Principles of Pharmacology: Concentration-Response Curve
Learning Outcomes
Draw typical "concentration vs response" and "log concentration vs response" curves with labeled axes.
List common responses to drugs and explain how they are measured.
Distinguish between in vitro, in vivo, and ex vivo measurements.
Explain the term "EC50" and how it is measured.
Distinguish between the terms "potency", "potency ratio", and "relative potency".
Explain the term "Therapeutic Index" and how it is measured.
Introduction
"All substances are poisons: There is none which is not a poison. The right dose differentiates a poison and a remedy." - Paracelsus (1493-1541)
The Concentration-Response Relationship
Drug effects are quantified by studying the relationship between drug concentration (or dose) and the response produced by the drug.
This relationship is described by concentration-response curves.
Drug concentration vs. response: rectangular hyperbola.
Log drug concentration vs. response: symmetrical sigmoid.
Types of Pharmacological Experiments
In vitro: Drug effects are studied on a piece of tissue dissected from an animal (or human) and kept alive outside the body.
Most common type of experiment, including experiments on cells grown in tissue culture.
Responses measured: changes in muscle tension, enzyme activity, or hormone/neurotransmitter secretion.
Example: Effects of nicotine (NIC) on noradrenaline release from human cerebral cortex slices.
In vivo: Drug effects are studied in the living animal (or human).
Includes clinical trials, tightly regulated.
Responses measured: increase in blood pressure, reduction in pain threshold, reduction in allergen-induced bronchoconstriction.
Ex vivo: A tissue or organ is removed from an animal treated with a drug, and the drug's effects on organ function are tested in vitro.
Tightly regulated.
Examples: Experiments to see whether long-term drug treatment induces liver damage or alters brain biochemistry.
Concentration Units
For in vitro experiments, concentrations are expressed in Moles per litre i.e. Molar (M).
1 Mole of a drug contains 6.02 \times 10^{23} drug molecules which weighs the molecular mass, in grams.
A 1 Molar solution contains 1 Mole of a drug dissolved in 1 litre of solvent.
A 1 Molar solution of drug “X” will contain the same number of drug molecules as a 1 Molar solution of drug “Y”.
Drug Concentrations
Most clinically useful drugs act at concentrations in the range 1 \times 10^{-6}M to 1 \times 10^{-12}M.
Pharmacologists use prefixes: milli (m) for 10^{-3}, micro ((\mu)m) for 10^{-6}, and nano (n) for 10^{-9}.
A 1 micromolar ((\mu)M) solution is the same as a 1 \times 10^{-6} M solution.
Scientific Notation Examples
0.1 nM = 0.1 \times 10^{-9} M = 1.0 \times 10^{-10} M
0.5 mM = 0.5 \times 10^{-3} M = 5.0 \times 10^{-4} M
10 mM = 10 \times 10^{-3} M = 1.0 \times 10^{-2} M
30 nM = 30 \times 10^{-9} M = 3.0 \times 10^{-8} M
Constructing a Concentration-Response Curve
Simplified organ bath apparatus is used.
Cumulative concentration-response curve: Drug is not washed out between different concentrations.
Doses In Vivo
Molar concentrations cannot be used for in vivo experiments because the volume of the solvent (e.g., blood) is not known.
Drug doses are expressed as weight of drug per weight of animal, e.g., 1 mg per kg (1 mgkg^{-1}).
This allows an approximate extrapolation of the dose from a 20 gram mouse to a 70 kg human.
Maximum Effect (Emax)
Indicates the maximum response (effect) the drug can produce.
Increasing the concentration of the drug produces no greater effect.
EC50
Tells us the position of the curve on the concentration axis.
Defined as "the Molar concentration of a drug that produces 50% of the maximum response for that drug".
Sometimes other percentage values are used, e.g., EC90 or EC20.
Potency
A commonly used term to describe the concentration at which a drug is effective.
A potent drug is effective in very small amounts.
Can be quantified using the EC50.
The lower the EC50, the more potent the drug.
Comparing EC50 values for two drugs with the same action allows us to calculate their relative potencies, described by the potency ratio (M).
Often we will be comparing a new drug (the ‘test’ drug) with a drug that is already available (the ‘standard’ drug).
M = \frac{EC50(test)}{EC50(standard)} or \log M = \log EC50(test) - \log EC50(standard)
Potency Ratio
If drug ‘A’ is our standard drug, then M = 20. What if ‘B’ were the standard?
Note that a value of M less than 1.0 means that the test drug is more potent than the standard
Therapeutic Index
The ratio between the toxic dose of a drug and the dose producing the desired therapeutic effect.
The higher the therapeutic index, the less chance of the drug producing toxic side-effects in therapeutic use.
An important concept, but actually very difficult to quantify.
Sometimes defined as: Therapeutic index = \frac{LD50}{ED50}
LD50 = lethal dose in 50% of the population
ED50 = Effective dose in 50% of the population
No longer used for several reasons:
It is a meaningless definition from a clinical perspective. Death is a rather extreme side effect!
Ethically, it is no longer defensible to obtain LD50 values in animals.
In humans, therapeutic index can be calculated as \frac{TD50}{ED50}
Where TD50 is the “toxic” dose in 50% of the population, where look for the dose that produces some sign of toxicity e.g. causes nausea
But even then, we must treat it with caution because:
There is a wide person-to-person variation in both toxic and beneficial effects of drugs.
A drug can have different ED50 values depending on the condition being treated; e.g., the effective dose of ibuprofen for treating headache is lower than that for treating arthritis.
So, the concept of the therapeutic index is an important one, but it is not easy to derive a single value for any given drug.