Utilitarianism

Lesson 1: Introduction to Utilitarian Ethics

1. Definition:

• A consequentialist theory where the morality of actions is determined by their outcomes.

• The goal is to maximize utility: “the greatest happiness for the greatest number.”

2. Key Thinkers:

• Jeremy Bentham: Introduced utilitarianism and the Hedonistic Calculus to measure pleasure and pain.

• John Stuart Mill: Refined the theory, emphasizing the quality of pleasures (higher intellectual vs. lower physical pleasures).

3. Historical Context:

• Rooted in the Enlightenment’s emphasis on reason and human welfare.

Lesson 2: Fundamental Principles of Utilitarianism

1. The Greatest Happiness Principle:

• Actions are right if they promote happiness or pleasure and wrong if they cause unhappiness or pain.

2. Types of Utilitarianism:

• Act Utilitarianism: Focuses on the consequences of specific actions.

• Rule Utilitarianism: Focuses on adherence to rules that, when followed, maximize happiness.

3. Hedonistic Calculus (Bentham’s Tool):

Evaluates actions based on:

• Intensity: How strong is the pleasure/pain?

• Duration: How long will it last?

• Certainty: How likely is it to occur?

• Propinquity: How soon will it happen?

• Fecundity: Will it lead to more pleasure/pain?

• Purity: Will it lead to mixed results (pleasure and pain)?

• Extent: How many people will be affected?

Lesson 3: Characteristics of Utilitarian Ethics

1. Consequentialism:

• The morality of actions is judged solely by their outcomes.

2. Impartiality and Universality:

• Everyone’s happiness is considered equally; no special treatment based on status or relationship.

3. The Ends Justify the Means:

• Actions are acceptable if they result in the greatest good, even if the means are questionable.

Lesson 4: Applications of Utilitarianism

1. Policy and Public Decision-Making:

• Healthcare: Allocating resources like vaccines to maximize societal benefit.

• Environmental Ethics: Policies to combat climate change for long-term global welfare.

• Welfare Economics: Redistributing wealth to reduce poverty and increase societal happiness.

2. Personal Ethics:

• Encourages consideration of how individual actions impact others’ well-being.

Lesson 5: Critiques of Utilitarianism

1. Justice and Minority Rights:

• May justify sacrificing individual or minority rights for the majority’s happiness (e.g., “tyranny of the majority”).

2. Incommensurability:

• Difficult to compare and measure diverse pleasures and pains.

3. Practical Challenges:

• Predicting Outcomes: Hard to foresee all consequences.

• Immediate Calculations: Time-consuming and complex in urgent situations.

4. Potential to Overlook Individual Rights:

• May permit morally questionable actions if they maximize overall happiness.

Lesson 6: Utilitarianism in Contemporary Contexts

1. Public Policy:

• Cost-benefit analysis to evaluate societal impacts (e.g., environmental regulations, economic policies).

2. Professional Fields:

• Healthcare: Triage systems prioritize patients to maximize overall health benefits.

• Business Ethics: Decisions on pricing or resource allocation based on maximizing utility.

3. Global Ethics:

• Supports efforts like humanitarian aid and sustainability to benefit future generations.

Key Takeaways

• Utilitarianism emphasizes maximizing happiness and minimizing pain for the majority.

• It is widely applicable in ethics, policy-making, and professional domains.

• Critiques highlight challenges in measurement, justice, and individual rights.