Who Ultimately Pays the Tax Doesn't Depend On the Relative Elasticities of Supply and Demand
What determines how the burden of the tax is shared between buyers and sellers?
wedge shortcut: the most important effect of a tax is to drive a tax wedge between the price paid by buyers and the price received by sellers
Instead of shifting curves, start with a tax of $1 and “push” the vertical “tax wedge” into the diagram until the top of the wedge just touches the supply curve
The top of the wedge gives the price paid by the buyers, and the bottom of the wedge gives the price received by sellers, and the quantity at which the wedge “sticks” is the number on the x-axis
Using the wedge shortcut, shows whether buyers or sellers pay a tax is determined by relative elasticities of demand and supply
Elasticity of demand measures how responsive the quantity demanded is to a change in price and the elasticity of supply measures how responsive quantity supplied is to a change in price
When demand is more elastic than supply, demanders pay less of the tax than sellers
When supply is more elastic than demand, suppliers pay less of the tax than buyers
An elastic demand curve means that demanders have a lot of substitutes and you can’t tax someone that has a good substitute because they’ll just buy the substitute
When demand is elastic, sellers will just end up paying most of the tax
An elastic supply curve means that the workers and capital in the industry can easily find work in another industry
If you try to tax an industry with an elastic supply curve, the industry inputs will escape to other industries
Elasticity = escape
Whether buyers or sellers pay more depends on who can escape the best (which curve is more elastic)
What determines how the burden of the tax is shared between buyers and sellers?
wedge shortcut: the most important effect of a tax is to drive a tax wedge between the price paid by buyers and the price received by sellers
Instead of shifting curves, start with a tax of $1 and “push” the vertical “tax wedge” into the diagram until the top of the wedge just touches the supply curve
The top of the wedge gives the price paid by the buyers, and the bottom of the wedge gives the price received by sellers, and the quantity at which the wedge “sticks” is the number on the x-axis
Using the wedge shortcut, shows whether buyers or sellers pay a tax is determined by relative elasticities of demand and supply
Elasticity of demand measures how responsive the quantity demanded is to a change in price and the elasticity of supply measures how responsive quantity supplied is to a change in price
When demand is more elastic than supply, demanders pay less of the tax than sellers
When supply is more elastic than demand, suppliers pay less of the tax than buyers
An elastic demand curve means that demanders have a lot of substitutes and you can’t tax someone that has a good substitute because they’ll just buy the substitute
When demand is elastic, sellers will just end up paying most of the tax
An elastic supply curve means that the workers and capital in the industry can easily find work in another industry
If you try to tax an industry with an elastic supply curve, the industry inputs will escape to other industries
Elasticity = escape
Whether buyers or sellers pay more depends on who can escape the best (which curve is more elastic)