwin to illustrate how selection can lead to dramatic changes in form and traits within a species (e.g., Brassica oleracea leading to various vegetables).
Natural Selection: The differential survival and reproduction of individuals due to heritable traits that confer advantages in a given environment, leading to gradual changes in populations over generations.
Struggle for existence: A concept derived from Malthus's ideas, applied by Darwin to describe the competition for resources and survival that occurs among all living organisms in a population, where not all offspring can survive due to limited resources.
Wallace: Alfred Russell Wallace was a naturalist who independently arrived at ideas similar to Darwin's (descent with modification and environmental shaping of traits). He sent his manuscript to Darwin, leading to a joint presentation of their ideas to the Linnean Society in 1858.
Mayr: Ernst Mayr was a 20th-century Darwin scholar who summarized the core claims of Darwin's theory into key observations: high reproductive potential, stable population size due to resource limits, variation among individuals, heritability of some variation, and differential reproduction based on advantageous traits.
Homology: Similarity between species due to shared ancestry (descent with modification). A classic example is the shared bone plan of tetrapod forelimbs (e.g., in humans, cats, bats, whales), despite their different functions.
Biogeography: The study of the distribution of species and ecosystems in geographic space and through geological time. In the context of evolution, it provides evidence for descent with modification through observations like the law of succession, demonstrating that living species in a region are related to the fossils found there.
Law of succession: Darwin's concept stating that living species are found in the same geographic areas as their fossils, suggesting a historical lineage and supporting descent with modification in a geographic context (e.g., modern armadillos and extinct glyptodonts in South America).
Transitional fossils: Fossils that exhibit intermediate features between ancestral and descendant groups, providing evidence of evolutionary transitions. Examples include Ambulocetus and Rodhocetus, which show the evolutionary steps from terrestrial to aquatic habits in cetaceans.
Cetacean example: Cetaceans (whales, dolphins, porpoises) are the group of marine mammals whose evolutionary transition from land mammals to aquatic forms is well-supported by fossil evidence (e.g., Pakicetus, Ambulocetus, Rodhocetus) and molecular data. They are closely related to even-toed hooved mammals (artiodactyls), with hipp