Introduction to Ethics in Psychological Research
How Ethics Guide Psychological Research
Evolution of Ethical Guidelines
Ethical guidelines in psychology evolve over time.
The Open Science Movement underscores ethical issues that have gained prominence recently.
Future generations may question past ethical standards in psychological research, reflecting on what was considered acceptable.
Core Principles of Research Ethics
The essential objective of ethics in psychology is to avoid both short-term and long-term harm to human and non-human animals involved in studies.
Unethical Studies in Psychology
Historical Context of Unethical Research
There are noteworthy unethical studies in psychology's past that serve as cautionary tales.
A continuum exists regarding the degree of unethics; minor violations differ from severe ethical breaches.
Example of Unethical Research: Facebook Experiment (Kramer et al., 2014)
A study manipulated Facebook users’ news feeds without their knowledge.
Half of participants received positive messages; the other half had negative messages hidden.
Result: Participants who received fewer positive messages posted less positively, reflecting emotional content changes due to manipulation.
Unethical Study Timeline
Table 2.4 features a chronological order of studies that are deemed unethical by contemporary standards.
APA Ethical Guidelines for Research Participation
Rights of Participants
The established rights of study participants hinge on the Belmont Report (1979) and American Psychological Association guidelines.
Participants should be informed of their rights before participation.
Notable rights include:
Informed Consent:
Individuals should be aware of study expectations, potential risks, and anonymity of personal information.
Right to Withdraw:
Participants can exit the study at any time for any reason or skip questions they find uncomfortable.
Post-Study Transparency:
After completing the study, participants can inquire about hypotheses, results, and any deceptions involved, along with contact information to report concerns.
Ethical Standards in Animal Research
Historical Abuse in Animal Research
Certain practices in psychology have previously crossed the line into animal cruelty; modern ethical standards are significantly stricter.
The APA provides a hotline for reporting abuses.
Guidelines for Animal Research
Justification:
Ethical approval must consider the welfare of animals throughout the research process.
Care:
Animals should be housed in clean, suitable environments and treated with compassion.
Minimal stress and discomfort must be ensured during experimentation.
Use of anesthesia is mandated during surgical procedures on animals, if necessary.
Observational studies in natural settings should be conducted responsibly to avoid disruption.
Oversight and Approval Processes
Institutional Review Boards (IRB)
Researchers are accountable for safeguarding participants' rights and welfare.
All research involving humans or animals is monitored by specialized committees:
Institutional Review Boards:
Focus on studies with human participants.
Institutional Animal Care and Use Committees:
Oversee studies utilizing non-human animals.
Committees typically consist of interdisciplinary representatives, including faculty from various departments, legal experts, and community members.
Approval Process
Psychologists must obtain prior approval for their studies from the relevant university committee.
Approval involves detailed submissions outlining the study’s purpose, procedures, participant compensation, expected benefits, and potential risks.
Committees may ask questions and require modifications if necessary.
Conclusion: Importance of Ethics in Psychology
Modern psychology emphasizes:
Conducting research effectively (doing science well).
Upholding ethical standards (doing science ethically).
The integration of these principles instills pride among authors and researchers in the field of psychology, fostering a commitment to ethical research practices.