Chapter 1.1
What Is Psychological Abnormality?
Psychological abnormality is challenging to define, despite various definitions proposed over years.
Most definitions share common features known as the "four Ds":
Deviance: behavior that is different, extreme, unusual, or bizarre.
Distress: emotional suffering that is unpleasant for the individual.
Dysfunction: interference with daily activities and the ability to function effectively.
Danger: behavior that poses a risk to oneself or others.
While these elements provide a starting framework, there are significant limitations to this definition.
Deviance
Abnormal psychological functioning is considered deviant, but deviant from what?
An example: Amira's behavior, including crying at night and having disturbing thoughts, deviates from typical societal norms.
Cultural context influences perceptions of deviance:
Norms vary from culture to culture, shaped by history, values, technology, etc.
Example: Padaung women wear neck rings, which are normal in their culture but abnormal in Western societies.
Societal Norms: Behaviors that break legal norms are criminal, while those that violate psychological norms are labeled abnormal.
Change Over Time: Definitions of normality can shift. For instance, demanding women in leadership roles were once viewed as delusional but are now seen as empowered.
Contextual Considerations: Situational factors matter. E.g., Amira's emotional response during the COVID-19 pandemic is more understandable in context.
Distress
Unusual functioning does not automatically qualify as abnormal unless it causes distress.
Example: Ice Breakers in Michigan swim in freezing lakes; their behavior is not distressful and is seen positively, suggesting normal functioning despite its unusualness.
Positive Frame of Mind: Individuals can experience distressing situations without feeling distressed.
Example: Alberto enjoys hearing voices and feels empowered by them. His experience might still be viewed as abnormal despite his positive feelings.
Dysfunction
Abnormal behaviors often disrupt daily functioning.
Example: Alberto quitting his job and distancing himself from his family indicates dysfunction, contrasting the Ice Breakers who maintain their jobs and enjoy relationships.
Danger
Dangerous behavior is a significant aspect of psychological dysfunction and involves risk to self or others.
Despite common beliefs, most individuals with psychological issues (like anxiety or depression) do not pose a danger.
The Elusive Nature of Abnormality
Definitions of psychological abnormality raise numerous questions and uncertainties.
Thomas Szasz's View: He argues that what society labels as mental illness are merely "problems in living," questioning the validity of mental illness as a concept.
Evolving Norms: Societal definitions of abnormality have changed over decades. For instance, tattoos, previously viewed as abnormal, are now widely accepted, with nearly 40% of US adults having one.
Familiarity and Blindness: Commonly accepted behaviors (like excessive college drinking) may be overlooked despite being abnormal. Acknowledging abnormality often requires objective criteria and awareness of cultural biases.
Eccentricity vs. Abnormality: Distinguishing between behaviors needing intervention and those regarded as eccentric can be difficult—some peculiar behaviors may seem abnormal yet are accepted as eccentric.
Summing Up
Psychological abnormalities are usually characterized as deviant, distressful, dysfunctional, and potentially dangerous.
Context is critical in evaluating abnormal behaviors, emphasizing the role of societal norms and values.