Set 1: Argument structure and finding the gap
Set 1: Argument structure and finding the gap
Front | Back |
|---|---|
What is an argument? | Evidence offered to support a conclusion. Identify what the author believes and why they believe it. |
What is a premise? | A statement offered as support. For argument-evaluation questions, accept the stated premises and examine whether they support the conclusion. |
What is the main conclusion? | The claim the author ultimately wants you to accept. Other statements support it; it does not merely support another conclusion. |
How do I distinguish a premise from a conclusion? | Ask: “Why should I believe this?” The answer gives the premise. The claim being supported is the conclusion. |
What is an intermediate conclusion? | A claim supported by evidence that then supports the main conclusion. It performs both roles. |
What does “because” usually introduce? | A premise. Example: “We should leave because traffic is getting worse.” Leaving is the conclusion; worsening traffic is the premise. |
What does “therefore” usually introduce? | A conclusion. Confirm the statement’s role instead of relying only on the indicator word. |
What is background information? | Context that helps explain the situation but does not necessarily support the conclusion. |
What is an opposing viewpoint? | A position the author presents to challenge or reject. Do not mistake it for the author’s own conclusion. |
What is an assumption? | An unstated claim the reasoning relies on. It connects the evidence to the conclusion or rules out a potential problem. |
What is the gap in an argument? | The step from the premises to the conclusion that has not been established. Ask: “What did the author need to show but leave unproven?” |
How can the premises be true while the conclusion is false? | An overlooked possibility may break the connection. Finding that possibility exposes the argument’s weakness. |
Example: “Maya studied more and scored higher, so studying more caused her improvement.” What is the gap? | The author has not ruled out other explanations: an easier test, tutoring, or better sleep. Both observations can be true without proving causation. |
What should I preserve when translating a stimulus? | Who or what is involved, the relationships between claims, quantities, certainty, conditions, and the conclusion. Simplify the wording without changing the logic. |
What should I predict before reading the answers? | The kind of answer the question requires: a gap, missing link, supported inference, explanation, or description of the reasoning. Predict a function; exact wording is unnecessary. |