Criminal Evidence and Search and Seizure Concepts

Criminal Evidence: Search and Seizure

Legal Concepts in Search and Seizure

  • Search

    • Definition: An examination of an individual's person, property, or areas where they have a reasonable expectation of privacy by law enforcement.

  • Seizure

    • Definition: A government action that significantly interferes with an individual's possessory interests in property.

Possession Definitions

  • Actual Possession

    • Definition: Individuals have actual possession of property if they are physically holding or grasping it.

  • Constructive Possession

    • Definition: Individuals have constructive possession of property if they possess it but are not physically touching it.

Standards and Justifications for Search and Seizure

  • Standard of Justification: Traditionally governs all government searches and seizures of private areas.

  • The Court has identified circumstances in which probable cause is not necessary:

    • Probable Cause: A standard that induces a belief in a reasonable officer that an accused likely committed a crime.

    • Reasonable Suspicion: A lower standard than probable cause, it allows for investigative detention and questioning of private citizens without establishing probable cause.

    • Administrative Justification: Justifications for searches vary based on the government actors involved and the areas searched, weighing public safety against individual privacy rights.

Probable Cause

  • Definition: The justification necessary to arrest an individual or create a belief that a reasonable officer has that the accused is likely a criminal.

Reasonable Suspicion

  • Definition: A standard less than probable cause, sufficient for investigative detention, often cited by law enforcement for questioning and temporary detainment of citizens without probable cause.

Administrative Justifications for Search

  • Definition: Searches justified for administrative rationales vary widely; they weigh public safety interests against individual privacy rights.

  • Examples of Administrative Searches:

    • Enforcement of health codes.

    • Searches in heavily regulated businesses.

    • School searches.

    • Drug testing of specific populations.

    • Searches necessary to ensure public safety.

Expectation of Privacy

  • Definition: Individuals are protected from government-sponsored searches, seizures, and unlawful entry without probable cause and due process into areas deemed private.

Warrants and Their Requirements

  • Warrants

    • Definition: A legal directive issued by magistrates or judicial officials showing probable cause, authorizing law enforcement to make arrests, conduct searches, or seize evidence at specific times and locations.

  • Four Corners Rule

    • Definition: A legal requirement restricting judges from seeking probable cause beyond the information contained in the application and affidavit of a warrant, and limiting law enforcement actions to the parameters of the warrant itself.

Key Considerations in Establishing Probable Cause

  • Staleness: Refers to the period between the event prompting probable cause and the execution of the warrant; timeliness is crucial.

  • Particularity: The Fourth Amendment mandates specificity regarding the place, time, and items being searched or seized.

    • Defines that items not specified within the warrant cannot be included in the search.

  • Vicinage: Ensures individuals retain the right to be charged in the geographic location of the original jurisdiction; warrants are only valid if issued by judicial officials with authority over that area.

Types of Warrants

  • Anticipatory Search Warrants

    • Definition: Legal documents authorizing search and seizure before the evidence has arrived (e.g., a shipment of narcotics).

  • Sneak-and-Peek Warrants

    • Definition: Authorizes law enforcement to conduct surreptitious entry into places believed to contain evidence.

  • No-Knock Warrants

    • Definition: Permits law enforcement to enter premises without prior notification to occupants, used in situations where there is a risk to evidence or officer safety.

  • Nighttime Search Warrants

    • Definition: Grants law enforcement authority to conduct searches at night.

Warrantless Searches

  • Types of warrantless searches include:

    • Field Interrogations or Terry Stops.

    • Incident to Arrest.

    • Consent from individuals.

    • Plain View Doctrine.

    • Automobiles.

    • Exigent Circumstances affecting the need for immediate action without a warrant.