Chapter 1.1

What Is Psychological Abnormality?

  • Psychological abnormality is challenging to define, despite various definitions proposed over years.

  • Most definitions share common features known as the "four Ds":

    • Deviance: behavior that is different, extreme, unusual, or bizarre.

    • Distress: emotional suffering that is unpleasant for the individual.

    • Dysfunction: interference with daily activities and the ability to function effectively.

    • Danger: behavior that poses a risk to oneself or others.

  • While these elements provide a starting framework, there are significant limitations to this definition.

Deviance

  • Abnormal psychological functioning is considered deviant, but deviant from what?

  • An example: Amira's behavior, including crying at night and having disturbing thoughts, deviates from typical societal norms.

  • Cultural context influences perceptions of deviance:

    • Norms vary from culture to culture, shaped by history, values, technology, etc.

    • Example: Padaung women wear neck rings, which are normal in their culture but abnormal in Western societies.

  • Societal Norms: Behaviors that break legal norms are criminal, while those that violate psychological norms are labeled abnormal.

  • Change Over Time: Definitions of normality can shift. For instance, demanding women in leadership roles were once viewed as delusional but are now seen as empowered.

  • Contextual Considerations: Situational factors matter. E.g., Amira's emotional response during the COVID-19 pandemic is more understandable in context.

Distress

  • Unusual functioning does not automatically qualify as abnormal unless it causes distress.

  • Example: Ice Breakers in Michigan swim in freezing lakes; their behavior is not distressful and is seen positively, suggesting normal functioning despite its unusualness.

  • Positive Frame of Mind: Individuals can experience distressing situations without feeling distressed.

  • Example: Alberto enjoys hearing voices and feels empowered by them. His experience might still be viewed as abnormal despite his positive feelings.

Dysfunction

  • Abnormal behaviors often disrupt daily functioning.

  • Example: Alberto quitting his job and distancing himself from his family indicates dysfunction, contrasting the Ice Breakers who maintain their jobs and enjoy relationships.

Danger

  • Dangerous behavior is a significant aspect of psychological dysfunction and involves risk to self or others.

  • Despite common beliefs, most individuals with psychological issues (like anxiety or depression) do not pose a danger.

The Elusive Nature of Abnormality

  • Definitions of psychological abnormality raise numerous questions and uncertainties.

  • Thomas Szasz's View: He argues that what society labels as mental illness are merely "problems in living," questioning the validity of mental illness as a concept.

  • Evolving Norms: Societal definitions of abnormality have changed over decades. For instance, tattoos, previously viewed as abnormal, are now widely accepted, with nearly 40% of US adults having one.

  • Familiarity and Blindness: Commonly accepted behaviors (like excessive college drinking) may be overlooked despite being abnormal. Acknowledging abnormality often requires objective criteria and awareness of cultural biases.

  • Eccentricity vs. Abnormality: Distinguishing between behaviors needing intervention and those regarded as eccentric can be difficult—some peculiar behaviors may seem abnormal yet are accepted as eccentric.

Summing Up

  • Psychological abnormalities are usually characterized as deviant, distressful, dysfunctional, and potentially dangerous.

  • Context is critical in evaluating abnormal behaviors, emphasizing the role of societal norms and values.