Homicide and Serial Killers

Chapter 11: Homicide

Case Study: Charles Manson

  • Case study identifier: 584381
  • Location: Ventura, CA
  • Date: 22 April 1968

Definition of Homicide

  • Homicide is defined as the intentional killing of another person.

Types of Violence: Instrumental vs. Reactive

  • Instrumental Violence: Purposeful aggression often aimed at gaining a specific goal.
  • Reactive Violence: Aggression that occurs in response to a provocation, typically characterized by emotional arousal.

Demographics and Context of Homicide

  • Data Trends:
    • Offenders and victims are typically males under the age of 25.
    • Victims are often murdered by someone they know, such as acquaintances or family members.
    • Less than ¼ of homicide cases involve strangers.
    • Most homicides occur in private residences.
  • Precipitating Factors:
    • Arguments are significant contributors to homicide rates in Canada and the U.S.
    • In North America, substance abuse is a prevalent factor leading to violent incidents.

Personality Types and Reactive Aggression

  • Edwin Megargee’s research (1966) identifies two distinct personality types relating to aggression:
    • Under-controlled Offender:
    • Fails to internalize behavioral restraints against aggression.
    • Typically has a quick temper and a history of violent behavior.
    • More likely to act impulsively in aggression-related scenarios.
    • Over-controlled Offender:
    • Possesses extreme behavioral inhibition against aggressive impulses.
    • Tends to suppress emotions when provoked but may eventually erupt in rage.
    • Example: A 17-year-old involved in a mass shooting after years of bullying with no prior signs of violence.

Minnesota Multiphasic Personality Inventory (MMPI)

  • Overcontrolled Hostility Scale (O-H):
    • A tool used to identify individuals who show signs of overcontrolling emotional responses.
    • Distinguishes between highly assaultive and non-violent offenders.
    • Findings indicate adolescent murderers have a higher O-H score compared to non-murdering peers.

Self-Regulation and Pathway Models of Homicide

  • Self-Regulation: The capacity to control emotional responses and select appropriate behavioral reactions to stimuli.
  • This ability plays a critical role in contributing to reactive forms of violence, specifically homicide.
  • Dysfunctional Regulation Types:
    • Underregulation:
    • Impulsive behaviors stemming from an inability to manage emotional responses, leading to aggressive acts.

Homicide in the Family

  • Filicide: The act of killing a child by a parent.
    • Gender Distribution: Men are equally likely as women to commit this form of murder, often under the influence of alcohol.
    • Additional stressors such as unemployment and separation are commonly involved in these situations.
  • Neocide: Murder within 24 hours of birth.
  • Infanticide: Killing a child older than 24 hours, can be linked to factors like mental illness or psychopathy.
  • Conditions impacting filicide include:
    • Poverty, social isolation, unemployment, lack of education, and rare postpartum psychosis, which includes delusional thinking and mood instabilities.
  • Parricide: Killing of a parent, more prevalent in male perpetrators.
    • Adult perpetrators often suffer from mental illness and experience financial disputes.
    • Juvenile cases typically involve ongoing abuse.
  • Matricide: The act of killing one’s mother.
  • Patricide: The act of killing one’s father.

Multiple Murder Definitions

  • Mass Murder: Defined as the killing of four or more individuals at one location.
  • Spree Murder: Previously used by the FBI to categorize multiple murders at different locations but is no longer officially recognized.
    • Example: The movie Natural Born Killers, which depicts a couple murdering 11 individuals over an 8-day road trip.
  • Serial Murder: Involves the killing of at least two victims at separate times with a cooling-off period between murders.
    • Example: Ted Bundy, who committed multiple murders over a timeframe of five years.

Paraphilic Disorders in Serial Murder

  • Examples of paraphilic disorders include:
    • Exhibitionism: Gaining sexual pleasure from exposing oneself.
    • Pedophilia: Sexual attraction to prepubescent children.
    • Sexual Sadism: Deriving pleasure from inflicting pain.
    • Necrophilia: Engaging sexually with corpses.
    • Cannibalism: Consuming human flesh.
    • Vampirism: The act of drinking blood for sexual or sensational pleasure.
    • Erotophonophilia: Also known as “lust murder”, involves murdering an unsuspecting sexual partner while exercising control over them using lethal and non-lethal force.

Female Serial Killers

  • Research on female serial killers is limited; approximately 1 in 6 serial killers are women, complicating data collection and analysis.
  • Differences in Female Serial Killers:
    • Females tend to be more “active” for longer periods, employing more discreet methods.
    • Often referred to as the “quiet killers” who frequently use poison as their weapon of choice.
    • Males are usually more violent and showy in their methods.
  • Female killers are more likely to target acquaintances or loved ones.
    • Include the “black widow” killer (a wife who murders her husband) and the “angel of death” (female caretakers who kill their patients).
    • Financial gain is a common motive for women committing homicide.

Typology of Serial Killers

  • Organized Killer:
    • Crime scene displays intelligence and emotional control.
    • Exhibits social skills and maintains normalcy (e.g. Has a steady job, family).
    • Crimes are premeditated and often involve bringing tools for the act such as handcuffs and rope.
    • Victims are carefully selected, often stalked, and bodies may be moved to cover evidence.
  • Disorganized Killer:
    • Exhibits social and sexual ineptness; usually possesses a below-average IQ.
    • Lives alone and commits crimes closer to home, reflecting impulsive anger and chaotic murder scenes.
    • Uses readily available weapons and often leaves evidence at the scene without an attempt to cover it up.

4 Types of Serial Killers by Holmes

  • Visionary: Motivated by psychotic disorders.
  • Mission-oriented: Has a specific agenda, eliminating victims for a cause without being psychotic.
  • Hedonistic: Engages in thrill killings driven by pleasure, with a subset labeled as rape or lust killers (e.g. the Ice Man).
  • Power-oriented: Controls life and death scenarios, often stemming from an internal sense of inadequacy or powerlessness (e.g. Zodiac Killer).

Etiology of Serial Murder

  • MacDonald Triad: A behavioral syndrome involving three components that predict future violent behavior:
    • Fire Setting: Often associated with conduct disorder.
    • Cruelty to Animals: Frequently observed in violent offenders, indicative of conduct disorder.
    • Bedwetting: Presentation of this behavior early in childhood is also linked to future violent tendencies.