OPMA 317: Process Analysis & Improvement

OPMA 317: Process Analysis & Improvement


9.2 Learning Highlights

  • Preparation of Formal Process Flow Diagram:

    • A structured method to visualize and detail the flow of processes, enhancing understanding and identification of improvement opportunities.

  • Benchmarking:

    • The formal process of comparing an organization’s processes and performance measures against top performers in the industry.

    • Aimed at identifying gaps, understanding best practices, and creating targets for improvement.

  • Process Improvement Approaches:

    • “Tinker” Approach:

    • Incremental changes to improve existing processes.

    • “Tear-Down” Approach:

    • Radical redesign of processes, focusing on eliminating inefficiencies.

  • Technological Revolution in Industries:

    • Discusses how advancements such as automation and digital technologies have transformed industries, impacting efficiency, production quality, and customer satisfaction.

  • Push vs. Pull Production Systems:

    • Push Production System:

    • Produces goods based on forecast demand; often results in excess inventory.

    • Pull Production System:

    • Produces goods based on actual demand; minimizes excess inventory by controlling production triggers.

  • “Expose the Rocks” Concept:

    • A philosophy emphasizing the identification of hidden problems in processes obscured by excess inventory. This approach advocates for addressing those root issues directly to foster continuous improvement.


Summary of Process Analysis

  • Process analysis encompasses various methodologies and practices aimed at improving business processes.

    • Mini Case: Canadian Blood Services:

    • An example illustrating the complexities and operational challenges in real-world applications of process analysis.

    • 2nd Process Analysis Example:

    • Additional case studies to further illustrate the principles of process analysis in action.

  • Process Improvement Overview:

    • General strategies and methodologies for improving processes continually.

  • Selecting Processes for Improvement:

    • Recognizing Need for Change:

    • Identifying deficiencies or inefficiencies through various performance metrics and feedback loops.

    • Benchmarking:

    • A formal comparative analysis that aids in recognizing improvement opportunities.


Process Improvement Approaches

  • Business Process Reengineering (BPR):

    • A method of redesigning business processes to achieve significant improvements in critical areas like cost, quality, service, and speed.

  • Continuous Process Improvement (CPI):

    • Ongoing efforts to enhance products, services, or processes incrementally over time.

  • Comparison of BPR and CPI:

    • BPR typically involves radical changes while CPI focuses on small, iterative improvements.


Case Study: A Process Improvement Classic

  • Toothpaste Factory Case:

    • Problem: Occasionally shipped empty boxes.

    • Solution Process: External engineering firm hired, which implemented high-tech precision scales to detect defective boxes after a budget of $300,000.

    • Outcome: Initial positive ROI report, later contradicted by findings that no defects were detected, leading to an investigation.

    • Ultimate Revelation:

    • A $20 fan was preventing empty boxes from reaching the scales, showcasing the importance of process analysis and efficiency.


Process Analysis Mini Case: Canadian Blood Services

  • Overview of Canadian Blood Services:

    • A not-for-profit managing blood supply in Canada, serving both government and local communities.

  • Current Process at Blood Collection Clinics:

    • Steps include:

    1. Manual recording of donor information and assignment of number.

    2. Waiting in queue until called.

    3. Health checks include finger prick and eligibility questionnaire.

    • Issue: Long wait times causing donor complaints and potential deterrents for future participation.


Process Flow Chart of Current Blood Collection Process

  • Flow Chart Steps:

    1. Record name, assign card.

    2. Wait for number to be called.

    3. Verify donor information, conduct finger prick.

    4. Check eligibility via questionnaire.

    5. Donate blood or inform ineligibility.

  • Result of the Process:

    • Frustration among donors due to prolonged inefficient workflows.


Process Improvement Proposals

  • Recommendations for Improvement:

    • Move eligibility questionnaire check earlier in the process.

    • Implement online pre-screening questionnaires to reduce on-site wait times.

    • Add signage for common ineligibility reasons.

  • Benefits of Proposed Improvements:

    • Enhanced donor service and satisfaction.

    • Saving of resources on iron test supplies and labor costs.

    • Reduces the number of ineligible inquiries at the clinic.


Process Analysis Example #2: Bread Making Process

  • Overview:

    • Describes a bakery process for producing bread, including mixing, baking, cooling, and packaging.

  • Capacity and Bottleneck Analysis:

    • Current Capacity: 42,000 loaves per week determined by packaging bottleneck; cannot meet 50,000 weekly demand.

    • Effect of Adding Additional Packaging Machine:

    • New bottleneck shifts to cooling capacity, altering production capabilities.


Recognizing the Need for Change in Business Processes

  • Warning Signs of Required Changes:

    • Factors indicating that business processes may need re-evaluation include excessive overtime, declining market share, customer complaints, and other KPI performance declines.


Benchmarking Details

  • Definition:

    • Benchmarking is comparing processes and performance against industry leaders to establish targets for improvement.

  • Categories of Benchmarking:

    • Internal Benchmarking:

    • For multi-location organizations.

    • Competitive Benchmarking:

    • Often challenging due to limited data access.

    • Functional Benchmarking:

    • Comparing with specific processes from distinct industries (e.g., order entry from LL. Bean).


Process Improvement Approaches: BPR vs. CPI

  • Business Process Reengineering (BPR):

    • Typically aimed at radical improvements, entails significant investments and reorganization.

  • Continuous Process Improvement (CPI):

    • Focuses on gradual enhancements involving collective efforts and less disruptive changes.


Conclusion: Employee Involvement and Process Improvement

  • Highlighting the necessity of employee engagement and collaboration in the improvement process.

    • Requires appropriate training, time, and conducive cultural mindset to foster creative problem resolution.

  • Just-In-Time (JIT) Systems and Lean Production:

    • JIT focuses on reducing waste and improving quality by aligning production with demand, creating streamlined processes that enhance efficiency and effectiveness.