primaries and caucuses (1)
stage 1: primaries and caucuses. candidates in same party compete against each other in public vote
as incumbent president, nobody challenged donald trump
joe biden, bernie sanders, elizabeth warren, pete buttigieg were some of the candidates
fixed term – every 4 years.
first held in 1788.
if a president dies in office: no election, VP takes over
When JFK was assassinated in 1963 his VP Lyndon Johnson took over remaining months of the Presidency.
timing of the elections is in Article II of the constitution – stipulating every four years.
federal law goes further saying they should be held on Tuesday after the first Monday in November of every fourth year
to stand for president you must be:
natural born american citizen
at least 35 years old
youngest ever was theodore roosevelt (became president after mckinley's assassination in 1901) who was 42
youngest ever elected was jfk who was 43.
in 1951 the constitution was amended to limit presidents to two terms in office.
dwight eisenhower was the first to be bound with this along with regan, clinton, george w bush + obama
fourth constitutional requirement could be added – to not have already served 2 terms as president
Political experience
Major party endorsement
Personal characteristics
Ability to raise large sums of money
Effective organisation
Oratorical skills and being telegenic
Sound and relevant policies
potentially most important extra-constitutional requirement
2 groups have good pools of potential candidates:
state governors
state senators
of 22 candidates for Republican + Democratic presidential nominations in 2016:
11 had served as state governor
8 were senators
Other 3 – Donald Trump, Ben Carson & Carly Fiorina had no previous political experience.
Donald Trump was first person to be elected president w out any experience in either politics/military.
Of 19 people nominated as presidential candidates 1969-2016:
10 served in Senate
6 served as State governors
6 served as Vice President
despite large field of political experience in 2016, none of them were able to defeat a political novice (Trump).
if serious, have to be candidate for one of 2 major political parties
Wallace (1968), Anderson (1980), Perot (1992 & 1996), Buchanan (2000), Johnson (2016) showed third party + independent candidates don’t reach White House
Year | Winning Candidate | Losing Candidate |
1980 | Ronald Regan (R) | Jimmy Carter (D) |
1984 | Ronald Regan (R) | Walter Mondale (D) |
1988 | George H.W. Bush (R) | Michael Dukakis (D) |
1992 | Bill Clinton (D) | George H.W. Bush (R) |
1996 | Bill Clinton (D) | Bob Dole (R) |
2000 | George W. Bush (R) | Al Gore (D) |
2004 | George W. Bush (R) | John Kerry (D) |
2008 | Barack Obama (D) | John McCain (R) |
2012 | Barack Obama (D) | Mitt Romney (R) |
2016 | Donald Trump (R) | Hillary Clinton (D) |
2020 | Joe Biden (D) | Donald Trump (R) |
traditional discussion points out all presidential candidates have been white males.
This disappeared in 2008 when the choice was between a black man (Obama) or a white woman (Hillary Clinton).
Given pools of recruitment it isn't surprising that until 2008 this was the case – and whilst Hillary Clinton was the first female presidential candidate for a major party in 2016 – the recruitment pools are still dominated by men.
Being married is an advantage – only James Buchanan (1856) was a bachelor.
A scandal involving marital infidelity used to rule out potential candidates – but Clinton managed to secure the Democratic Party nomination despite allegations surrounding Gennifer Flowers.
Three of the Republican's last eight presidential candidates – Regan, John McCain and Trump have all divorced and remarried.
Crucial to a successful bid.
Campaigns are expensive – and only billionaires (Ross Perot – 92; Steve Forbes 96 & 00) have been able to finance their own campaigns.
Candidates have to raise the money before the primaries and caucuses begin - which means raising money the year before the election.
According to opensecrets.org, Hillary Clinton raised just over $700m during her unsuccessful Presidency bid in 2016!
During candidate selection process, major parties can’t endorse specific candidates
means candidates can’t use party's organisational structure either nationally or in each state
have to create own organisation
time consuming
expensive
demanding
consequences of not having effective organisation are dire for campaign
Abilities to speak well + look good on TV are crucial.
Trump's mastery of media was important factor in 2016 victory
Danger is that presidential elections can be portrayed as all style + no substance.
Candidates will get found out if campaign is 'policy free zone'.
Trump was an exception – he did have key policies on immigration and jobs but was thin on policy detail and tended to just repeat the promise of 'Make America great again'.
How they work | How it happened (2024) |
Candidates from the same party compete against each other in a public vote. In some years there are two (Democrat and Republican). It is unusual for a sitting President seeking a second term to be challenged. | Only 8 Republicans appeared in the first primary debate. This was lower than usual (Trump factor?). The first took place in August 2023. By January 10 there were only 2 candidates left debating… the final 3 debates were cancelled. |
Different states hold their primaries on different dates. Primaries tend to start in February – by tradition the first two states to hold them are New Hampshire and Iowa. | 8 candidates withdraw before the primaries leaving 5. Trump won the Iowa Caucus on Jan 15 – the first Republican to ever win an outright majority. By New Hampshire on Jan 23rd, Trump and Nikki Haley were the only two candidates left. He won 54-46. |
Some states choose to hold their primaries on the same day as each other to maximise their influence. It’s usually known as Super Tuesday. | Held on March 5th, it was still between Trump and Haley. Trump took all the states apart from Vermont. Biden was opposed by Jason Palmer who took American Samoa. |
Each state is given a number of delegates reflecting its population. Delegates are party activists that will go to a meeting after all states have had their primary. Usually each state awards delegates proportionally, but not always. | Example from New Hampshire: Trump (13), Haley (9) Example from Vermont: Haley (9), Trump (8) Example from Arkansas: Trump (39), Haley (1) Example from California: Trump (169), Haley (0) |
At the end of the primaries, the vote is confirmed at the party convention. | Republican Convention: Trump (2388), Haley (41) Democrat Convention: Biden withdrew on July 21. His support prior was 3905. A virtual nomination process took place to install Kamala Harris as candidate instead. She was then confirmed as candidate with 4567 delegates supporting in a ‘virtual roll call’. |
stage 1: primaries and caucuses. candidates in same party compete against each other in public vote
as incumbent president, nobody challenged donald trump
joe biden, bernie sanders, elizabeth warren, pete buttigieg were some of the candidates
fixed term – every 4 years.
first held in 1788.
if a president dies in office: no election, VP takes over
When JFK was assassinated in 1963 his VP Lyndon Johnson took over remaining months of the Presidency.
timing of the elections is in Article II of the constitution – stipulating every four years.
federal law goes further saying they should be held on Tuesday after the first Monday in November of every fourth year
to stand for president you must be:
natural born american citizen
at least 35 years old
youngest ever was theodore roosevelt (became president after mckinley's assassination in 1901) who was 42
youngest ever elected was jfk who was 43.
in 1951 the constitution was amended to limit presidents to two terms in office.
dwight eisenhower was the first to be bound with this along with regan, clinton, george w bush + obama
fourth constitutional requirement could be added – to not have already served 2 terms as president
Political experience
Major party endorsement
Personal characteristics
Ability to raise large sums of money
Effective organisation
Oratorical skills and being telegenic
Sound and relevant policies
potentially most important extra-constitutional requirement
2 groups have good pools of potential candidates:
state governors
state senators
of 22 candidates for Republican + Democratic presidential nominations in 2016:
11 had served as state governor
8 were senators
Other 3 – Donald Trump, Ben Carson & Carly Fiorina had no previous political experience.
Donald Trump was first person to be elected president w out any experience in either politics/military.
Of 19 people nominated as presidential candidates 1969-2016:
10 served in Senate
6 served as State governors
6 served as Vice President
despite large field of political experience in 2016, none of them were able to defeat a political novice (Trump).
if serious, have to be candidate for one of 2 major political parties
Wallace (1968), Anderson (1980), Perot (1992 & 1996), Buchanan (2000), Johnson (2016) showed third party + independent candidates don’t reach White House
Year | Winning Candidate | Losing Candidate |
1980 | Ronald Regan (R) | Jimmy Carter (D) |
1984 | Ronald Regan (R) | Walter Mondale (D) |
1988 | George H.W. Bush (R) | Michael Dukakis (D) |
1992 | Bill Clinton (D) | George H.W. Bush (R) |
1996 | Bill Clinton (D) | Bob Dole (R) |
2000 | George W. Bush (R) | Al Gore (D) |
2004 | George W. Bush (R) | John Kerry (D) |
2008 | Barack Obama (D) | John McCain (R) |
2012 | Barack Obama (D) | Mitt Romney (R) |
2016 | Donald Trump (R) | Hillary Clinton (D) |
2020 | Joe Biden (D) | Donald Trump (R) |
traditional discussion points out all presidential candidates have been white males.
This disappeared in 2008 when the choice was between a black man (Obama) or a white woman (Hillary Clinton).
Given pools of recruitment it isn't surprising that until 2008 this was the case – and whilst Hillary Clinton was the first female presidential candidate for a major party in 2016 – the recruitment pools are still dominated by men.
Being married is an advantage – only James Buchanan (1856) was a bachelor.
A scandal involving marital infidelity used to rule out potential candidates – but Clinton managed to secure the Democratic Party nomination despite allegations surrounding Gennifer Flowers.
Three of the Republican's last eight presidential candidates – Regan, John McCain and Trump have all divorced and remarried.
Crucial to a successful bid.
Campaigns are expensive – and only billionaires (Ross Perot – 92; Steve Forbes 96 & 00) have been able to finance their own campaigns.
Candidates have to raise the money before the primaries and caucuses begin - which means raising money the year before the election.
According to opensecrets.org, Hillary Clinton raised just over $700m during her unsuccessful Presidency bid in 2016!
During candidate selection process, major parties can’t endorse specific candidates
means candidates can’t use party's organisational structure either nationally or in each state
have to create own organisation
time consuming
expensive
demanding
consequences of not having effective organisation are dire for campaign
Abilities to speak well + look good on TV are crucial.
Trump's mastery of media was important factor in 2016 victory
Danger is that presidential elections can be portrayed as all style + no substance.
Candidates will get found out if campaign is 'policy free zone'.
Trump was an exception – he did have key policies on immigration and jobs but was thin on policy detail and tended to just repeat the promise of 'Make America great again'.
How they work | How it happened (2024) |
Candidates from the same party compete against each other in a public vote. In some years there are two (Democrat and Republican). It is unusual for a sitting President seeking a second term to be challenged. | Only 8 Republicans appeared in the first primary debate. This was lower than usual (Trump factor?). The first took place in August 2023. By January 10 there were only 2 candidates left debating… the final 3 debates were cancelled. |
Different states hold their primaries on different dates. Primaries tend to start in February – by tradition the first two states to hold them are New Hampshire and Iowa. | 8 candidates withdraw before the primaries leaving 5. Trump won the Iowa Caucus on Jan 15 – the first Republican to ever win an outright majority. By New Hampshire on Jan 23rd, Trump and Nikki Haley were the only two candidates left. He won 54-46. |
Some states choose to hold their primaries on the same day as each other to maximise their influence. It’s usually known as Super Tuesday. | Held on March 5th, it was still between Trump and Haley. Trump took all the states apart from Vermont. Biden was opposed by Jason Palmer who took American Samoa. |
Each state is given a number of delegates reflecting its population. Delegates are party activists that will go to a meeting after all states have had their primary. Usually each state awards delegates proportionally, but not always. | Example from New Hampshire: Trump (13), Haley (9) Example from Vermont: Haley (9), Trump (8) Example from Arkansas: Trump (39), Haley (1) Example from California: Trump (169), Haley (0) |
At the end of the primaries, the vote is confirmed at the party convention. | Republican Convention: Trump (2388), Haley (41) Democrat Convention: Biden withdrew on July 21. His support prior was 3905. A virtual nomination process took place to install Kamala Harris as candidate instead. She was then confirmed as candidate with 4567 delegates supporting in a ‘virtual roll call’. |