KK

Psychology: Research Methods, Part 1

Psychology and the Scientific Method

What is Psychology?

  • Psychology is the study of behavior.

Understanding Behavior

  • Explaining behavior often relies on:

    • Experience: Drawing on past similar situations and their outcomes.

    • Intuition: Developing a logical explanation for the behavior.

    • Problems with relying on experience and intuition:

      • Lack of knowledge of alternative outcomes if circumstances differed.

      • Potential for guessing without complete information.

      • Bias towards a particular explanation.

The Scientific Method in Psychology

  • Psychologists use the scientific method to study behavior.

  • Characteristics of the Scientific Method:

    • Empiricism: Objective observation of the world.

    • Replication: Demonstrating and observing a phenomenon more than once.

    • Publication: Making observations available for scrutiny and evaluation.

Skepticism and Open-mindedness

  • Psychologists:

    • Examine evidence behind claims.

    • Are open to new ideas.

    • Acknowledge the potential to be fooled and design research to protect against it.

Contrasting Approaches: Psychologist vs. Non-Psychologist

  • A Non-Psychologist…

    • does not consider alternative viewpoints.

    • clings to beliefs in spite of contrary evidence.

    • says, “Believe me, I am an expert.”

  • A Psychologist…

    • is open to alternative viewpoints.

    • will change beliefs if contrary evidence is found.

    • says, “Examine the evidence and decide whether it supports my claim.”

How We Can Be Fooled

  • Factors leading to false beliefs:

    • Repetition of false information.

    • Desire for easy answers and quick fixes.

    • Selective perception and memory.

    • Inferring causation from correlation.

    • Exaggeration of a truth.

Goals of Scientific Study of Behavior

  • Goals:

    • Describe behavior.

    • Predict behavior.

    • Identify causes of behavior.

    • Explain behavior $\rightarrow$ control/change behavior

  • Example:

    • Description: 5% of preschoolers exhibit aggressive behavior.

    • Prediction: Preschoolers who watch more violent TV shows exhibit more aggressive behavior.

Ways to Achieve Goals

  • Observational Research: Objectively observe and record behavior.

  • Correlational Research: Measure two variables and determine if a relationship exists.

  • Experimental Research: Control or manipulate one variable (independent variable) to determine if it causes changes in another (dependent variable).

Theories and Hypotheses

  • Theory (Scientific meaning): A systematic body of ideas that organizes what is known about a topic from past observations and makes predictions about future observations.

    • Examples: gravitational theory, Piaget’s theory of cognitive development.

  • Hypothesis: A prediction about the outcome of research, derived from a theory.

    • Supported hypothesis $\rightarrow$ evidence for the theory.

    • Unsupported hypothesis $\rightarrow$ evidence against the theory.

    • Theories gain acceptance as fact with ample support, or are modified/dropped with little support.

Publication and Peer-Review

  • Psychologists publish research in peer-reviewed academic journals.

  • Peer-review ensures high-quality research.

  • Process:

    • Manuscripts are evaluated by knowledgeable researchers.

    • Reviewers provide feedback to the author.

    • Author revises manuscript and responds to reviews.

Measurement

  • Variable: A quality or characteristic that can take on different values for different observations.

    • Examples: height, level of happiness, shoe color, exam color, puzzle difficulty, illumination level, year in school, number of others present.

  • Measurement: Assigning numbers or labels to observations to represent different amounts or qualities.

Operational Definitions

  • Psychological variables are often abstract (e.g., happiness, memory capacity, creativity).

  • Operational definitions define variables in terms of the operations performed to measure them.

    • Examples:

      • Happiness: Self-reported rating on a scale of 0-10 (0 = extremely unhappy, 10 = extremely happy).

      • Memory capacity: Number of words recalled from a list of 50.

      • Creativity: Number of different ways a person thinks of for using a paperclip.

Multiple Operational Definitions

  • A variable can have many possible operational definitions.

    • Creativity examples:

      • Number of different ways to use a paperclip.

      • Time it takes to escape from an escape room.

      • Number of operational definitions for “creativity” a person can think of.

      • Score given to a painting on a scale of 1-100 (100 = very creative).