Introduction to Ethics in Psychological Research

How Ethics Guide Psychological Research

  • Evolution of Ethical Guidelines

    • Ethical guidelines in psychology evolve over time.

    • The Open Science Movement underscores ethical issues that have gained prominence recently.

    • Future generations may question past ethical standards in psychological research, reflecting on what was considered acceptable.

  • Core Principles of Research Ethics

    • The essential objective of ethics in psychology is to avoid both short-term and long-term harm to human and non-human animals involved in studies.

Unethical Studies in Psychology

  • Historical Context of Unethical Research

    • There are noteworthy unethical studies in psychology's past that serve as cautionary tales.

    • A continuum exists regarding the degree of unethics; minor violations differ from severe ethical breaches.

  • Example of Unethical Research: Facebook Experiment (Kramer et al., 2014)

    • A study manipulated Facebook users’ news feeds without their knowledge.

    • Half of participants received positive messages; the other half had negative messages hidden.

    • Result: Participants who received fewer positive messages posted less positively, reflecting emotional content changes due to manipulation.

  • Unethical Study Timeline

    • Table 2.4 features a chronological order of studies that are deemed unethical by contemporary standards.

APA Ethical Guidelines for Research Participation

  • Rights of Participants

    • The established rights of study participants hinge on the Belmont Report (1979) and American Psychological Association guidelines.

    • Participants should be informed of their rights before participation.

    • Notable rights include:

    • Informed Consent:

      • Individuals should be aware of study expectations, potential risks, and anonymity of personal information.

    • Right to Withdraw:

      • Participants can exit the study at any time for any reason or skip questions they find uncomfortable.

    • Post-Study Transparency:

      • After completing the study, participants can inquire about hypotheses, results, and any deceptions involved, along with contact information to report concerns.

Ethical Standards in Animal Research

  • Historical Abuse in Animal Research

    • Certain practices in psychology have previously crossed the line into animal cruelty; modern ethical standards are significantly stricter.

    • The APA provides a hotline for reporting abuses.

  • Guidelines for Animal Research

    • Justification:

    • Ethical approval must consider the welfare of animals throughout the research process.

    • Care:

    • Animals should be housed in clean, suitable environments and treated with compassion.

    • Minimal stress and discomfort must be ensured during experimentation.

    • Use of anesthesia is mandated during surgical procedures on animals, if necessary.

    • Observational studies in natural settings should be conducted responsibly to avoid disruption.

Oversight and Approval Processes

  • Institutional Review Boards (IRB)

    • Researchers are accountable for safeguarding participants' rights and welfare.

    • All research involving humans or animals is monitored by specialized committees:

    • Institutional Review Boards:

      • Focus on studies with human participants.

    • Institutional Animal Care and Use Committees:

      • Oversee studies utilizing non-human animals.

    • Committees typically consist of interdisciplinary representatives, including faculty from various departments, legal experts, and community members.

  • Approval Process

    • Psychologists must obtain prior approval for their studies from the relevant university committee.

    • Approval involves detailed submissions outlining the study’s purpose, procedures, participant compensation, expected benefits, and potential risks.

    • Committees may ask questions and require modifications if necessary.

Conclusion: Importance of Ethics in Psychology

  • Modern psychology emphasizes:

    • Conducting research effectively (doing science well).

    • Upholding ethical standards (doing science ethically).

  • The integration of these principles instills pride among authors and researchers in the field of psychology, fostering a commitment to ethical research practices.