Imagery and Perception
Visual Imagery Overview
Definition of Visual Imagery
Visual Imagery: The experience of visual perception in the absence of a direct visual stimulus. This is exhibited when an object or scene can be perceived mentally even when it is not visually present.
Example: Ruben is walking across campus and thinking about Susan's book left at home; he imagines seeing it on his desk.
Related Concepts:
Episodic Memory: Involves recalling specific experiences, such as climbing the Eiffel Tower and remembering the view of Paris.
Semantic Memory: General knowledge about the world.
Mental Time Travel: A characteristic of episodic memory, which allows recalling past events.
Experiencing Imagery Exercises
Engage in practical exercises to stimulate visual imagery:
Count windows in your home.
Recall items from your breakfast table.
Determine the shape of an elephant’s ears (rounded or pointy).
Types of Imagery
Visual Imagery: "Seeing" in the absence of a visual stimulus.
Auditory Imagery: Imagining melodies or sounds in the mind.
Mental Imagery: Encompasses experiencing sensory impressions without sensory input, applicable to tastes and smells too.
Importance: Offers dimensions of thinking that complement verbal techniques.
Cognitive Revolution and Imagery
Measurement Techniques by Cognitive Psychologists
Development of methods to measure behavior to infer cognitive processes, illustrated by:
Alan Paivio’s (1963) Study:
Found that concrete nouns (e.g., truck, tree) are easier to remember than abstract nouns (e.g., justice).
Related to the Picture Superiority Effect seen in Chapter 7.
Shepard and Metzler (1971):
Introduced mental chronometry, measuring the time taken to perform cognitive tasks.
Example: Participants identified whether two pictures depicted the same object; the time taken was proportional to angle differences between views.
Implication: Suggests shared mechanisms between imagery and perception, raising questions of similarity and differences.
Understanding Perception and Spatial Relationships
Key Definitions
Perception: The process of making sense of environmental stimuli through senses.
Spatial Perception: Awareness of spatial relationships regarding the orientation of one’s body amidst distractions.
Visual-Object Imagery: The representation of visual characteristics of objects (shape, color, texture).
Spatial Imagery: Representation of relations among objects, including their locations and movements.
Similar Mechanisms in Imagery and Perception
Shepard and Metzler’s Experiments:
Found spatial correspondence between imagery and perception through tasks requiring mental rotations of objects.
Kosslyn (1973) and Mental Scanning: Participants took longer to navigate images over greater distances, supporting spatial imagery concepts.
Spatial vs. Propositional Imagery
Kosslyn’s Argument
Supported the perspective that visual imagery operates through Spatial Representation:
Different parts of an image correspond to specific locations in space.
Pylyshyn’s Rebuttal
Proposed that imagery is primarily Propositional:
Representations are abstract symbols, such as statements (e.g., “The cat is under the table”).
Contrast with Spatial Representation, which might be depicted similar to real images.
Evidence from Kosslyn's Experiments
Kosslyn's Boat Example: Propositional in nature despite spatial relationships.
Demonstrated how different pathways between parts affect speed in scanning.
Research on Imagery and Propositional Representations
Tacit Knowledge Explanation: People simulate real-world knowledge to inform their mental images, which influences reaction time in imagery tasks.
Finke and Pinker (1982): Experiment used brief visual stimuli followed by inquiries, demonstrating longer response times over greater mental distances.
Behavioral Comparisons of Imagery and Perception
Fundamental Experiments
Kosslyn's Animal Experiment (1978):
Participants answered faster about details regarding a larger animal when it filled more visual space, bringing forth spatial properties of mental imagery.
Mental Walk Task:
Participants estimated their distance to a mental image of an animal, showing real spatial dynamics.
Interaction Between Imagery and Perception
Farah (1985): Connection between imagery and perception established through participant tasks involving letter visualization.
Physiological Studies and Brain Imaging
Connection Between Imagery and Perception
Bottom-Up and Top-Down Processes:
Perception: Reliance on sensory inputs.
Imagery: Lacks visual input, impacting brain activation timings and areas.
Key Research Findings
Kreiman, Koch, and Fried (2000):
Investigated neurons in epileptic patients, revealing neurons that respond to both visual stimuli and imagined objects, termed imagery neurons.
Primary Visual Cortex Activations:
Showed activation from both real perception and imagined images (Le Bihan et al. 1993).
General Observations
Ganis, Thompson, and Kosslyn (2004):
Highlighted shared brain regions activated during perception and imagery, alongside notable differences in processing intensity.
Amedi, Malach, and Pascual-Leone (2005):
Explored non-visual processing deactivation during imagery.
Neuropsychological Case Studies
Patient Examples
M.G.S.: Impact of right occipital lobe removal on ability to visualize distances of imagined objects.
Unilateral Neglect: Patients exhibit visual neglect in both perception and imagery, indicating simultaneous brain impacts.
Disassociations in Imagery and Perception
Documented cases show differing abilities due to distinct cognitive mechanisms:
R.M.: Normal perception but impaired imagery.
C.K.: Normal imagery despite severely impaired perception.
Towards a Unified Understanding of Imagery and Perception
Summary Perspectives
Most consensus on shared mechanisms with distinctions in operation:
Perception is automatic; imagery is more labor-intensive.
Imagery can become ephemeral.
Pearson and Kosslyn (2015): Acceptance of flexible representations based on task demands.
Highlight disparity among cognitive styles, affecting imagery proficiency.