DF

Epicurean Tetrapharmakos – Four-Part Cure for Unhappiness

Context & Purpose

  • Speaker: Monte Johnson, philosophy professor at the University of California, San Diego.
  • Topic: Epicureanism’s four-part cure for unhappiness, the “Tetrapharmakos.”
  • Format analogy: Works like modern cognitive-behavioral therapy—short maxims to meditate on for anxiety relief.
  • Technical term: “Tetrapharmakos” = “four-part remedy”; originally a medical mix of 4 drugs.

The Four Capital Doctrines (Tetrapharmakos Summary)

  • 1. God is nothing to fear.
  • 2. Death is nothing to worry about.
  • 3. The good things in life are easy to acquire.
  • 4. The terrible things are easy to endure.
  • Epicurus’s practical advice: “Meditate on these ideas day and night … alone and with someone like yourself … and you will never be badly disturbed, whether awake or dreaming.”

Maxim 1 – “God Is Nothing to Fear”

  • Traditional religion depicts frightening deities (e.g., Zeus’s thunderbolts, Poseidon’s trident earthquakes).
    • Consequence: Costly, anxiety-inducing sacrifices to appease gods.
  • Epicurean natural science: Comprehensive physical explanation of the universe removes need for divine causation.
  • Theological argument:
    • A perfect being is invulnerable, happy, and therefore indifferent to human affairs.
    • Anger & pity are forms of suffering; incompatible with divine perfection.
    • Hence, blaming natural disasters or after-death punishments on a god is impious.
  • Ethical implication: Religious fear is unnecessary and harmful; abolish fear-based worship.

Maxim 2 – “Death Is Nothing to Worry About”

  • Link to Maxim 1: No divine punishment after death.
  • Physicalist psychology:
    • Body disintegrates ⇒ living thing ceases.
    • No immaterial soul for reward/torment.
  • Logical symmetry (“Lucretian symmetry argument”):
    • Death affects neither living (not dead yet) nor dead (no longer exist).
    • Past non-existence before birth felt as no loss; future non-existence is the same.
  • Comfort in finitude: All striving and suffering end at death; removal of death-fear liberates us for present enjoyment.

Maxim 3 – “The Good Things Are Easy to Acquire”

  • Nature’s free basics:
    • Air for breath, water for thirst, fire for warmth, earth for footing.
    • Minerals/plants/animals → shelter & food.
    • Social environment provides potential friends.
  • Result: Realization of “enough” produces tranquility & allows deeper aesthetic/scientific appreciation of reality.
  • Epicurus calls such a state “god-like” → invulnerable happiness without fear of nature.

Three-Fold Division of Desires (Epicurus’s Diagnostic Tool)

  • \text{Natural \& Necessary}
    • Examples: air, basic food & water, simple shelter.
  • \text{Natural but Not Necessary}
    • Examples: gourmet foods, mansions, sex.
  • \text{Neither Natural nor Necessary (“Hollow”)}
    • Examples: fame, riches, glory, political power, immortality.
  • Practical upshot:
    • Hollow desires are unlimited & hard to satisfy → net unhappiness.
    • Happiness increases by limiting desires rather than expanding acquisitions.

Two Kinds of Pleasure

  • \text{Kinetic Pleasure} (movement/stimulation)
    • E.g., drinking when thirsty, eating when hungry, warming when cold.
  • \text{Static Pleasure} (ataraxia + aponia)
    • Pain-free, satisfied, self-sufficient tranquility after needs met.
  • Both pleasures are naturally limited; beyond saturation, only variation (not increase) is possible.
  • Illustration:
    • Chocolate vs. vanilla ice-cream adds variety, not higher magnitude once satiety reached.
    • Epicurus’s diet: mostly bread & water; occasional pot of cheese labeled “indulgence.”
  • Rational hedonism:
    • Often better to eliminate a desire than labor to satisfy it.
    • Sometimes endure short pain for a greater future pleasure & vice-versa.

Maxim 4 – “The Terrible Things Are Easy to Endure”

  • Pain taxonomy:
    • Acute pains → sharp but short.
    • Chronic pains → long-lasting but dull.
  • If pain ever becomes both intense & prolonged, ending life is an option ⇒ thereafter no harm can reach us (links back to Maxim 2).
  • Grateful reflection on nature’s limits fosters serenity.
  • Intellectual/philosophical activity supplies compensatory joy for life’s pains.
    • Example: Epicurus, dying of kidney stones, writes to Idomeneus that recalling their philosophical talks outweighs his suffering.

Broader Significance & Modern Connections

  • Ethical stance: Removes fear-based piety, condemns sacrifice of human goods for imagined divine favor.
  • Psychological resonance: Mirrors contemporary CBT – replace irrational fears/desires with rational evaluations.
  • Practical minimalism: Encourages simple living, environmental moderation, sustainable resource use.
  • Existential liberation: Acceptance of mortality & bodily nature frees attention for friendship, inquiry, and aesthetic wonder.
  • Hedonistic but disciplined: Pleasure as highest good, yet defined primarily as absence of pain, not constant stimulation.

Key Numerical & Logical Takeaways

  • 4 core maxims = Tetrapharmakos.
  • 3 classes of desire → diagnostic/remedial guide.
  • 2 categories of pleasure → interpretive tool.
  • Logical syllogism for death:
    • “Where I am, death is not; where death is, I am not” ⇒ no overlap, therefore no experience of death.

Study & Meditation Tips

  • Daily practice: Repeat the 4 maxims morning & night; discuss with philosophically like-minded friends.
  • Journaling: Classify your current desires using the 3-fold scheme; plan eliminations/reductions.
  • Sensory audit: Notice transition from kinetic to static pleasure (e.g., first sip of water ⇒ satisfaction plateau).
  • Cognitive reframe: When pain/fear arises, recall natural limits & temporariness; visualize symmetry of pre-birth & post-death non-existence.