Imagery and Perception

Visual Imagery Overview

Definition of Visual Imagery

  • Visual Imagery: The experience of visual perception in the absence of a direct visual stimulus. This is exhibited when an object or scene can be perceived mentally even when it is not visually present.

    • Example: Ruben is walking across campus and thinking about Susan's book left at home; he imagines seeing it on his desk.

  • Related Concepts:

    • Episodic Memory: Involves recalling specific experiences, such as climbing the Eiffel Tower and remembering the view of Paris.

    • Semantic Memory: General knowledge about the world.

    • Mental Time Travel: A characteristic of episodic memory, which allows recalling past events.

Experiencing Imagery Exercises

  • Engage in practical exercises to stimulate visual imagery:

    • Count windows in your home.

    • Recall items from your breakfast table.

    • Determine the shape of an elephant’s ears (rounded or pointy).

Types of Imagery

  • Visual Imagery: "Seeing" in the absence of a visual stimulus.

  • Auditory Imagery: Imagining melodies or sounds in the mind.

  • Mental Imagery: Encompasses experiencing sensory impressions without sensory input, applicable to tastes and smells too.

  • Importance: Offers dimensions of thinking that complement verbal techniques.

Cognitive Revolution and Imagery

Measurement Techniques by Cognitive Psychologists

  • Development of methods to measure behavior to infer cognitive processes, illustrated by:

    • Alan Paivio’s (1963) Study:

    • Found that concrete nouns (e.g., truck, tree) are easier to remember than abstract nouns (e.g., justice).

    • Related to the Picture Superiority Effect seen in Chapter 7.

  • Shepard and Metzler (1971):

    • Introduced mental chronometry, measuring the time taken to perform cognitive tasks.

    • Example: Participants identified whether two pictures depicted the same object; the time taken was proportional to angle differences between views.

    • Implication: Suggests shared mechanisms between imagery and perception, raising questions of similarity and differences.

Understanding Perception and Spatial Relationships

Key Definitions

  • Perception: The process of making sense of environmental stimuli through senses.

  • Spatial Perception: Awareness of spatial relationships regarding the orientation of one’s body amidst distractions.

  • Visual-Object Imagery: The representation of visual characteristics of objects (shape, color, texture).

  • Spatial Imagery: Representation of relations among objects, including their locations and movements.

Similar Mechanisms in Imagery and Perception

  • Shepard and Metzler’s Experiments:

    • Found spatial correspondence between imagery and perception through tasks requiring mental rotations of objects.

  • Kosslyn (1973) and Mental Scanning: Participants took longer to navigate images over greater distances, supporting spatial imagery concepts.

Spatial vs. Propositional Imagery

Kosslyn’s Argument

  • Supported the perspective that visual imagery operates through Spatial Representation:

    • Different parts of an image correspond to specific locations in space.

Pylyshyn’s Rebuttal

  • Proposed that imagery is primarily Propositional:

    • Representations are abstract symbols, such as statements (e.g., “The cat is under the table”).

    • Contrast with Spatial Representation, which might be depicted similar to real images.

Evidence from Kosslyn's Experiments

  • Kosslyn's Boat Example: Propositional in nature despite spatial relationships.

    • Demonstrated how different pathways between parts affect speed in scanning.

Research on Imagery and Propositional Representations

  • Tacit Knowledge Explanation: People simulate real-world knowledge to inform their mental images, which influences reaction time in imagery tasks.

    • Finke and Pinker (1982): Experiment used brief visual stimuli followed by inquiries, demonstrating longer response times over greater mental distances.

Behavioral Comparisons of Imagery and Perception

Fundamental Experiments

  • Kosslyn's Animal Experiment (1978):

    • Participants answered faster about details regarding a larger animal when it filled more visual space, bringing forth spatial properties of mental imagery.

  • Mental Walk Task:

    • Participants estimated their distance to a mental image of an animal, showing real spatial dynamics.

Interaction Between Imagery and Perception

  • Farah (1985): Connection between imagery and perception established through participant tasks involving letter visualization.

Physiological Studies and Brain Imaging

Connection Between Imagery and Perception

  • Bottom-Up and Top-Down Processes:

    • Perception: Reliance on sensory inputs.

    • Imagery: Lacks visual input, impacting brain activation timings and areas.

Key Research Findings

  • Kreiman, Koch, and Fried (2000):

    • Investigated neurons in epileptic patients, revealing neurons that respond to both visual stimuli and imagined objects, termed imagery neurons.

  • Primary Visual Cortex Activations:

    • Showed activation from both real perception and imagined images (Le Bihan et al. 1993).

General Observations

  • Ganis, Thompson, and Kosslyn (2004):

    • Highlighted shared brain regions activated during perception and imagery, alongside notable differences in processing intensity.

  • Amedi, Malach, and Pascual-Leone (2005):

    • Explored non-visual processing deactivation during imagery.

Neuropsychological Case Studies

Patient Examples

  • M.G.S.: Impact of right occipital lobe removal on ability to visualize distances of imagined objects.

  • Unilateral Neglect: Patients exhibit visual neglect in both perception and imagery, indicating simultaneous brain impacts.

Disassociations in Imagery and Perception

  • Documented cases show differing abilities due to distinct cognitive mechanisms:

    • R.M.: Normal perception but impaired imagery.

    • C.K.: Normal imagery despite severely impaired perception.

Towards a Unified Understanding of Imagery and Perception

Summary Perspectives

  • Most consensus on shared mechanisms with distinctions in operation:

    • Perception is automatic; imagery is more labor-intensive.

    • Imagery can become ephemeral.

  • Pearson and Kosslyn (2015): Acceptance of flexible representations based on task demands.

    • Highlight disparity among cognitive styles, affecting imagery proficiency.