Pilgrimage of Grace causes 

Political causes

  • Rebels wanted Princess Mary legitimised and restored to the line of succession because Henry had divorced Catherine of Aragon
      * The marriage had been annulment - which states that the marriage had never existed in the first place
      * Mary had been baptised (illegitimised) and could no longer be part of the line of succession due to this marriage
  • Inspired by disaffected pro-Araganese supporters
      * Pro-Araganese wanted wanted to regain lost status in the cause
      * The main two Aragansese nobles are Darcy and Hussey
      * Araganese factions one is known as the conservative faction - stood for traditional role of monarchy and church and disliked the sense of any change
  • Wanted to a parliament to be held at York or Nottingham - North of the Trent
      * This is because the North didn’t feel they had a strong political voice
  • Evil Councillors
      * Rebels identifying crown servants and criticising advice they are giving to the monarch
      * Rebels attack and challenge the advisors but loyal to the monarch - it is a loyal rebellion
      * Crown servants were not from traditional wealthy families and the older nobles’ power was transferred to ‘men of low birth’

Religious Causes

  • 10 of the 24 demands were religious
  • Closure of the monasteries in the North of England
      * Dissolution in the Northern England (mainly in Lincolnshire) - the people in the North felt singled out - they were annoyed
      * Dr Ligh was sent up to Lincolnshire was sent to dissolve the smaller monasteries
      * People were worried in the dissolution of the monasteries meant they would lose the local members of the clergy meaning they will lose their instruction on the path to heaven
  • They wanted the pope to be restores as the head of the Church of England instead of the monarchy
      * In the North they had very strong traditional catholic views and listen to the pope and not the monarch - defending papal authority
      * papal authority is where the pope has more power of the church rather than the monarchy
      * Henry had more control of the church and the rebels wanted to reverse that power back to the pope
  • There was resentment of tithes and the poor quality of many priests - in Cumberland and the region to the West of Pennies
  • Reinstate smaller religious houses

Social Causes

  • Nobility kept increasing rent which made it unpayable
      * The tenants that were unable to pay were evicted
      * Nobility were raising rent above the entry fine (Rat Renting) then subletting it (renting it again) in order to make more profit
      * This increased the rent for mainly peasants - making their lives more difficult
  • Dissolution in the North
      * The poor depended on them for help, they were hospitals for the poor and they provided food and shelter
      * Most people lost their basic education, meaning they were losing their path to heaven as they would need to be able to read the bible
      * Most monasteries spent 5% of their income on providing help for the poor, and this was a huge amount, and the dissolution of monasteries hugely affected the poor
  • Rioting over illegal enclosures (mountains, forests, and parks)
      * Nobles were building fences around land to stop the commons from using it
      * Grievances about enclosures happened in two places - one in Giggleswick (Yorkshire) and Kendal (Lancashire)

Economic Causes

  • Rebels did not want to have to pay taxes
  • Government taxation
      * Subsidy taxes on sheep
  • Inflation was hitting the North
      * Particularly in the cost of land to rent
      * 2 in 4 harvests failed so there was an inflation in food
      * The inflation results in considerable hardship for the poor and for those dependent on charitable giving as little as 3% of monastic wealth went towards the poor
  • Tenths and Fifteenths were being difficult to pay