Heidegger as Nazi

Radical Philosophy (PHIL 106) Lecture 10: Heidegger - Philosopher and Nazi

1. Heidegger and Nazism: The Facts

2. Philosophical Connections

(a) The Historical Dimension of Authenticity
(b) A Counter-Enlightenment Philosophy
(c) The Mission of Germany

Philosopher and Nazi: The Facts

A. Involvement with National Socialism

  • 22 April 1933: Martin Heidegger elected as Rector of Freiburg University and joined the National Socialist Party.

    • Inaugural address endorsed Nazi policy.

  • Quotation from Heidegger:

    "The university must be integrated again into the Volksgemeinschaft [community of the people] and be joined together with the State... in the National Socialist spirit."

  • Condemnation of "humanizing, Christian ideas" that could undermine National Socialist ideals.

  • November 1933: Implemented policies against "non-Aryans" and Marxists.

B. Resignation and Continued Support

  • 23 April 1934: Resigned as Rector and ceased active participation in Party, but remained a member.

    • Continued to express support for Nazi ideals.

  • 1935 Remarks: Expressed that while he critiqued some philosophical works tied to National Socialism, he recognized the "inner truth and greatness" of the movement.

  • 1936 Conversation: Stated that National Socialism was the right course for Germany, asserting a need to endure.

C. Ethical Dilemmas in Philosophical Engagement

  • Quotation:

    "Do a thinker’s abhorrent political views mean we should stop reading their work? When should we do so? When should we not?"


Philosopher and Nazi: The Question

A. The Ethical Dilemma: Connection of Philosophy and Politics

  • Discussion on whether Heidegger can be viewed as a good philosopher despite his associations with Nazism.

  • Example of Gottlob Frege, an anti-Semite whose logic was not tied to his political stances.

  • Authenticity and Engagement:

    • Heidegger claimed that his philosophy was interconnected with his political views.

    • Reference to 1965 interview asserting that National Socialism aligned with his philosophical aspirations.

B. Interconnections of Philosophy and Politics

  1. The Historical Dimension of Authenticity

  2. A Counter-Enlightenment Philosophy

  3. The Mission of Germany


Connections 1: Historical Dimension of Authenticity

A. Collective Experience and Authenticity

  • Heidegger posited that human existence (Dasein) reaches into a future shaped by its historical context.

  • The Nazi movement viewed as a common destiny shared by the people.

  • Authentic Individuality:

    • Authenticity involves a sense of 'resoluteness' both individually and collectively.

B. Conscience and Authenticity

  • Conscience does not call for a specific action but for authenticity, which varies with context.

  • Interpretation of the Nazi revolution as a departure from complacent meanings.

  • Strenuous engagement with historical forces like nature and language recognized as paths towards authenticity, despite leading into uncertainty.


Connections 2: A Counter-Enlightenment Philosophy

A. Distrust of Modern Ideals

  • Heidegger's critique of both Communism and modern moral/ political ideologies.

    • Belief in equal rights and individual good life considered flawed.

B. Engagement with Reality and Science

  • Heidegger's philosophy emphasizes that the world reveals itself through active participation.

  • Criticism of science's reductionist view of existence and technology as merely a resource.

C. Nature and Technology

  • Distinction between traditional farming and mechanized agriculture.

    • Technology viewed as a way of reducing existence to mere utility and efficiency.

D. Examination of Inauthenticity

  • Critique of liberal democracies as ‘inauthentic incarnate,' engaged in forgetfulness of being and authenticity.


Connections 3: The Mission of Germany

A. World-Historical Responsibility

  • 1942 reflection on human essence and the role of Germany in addressing world issues.

  • Belief in a unique mission attributed to Germans, tying back to a historical and philosophical legacy.

B. Germanic Heritage

  • Heidegger's attraction to German peasant life as a source of authentic existence, glorified by Nazism.

C. Personal Remarks and Philosophical Journey

  • Reference to preference for peasants over philosophers, reflecting a grounded philosophy rooted in everyday life.

D. Philosophical Work Intertwined with Peasant Life

  • Metaphorically aligns philosophical endeavors with the labor of peasants, emphasizing a symbiotic relationship.