APGOV Unit 3 Review
THE BILL OF RIGHTS
The first 10 amendments of the Constitution were designed to protect civil liberties
Civil liberties: guarantees and freedoms that protect citizens from the government
Federalists - in favor of a more powerful central government
Anti-Federalists - in favor of more powerful states
Anti-Federalists said they wouldn’t ratify a constitution without the Bill of Rights
George Mason was a major antifederalist from Virginia
James Madison was a major federalist who helped write the Constitution, who argued against a bill of rights, saying that a good government won’t trample civil liberties, so no point in spelling it all out
Madison says that if we were to list civil liberties out, something would get left out, so it's better not to mention anything specifically
In 1787, the Constitution was signed
Madison wrote more than 10 amendments, but only 10 were ratified
These only protect citizens from the federal government, not the states, because the anti-federalists were concerned only about the federal government
FIRST AMENDMENT
Freedom of Religion:
The balance is between the religious practice of the majority and the free exercise of the minority religious practice
“Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof…”
establishment clause: Congress can’t establish a national church
Free Exercise Clause: You can practice your religion without interference from the government
Johnson Amendment: churches that don’t pay taxes can’t support or oppose political candidates
Republicans don’t want the Johnson Amendments because they think it takes freedom of speech away from pastors
Engel v Vitale, 1962: NY asked students to recite a non-sectarian short prayer before school started. The Supreme Court said this was a violation of the Establishment Clause of the First Amendment. State-sponsored prayers were unconstitutional
Wisconsin v Yoder, 1972: An Amish family wanted to remove their children from school after 8th grade, but Wisconsin law prohibited them from doing so. The Supreme Court ruled that the state's interest in educating children was outweighed by the family's right to exercise their religious beliefs freely.
Freedom of Speech:
Tinker v Des Moines: Students in Iowa wore black armbands to school to protest the Vietnam War. They were suspended and the students claimed that it was a violation of their right to Free Speech (symbolic). The Supreme Court agreed, saying that it caused no disruption, only fear of disruption.
When the court is making decisions about free speech, they are attempting to make the balance between individual freedom and social order
The court will decide based on time, place, and manner regulations, which are content-neutral regulations (they don’t restrict the words being said, only when, where, and how)
or based on defamatory (using speech to harm someone else, rarely protected), offensive (difficult to define), and obscene (difficult to define) speech regulations
clear and present danger rule: speech can be silenced if it is considered dangerous in some way
Schenck v United States (1990): Schenck was a socialist and against American involvement in WWI, so he made pamphlets discouraging men from participating in the drafting of the war. He got arrested under the Espionage Act. The court ruled that his conviction was constitutional, establishing the precedent that speech posing a "clear and present danger" to national security or public safety could be restricted.
The clear and present danger test is no longer used; the Brandenburg test has since taken its place, which makes it more difficult for the government to censor this kind of speech as it requires that speech be directed to inciting or producing imminent lawless action and that it is likely to produce such action.
Freedom of the Press
George Mason believed that the freedom of the press was one of the greatest bulwarks of liberty and should never be restrained
balance between national security and freedom of the press
prior restraint: if the government wants to exercise prior restraint over the press, its trying to restrain a story prior to its publication, or keep a story or article from being published
standard for prior restraint has been set very high
NYT v US: A stack of Pentagon Papers was leaked to the NYT, revealing Nixon had been lying about the war, and they began publishing stories about it. Nixon wanted to invoke prior restraint to protect national security. The court ruled that the freedom of the press was more important than national security in this situation, establishing a high presumption against prior restraint.
SECOND AMENDMENT
“A well-regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free state, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms shall not be infringed.”
The conflict about the Second Amendment arose over the first phrase of the amendment, arguing about the “security of a free state”
Back when the Constitution was being created, a standing army was a sign of tyranny
They wanted to create an army in times of war, then immediately disband it as soon as it was over; therefore, every man should own a gun if they were to be called to serve at any point
Basically, since we have a strong standing army that already bears arms, does that mean that our Second Amendment rights still apply?
FYI, the District of Columbia is a federal district, not a state
INDIVIDUAL FREEDOM VS. PUBLIC ORDER
None of our rights is absolute
Individual freedom v social order
8th Amendment: “Excessive bail shall not be required, nor excessive fines imposed, nor cruel and unusual punishments inflicted”
Is the death sentence a violation of “cruel and unusual punishments”?
4th Amendment: protects citizens against unreasonable searches and seizures of property; warrants must be secured before entering a person’s home, which can only be issued by courts when probable cause is well established
The controversy surrounding the 4th amendment has to do with security surrounding digital stuff
After the terrorist attacks, President Bush issued the patriot act that allowed the government to search through people’s metadata to find potential terrorists
SELECTIVE INCORPORATION
The process by which the Bill of Rights is applied to the states
14th Amendment: “No state shall make or enforce any law which shall abridge the privileges or immunities of citizens of the United States.”
The federal government must be restrained from infringing on the rights of citizens, and now the states have to adhere to these protections as well, ensuring that individual rights are upheld at both the national and state levels.
McDonald v Chicago (2010): Chicago had a law that said all handguns had to be registered, but the state had rejected gun registrations since the early 1980s, making it impossible to own one. When brought before the Supreme Court, the justices ruled that the Second Amendment right to keep and bear arms is applicable to the states through the 14th Amendment's Due Process Clause, thereby striking down Chicago's law as unconstitutional.
The amendments that have been SELECTIVELY incorporated to the states through SCOTUS decisions have been the 1st, 2nd, 4th, 5th, 6th, and 8th Amendments
DUE PROCESS AND THE RIGHTS OF THE ACCUSED
due process of law (from the 5th Amendment): “No person shall…be deprived of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law.” This principle ensures that all legal proceedings are fair and that individuals are given a chance to contest the legal actions taken against them, thereby protecting citizens from arbitrary denial of their rights.
Basically, the government has to follow established legal proceedings before sentencing someone, they can’t just sentence someone for no reason
the FOURTEENTH AMENDMENT makes it so that the states also have to follow the due process
4th Amendment: “The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated…”
Exclusionary rule: any evidence that is gathered in violation of the Fourth Amendment (without a proper warrant for the search) will be excluded from a person’s trial
Miranda rule: upon arresting someone, the officer must recite the following script: “You have the right to remain silent. Anything you say can and will be used against you in a court of law. You have the right to an attorney . . . “
public safety exception to the Miranda rights: if the officer took action before reciting the miranda warning because they were concerned about their safety it is considered an exception to the requirement, allowing any statements made by the suspect to be admissible in court.
In normal cases, any evidence gathered before reciting the Miranda are not admissible in court
6th Amendment: “In all criminal prosecutions, the accused shall enjoy the right… to have the assistance of counsel for his defense.” If you get arrested, you have the right to a lawyer
Gideon v Wainwright: Gideon was arrested and tried in a Florida court. Florida did not provide Gideon with a lawyer, and he was convicted. And when appearing in front of the Supreme Court on appeal, the Supreme Court incorporated the 6th Amendment to the states.
DUE PROCESS AND THE RIGHT TO PRIVACY
Equal Protection Clause of the 14th Amendment: “No state shall make or enforce any law which shall abridge the privileges or immunities of citizens of the United States… nor deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws.”
The Bill of Rights does not explicitly guarantee the right to privacy; however, the Supreme Court has interpreted several amendments to imply this right based on the 1st, 4th, 5th, 9th, and 14th Amendments
Roe v Wade (1972): The landmark Supreme Court case that established a woman's legal right to have an abortion under the right to privacy, ruling that the state could not impose excessive restrictions on this right during the first trimester of pregnancy. Jane Roe could not obtain an abortion because of the laws in Texas; she appealed to the Supreme Court, arguing that her rights had been infringed upon. The court agreed and ended up overturning abortion laws across the country.
The decision in Roe v. Wade: A woman’s right to abortion is considered her constitutional right to privacy. However, this right is not absolute, just like any other right protected, because at some point (viability), a pregnant woman has an actual human in her with whom her rights may be tempered because of the state’s interest in upholding the life of the child. The court defines the age of viability at the first trimester, which means that before the first trimester, states could not in any way restrict abortion. In the second trimester, states could make restrictions if they were related to the mother’s health. The third-trimester states could prohibit abortions entirely unless the mother’s health and life were at stake.
SOCIAL MOVEMENTS AND EQUAL PROTECTION
Civil Liberties: rights guaranteed to every American citizen by the Constitution
Civil Rights Movements: Ensures that every American regardless of sex, religion, or race has equal access to those civil liberties
CIVIL RIGHTS HAVE ATTEMPTED TO APPLY THOSE RIGHTS TO EVERYONE THROUGH THE DUE PROCESS AND EQUAL PROTECTION CLAUSES OF THE FOURTEENTH AMENDMENT
Civil Rights movements —> 14th Amendment
The 13th Amendment formally abolished slavery in the US, so every formally enslaved person was now a citizen of the United States.
The civil rights movement for blacks began around the 1950s
Martin Luther King Jr. promoted and led a nonviolent approach to this
Jim Crow segregation laws were enacted in the South, enforcing racial discrimination and limiting the rights of African Americans until the civil rights movement sought to dismantle these oppressive practices.
Women’s Rights movements: The ratification of the 19th Amendment in 1920 recognized women’s right to vote; however, there were still further discriminations, which led to the National Organization for Women, or NOW, being founded in 1966.
The Civil Rights Act of 1964 banned discrimination based on sex but was weakly enforced
NOW’s goal was to pass the ERA (“Equality of rights under the law shall not be denied or abridged by the United States or by any State on account of sex.”)
The ERA fell short of ratification
Education Amendment Act Title IX guaranteed women the same opportunities as men in educational societies that received federal funding
LGBTQ movement: gay men and women could not serve in the military; President Clinton wanted to reverse it, but instead passed the “don’t ask, don’t tell” policy: gay people could serve in the military, but don’t tell anyone, and no one would ask. President Obama then made it so that gays could serve in the military
Right to Life movement (abortion): came to light after Roe v Wade, and was mostly between women vs Christian and white evangelists
Hatch Amendment: proposed and unpassed amendment to the Constitution that would restrict abortion; per state, whichever law was stricter (state law or federal law) would become the law in that state
LETTER FROM BIRMINGHAM JAIL
How the Equal Protection Clause in the 14th Amendment supported and motivated social movements (civil rights movements for black equality)
In 1963, King led a campaign to desegregate Birmingham Alabama's shopping district, which got King and lots of others arrested
A group of white clergymen who were generally sympathetic to the movement published an open letter in the newspaper asking black people to wait instead of protesting, and this document is a response to this
Then he justified the nonviolent movement that he and other blacks were doing
He sought to create such tension that the community that has refused to negotiate is now forced to confront the issue
King explained that being patient and waiting would never work because “wait” means “never”
He argued that freedom must be demanded by the oppressed and that it is an urgent necessity, rather than a distant goal.
BALANCING MAJORITY AND MINORITY RIGHTS
Plessy v Ferguson ruled that racial segregation was fine and constitutional as long as it was “separate but equal.”
Black schools were not funded as much as white schools
Brown v Board of Education: overturned the separate but equal doctrine and ruled that racial separation is unequal, no matter what
Civil Rights Act of 1964: made it illegal to discriminate against anyone because of their race
Voting Rights Act of 1965: made it illegal to discriminate against voters
Title IX of the Education Amendments Act (1972): Title VI says that it’s illegal to discriminate against race, color, or national origin (excluding sex).
Title IX of the Education Amendments Act (1972) prohibits discrimination on the basis of sex in any educational program or activity receiving federal financial assistance.
Majority-Minority districts: a district in which the majority is a minority
AFFIRMATIVE ACTION
Describes policies enacted that favor groups that have been historically discriminated against
Takes action against discrimination instead of passing discrimination laws that will hopefully solve it
John F Kennedy signed a thing that said that the government had to actively seek different minorities to do work instead of opening jobs and saying anyone could have them
People argued that this policy discriminated against whites
So, is affirmative action constitutional or not
Since the Constitution does not make any claims about race, should race still be considered, or does the Constitution say that we should still do it if it helps historically discriminated races
De jure segregation: racial discrimination by law (Jim Crow laws)
de facto segregation: racial discrimination by choice (when a group of blacks migrates somewhere so that there are all blacks in one section and all whites in another)
Where de jure segregation is not clear, the court generally has ruled against affirmative action