Criminal Evidence and Search and Seizure Concepts
Criminal Evidence: Search and Seizure
Legal Concepts in Search and Seizure
Search
Definition: An examination of an individual's person, property, or areas where they have a reasonable expectation of privacy by law enforcement.
Seizure
Definition: A government action that significantly interferes with an individual's possessory interests in property.
Possession Definitions
Actual Possession
Definition: Individuals have actual possession of property if they are physically holding or grasping it.
Constructive Possession
Definition: Individuals have constructive possession of property if they possess it but are not physically touching it.
Standards and Justifications for Search and Seizure
Standard of Justification: Traditionally governs all government searches and seizures of private areas.
The Court has identified circumstances in which probable cause is not necessary:
Probable Cause: A standard that induces a belief in a reasonable officer that an accused likely committed a crime.
Reasonable Suspicion: A lower standard than probable cause, it allows for investigative detention and questioning of private citizens without establishing probable cause.
Administrative Justification: Justifications for searches vary based on the government actors involved and the areas searched, weighing public safety against individual privacy rights.
Probable Cause
Definition: The justification necessary to arrest an individual or create a belief that a reasonable officer has that the accused is likely a criminal.
Reasonable Suspicion
Definition: A standard less than probable cause, sufficient for investigative detention, often cited by law enforcement for questioning and temporary detainment of citizens without probable cause.
Administrative Justifications for Search
Definition: Searches justified for administrative rationales vary widely; they weigh public safety interests against individual privacy rights.
Examples of Administrative Searches:
Enforcement of health codes.
Searches in heavily regulated businesses.
School searches.
Drug testing of specific populations.
Searches necessary to ensure public safety.
Expectation of Privacy
Definition: Individuals are protected from government-sponsored searches, seizures, and unlawful entry without probable cause and due process into areas deemed private.
Warrants and Their Requirements
Warrants
Definition: A legal directive issued by magistrates or judicial officials showing probable cause, authorizing law enforcement to make arrests, conduct searches, or seize evidence at specific times and locations.
Four Corners Rule
Definition: A legal requirement restricting judges from seeking probable cause beyond the information contained in the application and affidavit of a warrant, and limiting law enforcement actions to the parameters of the warrant itself.
Key Considerations in Establishing Probable Cause
Staleness: Refers to the period between the event prompting probable cause and the execution of the warrant; timeliness is crucial.
Particularity: The Fourth Amendment mandates specificity regarding the place, time, and items being searched or seized.
Defines that items not specified within the warrant cannot be included in the search.
Vicinage: Ensures individuals retain the right to be charged in the geographic location of the original jurisdiction; warrants are only valid if issued by judicial officials with authority over that area.
Types of Warrants
Anticipatory Search Warrants
Definition: Legal documents authorizing search and seizure before the evidence has arrived (e.g., a shipment of narcotics).
Sneak-and-Peek Warrants
Definition: Authorizes law enforcement to conduct surreptitious entry into places believed to contain evidence.
No-Knock Warrants
Definition: Permits law enforcement to enter premises without prior notification to occupants, used in situations where there is a risk to evidence or officer safety.
Nighttime Search Warrants
Definition: Grants law enforcement authority to conduct searches at night.
Warrantless Searches
Types of warrantless searches include:
Field Interrogations or Terry Stops.
Incident to Arrest.
Consent from individuals.
Plain View Doctrine.
Automobiles.
Exigent Circumstances affecting the need for immediate action without a warrant.