Set 1: Argument structure and finding the gap

Set 1: Argument structure and finding the gap

Front

Back

What is an argument?

Evidence offered to support a conclusion. Identify what the author believes and why they believe it.

What is a premise?

A statement offered as support. For argument-evaluation questions, accept the stated premises and examine whether they support the conclusion.

What is the main conclusion?

The claim the author ultimately wants you to accept. Other statements support it; it does not merely support another conclusion.

How do I distinguish a premise from a conclusion?

Ask: “Why should I believe this?” The answer gives the premise. The claim being supported is the conclusion.

What is an intermediate conclusion?

A claim supported by evidence that then supports the main conclusion. It performs both roles.

What does “because” usually introduce?

A premise. Example: “We should leave because traffic is getting worse.” Leaving is the conclusion; worsening traffic is the premise.

What does “therefore” usually introduce?

A conclusion. Confirm the statement’s role instead of relying only on the indicator word.

What is background information?

Context that helps explain the situation but does not necessarily support the conclusion.

What is an opposing viewpoint?

A position the author presents to challenge or reject. Do not mistake it for the author’s own conclusion.

What is an assumption?

An unstated claim the reasoning relies on. It connects the evidence to the conclusion or rules out a potential problem.

What is the gap in an argument?

The step from the premises to the conclusion that has not been established. Ask: “What did the author need to show but leave unproven?”

How can the premises be true while the conclusion is false?

An overlooked possibility may break the connection. Finding that possibility exposes the argument’s weakness.

Example: “Maya studied more and scored higher, so studying more caused her improvement.” What is the gap?

The author has not ruled out other explanations: an easier test, tutoring, or better sleep. Both observations can be true without proving causation.

What should I preserve when translating a stimulus?

Who or what is involved, the relationships between claims, quantities, certainty, conditions, and the conclusion. Simplify the wording without changing the logic.

What should I predict before reading the answers?

The kind of answer the question requires: a gap, missing link, supported inference, explanation, or description of the reasoning. Predict a function; exact wording is unnecessary.