Heidegger as Nazi
Radical Philosophy (PHIL 106) Lecture 10: Heidegger - Philosopher and Nazi
1. Heidegger and Nazism: The Facts
2. Philosophical Connections
(a) The Historical Dimension of Authenticity
(b) A Counter-Enlightenment Philosophy
(c) The Mission of Germany
Philosopher and Nazi: The Facts
A. Involvement with National Socialism
22 April 1933: Martin Heidegger elected as Rector of Freiburg University and joined the National Socialist Party.
Inaugural address endorsed Nazi policy.
Quotation from Heidegger:
"The university must be integrated again into the Volksgemeinschaft [community of the people] and be joined together with the State... in the National Socialist spirit."
Condemnation of "humanizing, Christian ideas" that could undermine National Socialist ideals.
November 1933: Implemented policies against "non-Aryans" and Marxists.
B. Resignation and Continued Support
23 April 1934: Resigned as Rector and ceased active participation in Party, but remained a member.
Continued to express support for Nazi ideals.
1935 Remarks: Expressed that while he critiqued some philosophical works tied to National Socialism, he recognized the "inner truth and greatness" of the movement.
1936 Conversation: Stated that National Socialism was the right course for Germany, asserting a need to endure.
C. Ethical Dilemmas in Philosophical Engagement
Quotation:
"Do a thinker’s abhorrent political views mean we should stop reading their work? When should we do so? When should we not?"
Philosopher and Nazi: The Question
A. The Ethical Dilemma: Connection of Philosophy and Politics
Discussion on whether Heidegger can be viewed as a good philosopher despite his associations with Nazism.
Example of Gottlob Frege, an anti-Semite whose logic was not tied to his political stances.
Authenticity and Engagement:
Heidegger claimed that his philosophy was interconnected with his political views.
Reference to 1965 interview asserting that National Socialism aligned with his philosophical aspirations.
B. Interconnections of Philosophy and Politics
The Historical Dimension of Authenticity
A Counter-Enlightenment Philosophy
The Mission of Germany
Connections 1: Historical Dimension of Authenticity
A. Collective Experience and Authenticity
Heidegger posited that human existence (Dasein) reaches into a future shaped by its historical context.
The Nazi movement viewed as a common destiny shared by the people.
Authentic Individuality:
Authenticity involves a sense of 'resoluteness' both individually and collectively.
B. Conscience and Authenticity
Conscience does not call for a specific action but for authenticity, which varies with context.
Interpretation of the Nazi revolution as a departure from complacent meanings.
Strenuous engagement with historical forces like nature and language recognized as paths towards authenticity, despite leading into uncertainty.
Connections 2: A Counter-Enlightenment Philosophy
A. Distrust of Modern Ideals
Heidegger's critique of both Communism and modern moral/ political ideologies.
Belief in equal rights and individual good life considered flawed.
B. Engagement with Reality and Science
Heidegger's philosophy emphasizes that the world reveals itself through active participation.
Criticism of science's reductionist view of existence and technology as merely a resource.
C. Nature and Technology
Distinction between traditional farming and mechanized agriculture.
Technology viewed as a way of reducing existence to mere utility and efficiency.
D. Examination of Inauthenticity
Critique of liberal democracies as ‘inauthentic incarnate,' engaged in forgetfulness of being and authenticity.
Connections 3: The Mission of Germany
A. World-Historical Responsibility
1942 reflection on human essence and the role of Germany in addressing world issues.
Belief in a unique mission attributed to Germans, tying back to a historical and philosophical legacy.
B. Germanic Heritage
Heidegger's attraction to German peasant life as a source of authentic existence, glorified by Nazism.
C. Personal Remarks and Philosophical Journey
Reference to preference for peasants over philosophers, reflecting a grounded philosophy rooted in everyday life.
D. Philosophical Work Intertwined with Peasant Life
Metaphorically aligns philosophical endeavors with the labor of peasants, emphasizing a symbiotic relationship.